The Archive · 1887

The Indian Civil Service

Tue Covenanted Civil Service of India has been called by its friends and supporters, Sir Richard Temple says, the finest service of its kind in the world. Tt has produced a splendid array of statesmen and administrators of which England is justly proud. It consists, in Sir Richard Temple's words, of a highly trained and organised body of Brit gentlemen, who are appointed in England under covenant, with certain conditions of serving the State during the best years of life, and to whom the chief offices in the civil administration of the country are secured by law. Formerly these appointments were obtained by patronage, but since 1854 they have been open to public competition, and this change has produced no marked effect in India. "The service was excellent before; it is still excellent." But the change has been favourable to England by abolishing the large amount of patronage. This may be perfectly true, but on the other hand the old patronage system maintained 'a succession of very able men whose natural abilities and statesmanship established and strengthened the British power in India, in difficult times and in ways in which the Competition Wallah has not yet been_ tested. Any student in the United Kingdom who can surpass all others can now gain entrance into the service. A native of India can compete for these appointments if he chooses to go to land. There is also the Uncovenanted Civil Service into which-a lange number of natives have been introduced, and they now fill many of the superior posts, while the lesser posts and the clerkships in the administration are almost all filled by them, The hope of attaining some of the best prizes in the public service has been held out to the natives, by the appointment of some of them to high offices and, in pursuance of this policy, arrangements have been male for appointing a limited number of natives, particularly chosen in India, to the Covenanted Civil Service.

Mr. John Bright has lately been addressing the East India Association on the Indian Civil Service. Before he spoke, a paper was read to the meeting on the subject of the further admission of natives of India to the Civil Service, in which it was laid down that a purely competitive system of selection was undesirable owing to the peculiar social condition of the country. It would be a singular thing if this view should obtain general support in England, where all privilege in this service has been abolished, and it bits one the difficulties with which Englishmen have to do in India, where old customs and prejudices demand respect from us with more or less force.. Mr. Bright has Jong taken an active, if not always an intelligent, interest in Indian affairs. In this speech he tells how in 1853 Sir Charles Wood, then President of the Board of Control—the Indian Office of the time—spoke from five o'clock in the afternoon until ten o'clock at night in eulogy of the East India Company, and how he, Mr. Bright, spoke for two hours in reply. "I thought then, as I think now," Mr. Bright says, "that I had very much the best of the argument," and we may be sure that as far as speaking went he was victorious, for Sir Charles Wood had, as Mr. Grant Duff said in the House, been denied by Providence the gift of articulate utterance. Mr. Bright in his recent speech was modest and moderate compared to his former self, and confessed that he rather rizzled about the manner in which a further and considerable admission of natives to the Civil Service should be made. Their admission rests on the Charter of 1833 and upon the Queen's Proclamation after the Mutiny. Lord Macaulay had said that their admission to high offices should be by slow degrees, but Mr. Bright is of opi that if Lord Macaulay were to return to the earth he would think that our rate of progress in this respect had been too slow, and would condemn it as much as the speaker did. But Mr. Bright confessed that if he had the matter to settle he should be very much puzzled what to do in the conditions of India became you could not ay, for example, in Tudia should take offices to the that a given percentage of the population

same extent that Englishmen there do, for with the enormous population of 200,000,090, it is quite obvious that the natives of India would have the whole of the offices in their own hands, and no friend of India would say that the great bulk of the 200,000,000 are qualified by education, experience, or independence of character to undertake the offices." He would leave it rather to public opinion in England which was animated by the most friendly spirit to India, and is open to any teaching which may come to it on this subject; and the English people are anxious that the government of India should be a wise government. Now, he said in almost, as many words, a wise government will take care to extend from time to time the admission of natives to the service. And, jof what England had already done to extend to India some of the privileges which her people enjoy at home, such as a free press and the right of public meeting, Mr, Bright said: "itis a wonderful thing for a despotic government"—English rule in India is not despotic, but we can understand what Mr. Bright meant by the word—' to allow the people it governs the privileges and practices of free nations." There is probably no appreciable difference in Mr. Bright's views on Indian ques-now, and those of the ordinary moderate-minded Englishman.—_Between his attitude and that of men of extreme views, the men, like Lord Ripon, who are in a hurry, there is the greatest, difference, and if the wise men whom England sends to govern India are left alone, if they are not impelled to hasty legislation, natives of India will receive their share in the government of their country, and the service will not suffer. How gradual the change must be may be inferred from a recent statement by Sir Henry Maine, that it is impossible, on the most liberal assumption, to reckon the proportion of persons in India who are sufficiently educated to take an interest or part in politics to the rest of the population at more than 1 in 10,000. Further, the Zimes says that the total number of graduates in Indian Universities during the twenty years preceding 1883 did not amount to 5,000, while it is impossible to reckon the mumber of educated natives of all classes at more than 25,000, which is perhaps considerably above the mark.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account