The Archive · 1887

"TASMANIA."

Tne judgment of the Wreck Commissioner on the loss of the Peninsular and Oriental Company's steamer Tasmania is severe upon nearly all who were connected with the unfortunate vessel. It will be somewhat difficult for the Chairman of the Company to prove to the satisfaction of the public that the ship was sufficiently officered and properly navigated. For the Commissioner considered that for a vessel of the size and speed of the Zasmania there should have been provision for two officers always to have been on the watch, and the Assessors were of opinion that with one officer more the ship would have had an ample and sufficient crew. This deliverance will no doubt have the proper effect with the Directors of the Company, and probably with those of other lines trading to the East. We are not sure that any blame attaches to the Company, because the Tasmania is held to have been under-officered, as the Wreck Commissioner does not say that she had not the number required by the Act of Parliament, but merely gives his opinion and that of the Assessors. And we do not think that the Company can be censured for the shameful misconduct of the second officer and others. The Chairman stated in his speech to the shareholders a few months ago that all the officers on board the Tasmania were experienced men, several of them holding master's certificates, so that he {and his colleagues had done all that they could to place their ship and the safety of her passengers in good hands, That one of the officers proved himself, when the time of trial came, to be r: and heedless of the safety of the vessel j was a misfortune that could scarcely have been provided against. It does not appear from the judement or from the evidence taken in the course of the enquiry, which we have seen, that this officer had previously shown incompetence or recklessness or did not possess the full confidence of the captain.

The captain had erred in putting the ship on a course that was perfectly inexplicable to the Court, it was an improper and unsafe one, the second officer carried the mistake further by not ascertaining and verifying the position of the ship although there was 2 fresh wind and strong sea. The second officer was not on the bridge while the Tasmania was rushing on destruction, "and," the Commissioner says, "if he was on deck he did not see Cape Feno light and could not have kept a proper look-out." The case for the second officer and the other officers was ably argued by their counsel, who endeavoured to prove that the cause of the disaster was the abnormal set of the current which preceded instead of following the wind and set the ship a mile and a half out of her course, which the Commissioner deals with by saying: That in the opinion of the Court the cause of the disaster was that when the current and breeze took her to the leeward of her course, no proper steps were taken to ascertain and verify her position, and more improper and tnseamanlike conduct the Court had seldom seen. The censure passed on the state of affairs on board after the disaster, and on shore, is not too severe: no one, except the chief officer, connect= ed with the ship comes out of the enquiry with credit; some blundered, others behaved with a callousness which we hope has rarely been shown by English sailors. Many of the male passengers refused to lend a hand and otherwise conducted themselves in a shameful way. The whole story of the wreck is one that we would wish to forget.

It will be seen that the Court was of opinion that Lascars are almost a neces sity in tropical climates and the Red Sea, allowing one Lascar and a half to be the equivalent of a European, We are not inclined to believe in the necessity for employing Lascars on board steamers trading to the East. At least one line betwen Europe and China has no Lascar seamen, and it is not understood to be an extravagantly managed company. This shows that. it is not almost a necessity to employ Lascars, and the certificate, so to speak, of their general utility and trustworthiness under any circumstances at which the Assessors in this case give, will not remove the want of confidence which the general public feels in them. We should therefore anticipate that the P. & 0, Company and other lines in which Lascars are largely employed will reconsider the policy of retaining them, at all events im such numbers. The Tasmania had a crew of 160 men of whom 55 were Europeans, which included we presume engineers, stewards, and others not usually included with the crew, which landsman at least suppose to be wholly composed of sailors. And though we remember that the Chairman of the Company stated that Lascars were more trustworthy than Europeans, who frequently misconducted themselves on the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account