The Archive · 1887

Miscellaneous Articles

ENGLAND IN THE MEDITERRANEAN

One result of the Naval manceuvres in the English Channel may be to bring to the fore the advisability of retaining Gibraltar, Malta and Cyprus. 'The' "capture of Falmouth," has it is said shown that such places of arms are of Tittle use under the changed conditions of warfare. Sir Henry W. Gordon, brother of General Gordon, has published a memorandum drawn up by the latter in 1881, in which he seeks to show that we ought to get out of the Mediterranean altogether. Modern warfare, he begins by saying, "has completely changed the strategical advantage of positions around dockyards or arsenals it has obliged the defence to occupy pon miles further off than those hitherto considered necessary. In the same way modern warfare has affected Malta and Constantinople, diminishing their value with regard to the trade routes of the world. Gibraltar and the Skager Rack are now the Constantinoples or keys to the issues of the Russian,

fleets in the south, and to the German Austrian, Italian, and, partially, French and Russian fleets in the north (for Kiel is within the Skager Rack.) Say, "then, the Skager Rack, Gibraltar, and the Red Sea were plugged up by heavy British fleets, then Great Britain would only have to deal with the French, Spanish, and Portuguese coasts on the Channel or on the Atlantic. There would still be the United States and Russia in the Pacific to be looked after." But we possess the advantage of holding distant: strategical positions which modern warfare has rendered important, while at the same time the value of the Mediterranean has been diminishing, in the case of war. If a heavy fleet blocked the entrance to it, General Gordon could not see any advantage to be gained against us by the fleets: shut. in it. Me holding of the Red Sea and Cape routes by Great Britain would be preferable to holding the Mediterranean and the Canal with the inevitable sequent complications that would arise. These complications would come from the Canal and a portion of the land near it being French property, sold, the French consider, to them; its being in Bayptian territory and the effect which the scuttling ofa ship in the canal would have upon on position when we were at war.

alto has, be considered, lost much of its importance: the Mediterranean now differs much from the Meditermmean of 1815; other nations have great dockyards on its shores backed by united peoples, and steam has brought every nation in Europe close to the Mediterranean.

involves no complications and should The alternative route by the Cape receive our: first consideration, as a commercial nation dependent on our trade, in which we are most vulnerable in war time, and to guard this trade should be the main object with us, He proceeds to say: "Looking at the chart of the world and considering that if the following places, Gibraltar, Bermuda, Ascension, St. Helena, Aden, Ceylon, Seychelles, Chagas, Mauri tins, Simon's Bay, St. Paul, the Fall land Islands, Hongkong, Borneo, New Zealand, and Vancouver Island, were held as' lairs or dens, as coaling stations for our vessels, what chance would any maritime enemy have of crippling us by destroying our trade? Look at the Mediterranean and see how small is that sea upon which we are apparently devoting the greater part of our attention. No diplomatic complications can attend the organisation of the stations named. By this means we should unite all our colonies with us, for we could give them our support effectively." India should be defended from a Russian advance by raising the tribes near the Persian Gulf, supplying them with money, arms ete. a few adventurous officers, and leading them on the Russian flank. Cor further East in his survey of the world's defensive points, General Gordon says that Hongkong, owing to China possessing islands in her harbour, cannot be defended; and that when the Sultan of Brunei (Borneo) dies we ought occupy the country, he has no heirs, and then, with one flank on Vancouver Island and the other in Borneo, we could make front the Russian place darmes, Vladivostock, to which place her Black Sea establishments have been moved. Russia has an eye for support at Vladivostock from San Francisco; she hopes, in time of war, to embroil us with the United States. The memorandum does not appear to have attracted much attention at home, probably because people are not yet ripe for considering the hey of surrendering Malta in cold ood. And it may be that a large number of persons who admire General Gordon's character do not extend that feeling to his political judgment; but few if any will not agree in what he urges in favour of the establishment and maintenance of coaling stations.

Sir Samuel Baker replies in a letter to the Times to the arguments in this memorandum. His experience of the Cape and the Canal routes to India would lead him to shun the former at any time and to secure the latter at all times. Both routes must be rendered secure by England, and rather than yield the protection of the Canal to another Power, or even abandon it to the chances and risks of Egyptian protection, he would make it a casus belli_and confront all adversaries. If we leave the Canal in the hands of the French, how could we retain Aden, which is only four days sail from Suez, which the holders of the Canal could make a base of operations Aden could be starved out. In his opinion Britain must possess an unbroken line of coaling stations along the great commercial highway to the East, and these must be adequately fortified. With the Mediterranean, Ezypt, and the Red Sea dominated by another Power, thes? coaling stations could not be held, and they are of virtual necessity to a m: time nation, Sir Samuel Baker is thoroughly opposed to the policy of giving any place which we hold muder press tire from other Powers, as "there can be little doubt that a nation which has become great through the force of arms can never safely retreat from strategical positions—which would" assuredly be occupied by the enemy—without a loss of reputation to be followed by contempt." In that we hope he represents the national determination and spirit.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account