The Archive · 1890

"THE LIGHT OF ASIA" OR "THE LIGHTS OF ASIA"?

"In the historical narrative" (soys Sir Menier Williams) "there are, I think, only two points which bear any resemblance to anything in the life of Christ. The firet is the visit of the old sage, who after the birth of Gautama predicted that he would be a Buddha, and rejoiced to have seen him. But when it is considered that there is nothing here of carrying the child to the temple to be presented, no reference to the mother (such as is falsely introduced into The Light of Asia), and that it is common custom after child is born in India to get sage to see him and pronounce his horoscope, it is difficult to see more than a slightly interesting coincidence. The ethos is the so-called temptation of Buddha by Mara. Now Marais rather the opponent than the tempter. He did not try, according to the early records, to lead Gautama into sin, so much as to stop his career. And that while the celestial beings were entreating Gautama to become the Buddha or to preach hie discovery, Mara should try to prevent him, was an inevitable element in the story.. Other apparent instances are fictitious. This is the case with many things in The Light of Asia... I take up Professor Rhys, Davide's 'Manual. of Budihism. On "Parable of the 8,199 T age thy heading usterd Seed." That is no parable, in the 8 in which our Lord' Was a parable, and it is about mustard drug and not as a seed, and the aim is to shew the certainty of death. On the next page is the Parable of the Sower," which has nothing to do with preaching or hear+ ing, and so on of other pretended resemblances shown to be equally far-fetched imaginary. Where there are any actua} sem blances they are found in more recent Buddhist books. "Likenesses to Christianity," Bp. Coplestone says," there are, and most touching ones; but they are generally im the expression of man's weakness and need, not in the method of meeting them." Professor Rhys Davids himself quotes M. E. de Bunsen's Zhe Angel Messiah where he says, 'I can find no evidence whatever of any actual and direct communication of any of those ideas from the East to zo West." (Fortnightly Review, div., p. 101.

On the other hand Brahma and Buddhism shew evident borrowings from Christianity.

Dr. Edkins tells us that Buddhism began to spread in China only in the 4th century of our era. None of the Buddhist books in which anal gie to Christian teaching or tactices can be traced, can be shown to older than the Gth century of our era and Mgr. Laouenan shows' that in all instances where any such analogies or likenesses can be supposed to exist, the original idea is to be found, not in Brahmanism or Buddhism, but in Christianity. The Trimurti, or Hindu Trinity, appears for the first time in Indian theogony about the 12th century (Laouenan, vol. 1, p. 7); the Brahma-Sastr dates no farther back than the 13th century (p. 14); the caves of Elephanta near Bombay, the sculptures in which represent scenes of the Creation, are not older than the 10th century of our era (p, 16). Of the Skanda Purana the oldest portions appeared just anterior to the age of Mohammed of Gazni—997 to 1030 A.D. The Prem Sagar relates at length the birth, the early sports, and adventures of Krishna, and was written about the 12th century (p. 61). The horosco} of Krishna, cast by the astrologers at the time of birth, has been found to belong to the 7th century (p. 62). The Bhavagad-Ghita was written about the 10th.or 12th century. The Mahabarata, of which it forms an episode, describes among N.C. Herald of 7th March.

Seo N..0. D. WU. of 28th February, and

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account