The Archive · 1888

The Germans and Their Minister

Tne general mercantile community of Shanghai will, we should imagine, read with considerable surprise the account which appears in another column of the proceedings at the German Consulate-Veneral on Saturday afternoon. Germans must be accustomed to very cavalier treatment at the hands of their officials, if the recent despatch from their Minister to the Committee of the General Chamber of Commerce here, on the subject of the Telegraph Convention, did not arouse in them any feelings of resentment. It was somewhat severely criticised in our columns, as it deserved and this criticism the German community here, with almost perfect unanimity, makes an occasion for kissing the rod, and assuring Mr. von Brandt that his ill-mannered letter is really a proof of his energy, amiability and kindness, and his strong desire to further German commerce. If the Germans here really like to receive a rebuff of that kind from their Minister, we do not grade them their pleasure but we cannot help thinking that the address which we presume is now on its way to Peking, is a most unfortunate one. The solidarity of the commercial community in Shanghai has hitherto been perfect. In their trade, in their amusements, in their whole life in fact in the Far East, Germans and English have hitherto met on an equal footing they have competed with each other, as friends may do, but there has never been any international jealousy between them. Germans and English have sat side by side on the of every public institution from the Municipal Council down; the very Committee of the Chamber of Commerce, which was recently addressed with such uncalled-for rudeness by Mr. vou Brandt, has German members on it, It must therefore be conceded that the particularist tone which pervades. the address in question is most lamentable. If the German community here think that Mr. von Brandt will be gratified by their kissing the hand that has just chastised them, that the presence of this address in his pocket will add to Mr. von Brandt's enjoyment of the well-eared leave which he is about to take, they are quite right to assure him, in the most fulsome terms of which their language is capable, of their love and iration; but it seems worse than ill-advised to make that address the vehicle for a display of their jealousy of their English fellow-residents. They might remember that every privilege they enjoy in China, the very existence even of their trade, they owe to Buglaud, whose magnanimity in throwing open to all the world, Germans included, every commercial advantage gained in any part of the world, deserves a better requital. But for their exertions, and the vast exnditure of their men and money by Bugland and France, there would be no German Minister in Peking; and it is by the presence of a large British syuadron in Chinese waters that their privileges are secured to our German fellow-residents. Prince Bismarck would not waste the bones of a single Pomeranian to secure German trade in China, The harmony that Sir Frederick Bruce fostered between the foreign representatives at Peking has been unfortunately allowed by his successors to disappear, and we are sorry to see the German community here recognising with gratitude how thoroughly Mr. von Brandt fights for his own hand at Peking. The anomalous position of doyen that Mr. von Brandt holds—anomalous, because a doyen is out of place where the Ministers are not allowed to communicate directly with the Chief of the State to which they are accredited,—should never be held by one who works so exclusively for the benefit of his own countrymen as the German minister is praised by his countrymen for doing; but this is not so disheartening for us in Shanghai, as that our German fellow residents should subscribe almost unanimously to an address, which asserts almost in so many words that they recognise themselves as an element quite apart from the rest of the foreign community.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account