The Archive · 1883

RECENT UNTERANOES ON CHINESE 'MATTERS

Toro gentlemen of experience in Chinese affairs have lately given their views on them to the New York Herald. Goveral Gordon, in a letter dated from Jaffa, rambles over many subjects about some of which he evidently knows very little. Ho abuses the foreign residents roundly, saying that they may be written down as identical with those in Egypt in all affairs. "Their sole iden is, without distinction of nationality, an incrossing power over China for their own trade and for the opening up of the country as they call it; and any war will be popular with them, so that they will egg on any power to make it." My idea la that no colonial or foreign community in a foreign land oan properly and for the general benefit of the world consider the questions of that foreign state. The leading iden is how they will benefit themselves. The Isle of Bourbon, or Reunion, is the cause of the Madagascar war. It is ogged on (aic) by the planters there, snd to my idea the planters want slaves from Madagascar. I have very mean opinion of the views of any solovial or foreign community, though Town they are powerfal for evil. Who would dare to oppose the European colony in Egypt or Chins and remain in these couutcies P" These are pretty tint accusations against foreigners in China; but we do not think they are merited by any action or ox-pression of opinion on the part of Europeans or Americans in this oonntry. The intoresta of foreigners in China are bound up with a peaceful policy. Exoopt the insignificant few who trade in arms, all residents hero and at the other Treaty Ports would be losers in the event of war breaking out, Trade would be diminished and isorganized, and the subjects or citizens of the nation whioh was at war with China would either see their commerce altogether suppressed, or pass into the hands of other people. It goos without ing that the interests of all mercantile men are identified with peace, but General Gordon has evolved a peculiar race of traders from the depths of his inner consciousness. It is not unlikely that the bulk of the Buropean adventurers who preyed on Egypt wore of a class such as he has Gesoribed. But there are none, or very fow, of these unscrupulous people in the foreign command in Ohina, There is scarcely. any occupation for them nowadays; and the General had probably present in his mind the hordes of foreigners who swarmed to Ohina in the time of the Taiping rebellion, These men could not live now. The foreigner at the ports is quiet going man who wants peace above all things, and seldom troubles himself about political questions. General Gordon has so weakened the esteem in which his character and abilities were held, by his uncautious use of wild language, that a great many people have ceased to care what he writes or says, His last letter, to which we are uow referring, will increase the number of these; but there are many who will regret that the General has not a friend at his elbow who could prevent his singular and inconsiderate performances on paper.

The other gentleman who has contributed his opinions on current events in China is Commodore Sbufeldt, He talks in a very different style from that of General Gordon, He hae his fling at European nations in their dealings with Chins, accusing them of pursuing a dictatorial policy. Many people, on the contrary, think that there has generally been a want of firmness in the diplomatic dealings of western nations with the Court and Cabinet of Peking. The English Ministers have often been acoused by their ustionals of taking too Chinese a view of such matters as came into dispute between them and the Tsung-li Yamen, As the Correspondent of the Zimes, portion of whose letter we published yestoraay, said, "they have one and all succumbed to the curious delusion that on their pair of shoulders rested the onus of conserving the Chiner empire." Commodore Shufeldt live for a longer time in the China of the present days than General Gordon did, and his more accurate knowledge of the constitution of the foreign communities, and their opinions, no doubt prevented him from falling into serious mistakes about us, He sees clearly Iso the trae position which we oooupy here, and the necessity for the maire tenance of a naval force at the ports sufficient to protect the lives and prorty of foreigners.

He says traly that those only who have lived in China, perhaps, will realize the uncon. trollable character of a Chi mob.

On such occasions the authori not only ignored, but if need be are crushed." Commodore Shufeldt's remarks on the sdvautages to foreign uationsof being well represented by ships of war in China are excellent. Not only does their presence inspirit foreigners in troublous times, but there is no doubt they have a good effect on the native rulers. A ship of war is a reminder to a mandarin of the power which may be exerted by the nation to which it belongs, to right the injuries that may be inflicted on its subjects or citizens. As such our corvettes and gunboats have often been useful and will no doubt be so again.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account