The Archive · 1887

Benjamin David Benjamin

Me. Larma instructed by Mr, Henry Stead, Attorn: official liqui appoated for the plaintiff.

Hie. Wantswaiour for the defends Cowusel for the plaiutif read the plad-ings which were s follow The Petition sheweth as follows Company registered the Kuglish Companies Act of 1862, of liquidation, and Jam Official Liquidator of and carrying on business—On the 7th December 1880 the plai bank by the then Official Liquidators thereof obtained " judgment of the High Court of Tadicature at Bombay against the Defendant, whereby the Defendant was ordered to pay to the said Bank the sum of Rupees 24, for debt end interest and further simple interest at the rate of 5 per cent. per aunum upon the amount of the said judgment from the date of the said judgment until payment, '4—Aud as an alternative ground of claim the Plaintiff Bank, by its said Liquidator, says that in the year 1866 the said Bank was ordered to be wound up by the Court of Chancery in Bugland and that the Defendant was then a holder of 200 shares in the said Bank and that he was by the said Court daly settled on the list of contributories as the holder of the eaid shares, and that he was adjudged to pay to the said Bank la Tiquidation the eum of 1,600 pounds sterling, la respect of the said shares. The jadgmont of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay referred to in the preceding paragraph hereof was founded on the Defendant's debt to the said Bavk by reason of the facts hereinbefore referred to.

5.—The said sum of Rupees 24,090} has not, nor has apy part thereof, been paid to Plaintiff Bank or to the assid Official Coo now entitled to with interest according to the 7 jaheete the said sum of Rey 00013 -—Tho said sum of Rupses 2409032 is equivalent to Shanghai Taels 7,696.74 and the interest thereon for six yeara expiring on the 7th day of December 1886 amounts to Shang. uni Taels 2,309.00 making together the sum of Shanghai Taels 10,005.74.

Tue Plaintiff therefore prays the Defendant may be decreed to pay the said James Cooper as such official Liquidator as aforesaid the aald aum of Shang: hai Tsels 10,005.74 with the aunts of this suit, (2) Tunt the Plaintiff may have euch other or further relief as the nature of the case may require, The answer of the defendant was se follows i—

1,—The defendant has no knowledge as to the truth of the statements contained in the Ist paragraph of the Petition and loaves same to be proved,.

The defoudaut admire the statement the Qud paragraph of the petition, uudant denies the trath of ea:

4th and Sth paragraphs of the 4 With eferonse to th a un of Rupess 24,090} 3 mentioned in the said paragraph or any pact thereof. the petition registered as the holder of shares in the said bank it was when he was an infant und and (4) that if any pr y, and judgment obtained in the High' Court of Judicature at Bombay, as mentioned or id, (6) that taken and any ious wade proceed High Court and (7) that the pi tiffs claim so far a it rate upon the ground of claim mentioned or referred to li Statue of Liwitatious, Chapter 42 of the jarageaph of the petition iv hi and 4th years of King William the 4th, by the fact that no notice was given to the defendant of any appointment to a lat of contributories mentioned in the said Ath paragraph Dr, Laruax said his Lordship would that the statement of claim relied upon judgment of the High Court of Bombuy for 24,000 rupees; on the alternative claim 5 or the facts and merits of the case, on which that judgment was obtained. The defeudaut according to the mode tu system pleaded toveral pleas, some of which were not admissible pleas d would be demur-table on that part of the claim which rested upon the judgment of the High Courts and the same pleas which he ssid were inadmissible in the firet, were admissible in the latter portion, There were other claims which he held would he inadimi should how the 0 on the judgment should separated in any way which The first defence jer took tha shares, and that he was an infant, was very well settled law that a, foreign judgment was conclusive us to merits and facts and law. If his Lordship wished he, (Counsel) would produce authorities in proof of this,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account