The Archive · 1887

[23 LI. C.C. 8601

Thacker v. Harv He thought that the defendants suggestion that shares should be differently treated in Hongkong and Shanghai, from shares i London and New York, and re wares and merch that they can now His Honovr—The question is whether the forbearance did nut rescind the cou-tract.

Mr. Warnewnraur urged th did not. The contract was there in writ Regulation as to Li msnce to run till the day arrived on which Me, Robinson could pay, and that was not ill'the day of his death Judgment was reser 8th Feb.

His Hoxovr in giving judgment said The petition in this cause alleges that on or about the 21st of March, 1883,. the Inintiffs through Mesiours Chater and ernon, of Victoria in the Colony of Hongkong, Stock and Share brokers, contracted with the said Samuel Dealy Robinson to sell to hin for de 1 the Bist day of July then next Gfty shares in the Luzon Sugur Refiving Company Limited at or for the price or sum of $5,400; and that on or about the 23rd day of April, 1883, the plaiutifi, through the said MessioursChater and Vernon, contracted with the said Robinaon to aul to him fur delivery on the Bist day of Auguat then next " further one hundred shares in the eaid Company at or for the price or sui of $10,100. When the 31st-of July cine, Robinson did tact for th hundred find not matured) and alai sum of $3,050, alleging that sum to be the difference between the agreed price of the ssid shares on the Slat day of July, 1883. Robiuson's reply to suidlotter dated August 20th, 1883, was introduced' by plaintiffs together with a declaration of Vernon the id a declaration made by the plain-i introduced by the defendant who, for-lack of means of the estate to employ counsel, defend: himself. "He relied on theo legal positions. Jst—That the contract was void under the Statute of Frauds.

Statute of 8 and 9 Victoria, wagers by way of stock trausactioug, it was an illegal contract, and plaintiffs should barred by the Statute of Limitations. Hongkong being the place, of contract and performance thereof, the contract under established rales of construction, is to be construed by the law there. of force, Shares in joint stock conipanies do not by the law in force xt Hongkong, " Britiah thin the Statute of Frauds.

Benjamin on Sales Sec U1.) This de: fence is overruled. As to the contract being legal under 8 and 9 Victor, is depends Wa shares should be bought and sold, but as a wager? The only evidence adduced of the Broker and the Plaintiffs there is nothing to show that there was not to be x delivery of the shares on the completion of Robinson's pat of the contract. It was not a contract for differences, and hange not embraced under said Statute, vs. Hardy 42 B. D.' 685, Statute.)

The second defence is also ove: ruled. But when we come to the plex of th Statute of Li féxtions the case presents 83ed paragraph of our Regulations for Consular Qourts in China la as follows; "Civil actions based written promise contract of instrument mint be cvmmmonced with aix years al the cause of xetion accrues; others within two." What is this action based on? Is it on the parol contract made by the Brokers ffs und Robinson, or on the Mosely dated August Lith, 1883, that of Robinson dated August 20th, 18832 It appow to the Court unquestionably on the fon tious of the petition as damage 's won-performance bared on the amount claimed of defendant

of contracts of 21at March, 1883, and 23ed. April, 1883, and the letter of plainti ply " proposal to leave the matter open for Robinson to pry up by instalment as it takes two to On the contrary I cannot hold out any hopes with toga to the future,"

teu he doos add, if T should be lucky as to in my power to do anything in the matter, you can rely on my doing my utmost." *Té Roviuson had sented to the instalment proposition, and timated dates, when he would mn, that durin plaintiffs could not have sued him on his letter as contract between them, contended that now he being dead, pfui tiffs have a right on the letters to ovis uto Court and recover pro rata shar among intestate's other creditors. If his letter did not afford ground to one him on during his lifetime, the Ouurt fails to per-dying' gives, it, any more validity.

held fo 1 Administrator can only the contracts of and not his proposals," (Shipps 0. J 20 Penn, State Reports 708.) Rubin son propered to. pay if he got able, but did wot contract to do so. The Goui of opinion Unt the claim is based on parol contract there memorandum signed by Robi date of making the contracts, nur any promise in.writing to pay the amount claimed at any time; and the right of action having accrued more than two years before suit was brought the plea is sustained, forcibly argued by the loxrued Counsel for the plaintiffs that svotion 4086 of th Revised Statutes of the United States under which in conformity with section 4,083 the Minister and Consuls. placed

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account