The Archive · 1887

THE DEBATE ON THE TOTAL SBSTIURNOE MOVEMENT

Tae interest which the open. debate of the Literary and Debating Society on Wednesday night bad created among our publio was shown by the large audience which assembled in the Manic Hall. Part of this interest had probably been aroused by the series of Addresses which Mra, Leavitt recently delivered, but the monotony of the mental recreations which prevail here no doubt makes a large number of residents Whatever may have been the mol or temptations, they were sufficient almost to crowd the Masonic Hall with Indies and gentlemen, who closely followed the arguments of the various speakers, and from time to time apthe speeches own opinions, There is probably not much that is new to be said now either for or against Total Abstinence, really after all what all the had in their minds, and to which they devoted the greater part of their speeches, For, although the debate was to be upon the manner in which the oral Abstinence campaign is conducted in Europe and America, the restraints of the formal resolation were either altogether got rid of or wore worn very lightly, Th was probably expected, as even assemblies far more versed in the conduct of debate than the Literary and Debating Society, it is diffoult for the most practised apeakers to keep with which they in the House of Commons for instance either the House draws the attention of the Speaker to thedivagations of oratere, ortho Speaker elf interferes and brings the wan. dering orator back to subject matter, Ina purely Debating Soviety, especially in one where the ten minutes enforced, there is scarcely any necessity to commit to the Obairman the power of recalling speakers to the qa tion before the meeting. It is true that a good deal of wandering away from the matter ander debate into all manner of side issues and even into totally irrelevant subjects, or no particular subject at all, can be done in ten minutes by hardened ramblers, bat it is only in very bad cases that these excursions into space begin before the fics' half of that period has been exhausted. And even aban donment to the fatal facility of uttering mero. words is unlikely to assai speakers on such an occasion as that of Wednesday, when those who tended to speak doubtless prepared themselves beforehand, as every ora-for does. When this is not done, and there is no time rule, a determination of words to the head sometimes produces those exuberantly verbose speakers who exhaust time and encroach apou eternity." acters in the artificial comedy of the Restoration were a world of themselves and ould not be criticised by any of the canons which rule actual life, so thos part in the debates of the Literary and Debating not held respousiblefor the opinions they advocate. Criticism on their speeches would, therefore, bs eve!

than it usually publio with discriminating the art with which the orators play their parte, and even this very limited sphere is closed to the Press. But the subject of the debate is engaging so much attention here and elsewhere, that we may refer to the figures which were advanced in support of the necessity of Total Abstinence. They are part of the stock of the advocates of Total Abstinence and of Liquor Law men in every country, by whatever names they may call themselves. The largo expenditare on drink in Grent Amerion was used on Wednesday night in defence of those who carry on the agitation in favour of total abstinence. A thousand millions of dollars is a large sum to be on intoxicating liquors, and it is employed to support argu. mounts either for the necessity of suppressing the liquor trade or of po sonal total abstinence, nothing is said of the immense deduction whioh should be made from the amount, for wines, spit and beer that are used for medicinal purposes or by people who do not in any way exceed moderate enjoyment. OF course, we shall he told tint the present medical practice is to do away as far as possible with the aso of stimulants, but there are many cases in which they are till em. ployed, and a great number of old fashioned practitioners, probably still the majority, who adhere to the old tem. Deduoting the cost of the liquor used for medicinal purposes, and og a harmless pleasure by people of well regulated minds, who do not, astheSoote say, abuse the mercies, agood round sam will be taken off that formidable Euglish and American "drink bill" of which 80 much is said. Supposing the society for the reform of dress was to formulate the amount spent on their attire by the men and women of England and America, the most enthusiastic supporter of Liquor Laws would see the absurdity of the whole amount being said to be wasted; and would recognize necessity of stopping a good di short of total abstinence from cloth Every rational being knowstheevil whioh excessive drivking does in the world, and would gladly see the vice abated and help those who are engaged in promoting temperance. Bat reasonable people—mho are never enthusiasts, bat who are, after all, those who effect the permanent good in the world—turn away from those who make use of such statements as this we are referring to. It is highly improbable that their use had avy effect on the vote which was taken at the close ut the debate on Wednesday, but thole eniployment is very likely to deter many from giving consideration to temperance objects. Such an audience as that which pronounced aguinst the methods by which the Total Abe movement is now curried on was fai ly representative of the middle class, and if a vole of the same kind of people were to be taken in England or America the result would be the same.

THE EXPECTED VISIT OF PRINCE CH'ON, Tae visit of Prince Ch'an to the northes als is to be followed by his visiting the. southern porte, He has been requested to do ea by the Empress, and be will probably arrive here between this and midsummer, His inspection will include Shanghai and Foochow arsenals and fortifications, it not being his intention, at all eventa at present, to go further south than the latter port.. While here it is expected by the officials that he will make his head quarters at the Kiangnan Arsenal, and great preparations will have to be made for his entertainment and that of the large suite which will accompany him, We hope we are not mistaken in considering this request of the Em. press as marking a change in the light in which Shanghai has hitherto been looked at by the Official and Literate classes in China, The native oily being only a sion, las been of no repute with them; and although the visit of the Prince is one of daty, which might maleo it nvovssury for bim to go to places of even lower status than Shanghai, the fact of his coming here will have a good effect on the minds of the altar-conservative classes, especially in Peking, where our Settlement, and the City, have hitherto been held in something not very unlike contempt, Bat it is probable that nother and more practical result may arise from the visit of Prince Ch'an, The organisation of the New Board of Admiralty ceeding, and one question which yet soiled is where the Murq will be stationed. It is considered pro. bable that he will tuke in charge that portion of the navy and theconst defences which will be most couvevieutly and advantageously administered near one of Arsonals about this part of the Hmpire. In many ways Shanghai possesses advantages which Navking has not. It is nearer to the sea; has decke and every appliance of labour, and skill and has resources which in the case of an emergency could supplement the Kiang. nan Argoual, The Admiralty depart" ment here would be in close proximity to chants, agenta, and establishments with which it might have dealings, and some considerable benefit to it and its working might arise therefrom. Its employes of all grades would be in better position to learn or to keep paca with what is being done by foreiguera in their own professional way than they would be at Nanking, or indeed in

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account