The Archive · 1884

Shanghai Literary and Debating

SOCIETY

A meeting' of this Society was held in the Library of the N.-C. Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society on Thursday evening. Mr, Bright, President, occupied the chair, and the room was crowded.

Mr, Warsuwnicur rose to move "That the heary of Progressive Human Improvement is tenable." He said the expectations which had been fostered in minds of the public by the advert ments which had stared at them in the papers day after day, the paragraph and leaderettes, and some rat statements made by the Presiden ducing him to the meeting, made him feel that responsibilities were cast upon him which he was utterly unable adequately to support. he motion which he proposed might be considered not a very practical o but he thought it was one of deep interest to them all, and if the view which he would endeavour to support was the right one they rust feel that they had gained valuable possession, It must be something for human being to have made up his mind that the life of the race was not like that of a squirrel inn revolving cage—a series of efforts to yet up, followed by a constant going down, and that they had a part in an organisation which would in the course of nes continually ascend to higher and higher levels. The subject might be conveniently looked at from three poi of viow—the theological, the philoso and the historical, The three were intimately connected, and no doubt the considerations which applied to one would be found also applicable in many. ways to the others, He should not deal at any length with the theological aspect of the question Decause it was not very desirable in a public meeting, and it was altogether too mighty a subject to attempt to xeasp in an elementary ninnuer, -Buthe thought that no man who called himself a Christian, who believed in the divine government of a Supreme Being, could doubt that the human race was progressive. To deny that was to believe that the Creator whom he be-Tieved to be all powerful, all wise and all good had created man to wander for ever in a maze, in perplexity, in darkness, from which he was never to emerge, having nothing but gleams of light to the end of time, The leaders of religious thought whom the world most revered had uniformly pointed to the ides of human perfeotibility, and the injunoti perfect even as your Father in Heaven is perfect," showed thnt the greatest teacher taught that perfectibility was attainable, impressed upon his hearers the porsibility of their attaining it, Therefore from the theologi ut of view there Was no theory.con t with the Christian theory but that of human improvement. being possible 1g in fact the Jaw of human natu world, With regard to the philosophical view of the subject, he proposed to rely mainly on one of the ablest exponenta of the theory from his point of view, Mr. Herbert Spencer, who laid down the theory somewhat in this way, Ho Ixid down the proposition that all evil resulted from the nou-ndaptation of constitution to conditions, by which he meant that every kind of physical and -moral_ and mental evil results from the being f harmony with theeireumstan he or itis placed. The plant withers and dies when the soil or the alimato or the supply of nourishment deficient, When light or warmth or air taken away the plant censes to flourish and dies. All discases—senses of animals, disen traceable to the incompatibility of ciroumstances, All human suffering, mental and physical, is the result of our being in Aituntions which our system is not adapted to support or endure. MIN Svencer ssid, OR, ab ik te natoce oF the wenny Feferaliy (g cue generic cause—want of congruity between the faculties and their spheres of action." Phot was his first proposition. His sec was that ey tantly tends to appear. Che organisation of the plant, the animal and the man hag a tendency to assimilate itself to its circumstances, to accept its conditions and to triumph over them. Mr, Wainewright instanced cases of acclimatization of plants and i h man and his Lhey were assi generations to the circu hoh he was placed. Proceed they came to this proposition being is either unaltered by circumstances, or he becomes more and more fitted to them, or he becomes more and more unfitted, He must be one of these th things, It did not need any argument—was here on one's consciousness—thnt human being was not unaltered by circumtwnces, It was equally clear that he did not become more and more unlitted; axd therefore they were left with the third alteruative—that he becxme more and more fitted to them. Mr, Wainewright proceeded to quote at length from Herbert support of the theory that faculciroumatances did not allow fil while those which finally rod, and thus all im 1a. Development thus a logical certainty. Humanity must in the end become completely adapted to its conditions, and civilisation, instead of being artificial, was a part of nature. 'That was the philosophical view of the subject. 'Turning to the historical view they would find, o looking over the history of the world, that the theory was fully' supported. waa no doubt that in times past had attained toa hich degree of tion and in the course of revolving their progress had been arrested parently their degradation had arrived but looking over the whole field of history he th xy would these down they might call them ao, than the onward progress—the retreating wave was very much aller than the wave which had advanced. He attributed this to the vital force which had gradually transformed nature—the growth of liberty, the greater perfuction of it and its wider di In early times the individual was uppermost but now, in the words of a ker, individuals were only powerful for as they were the exponents of the wishes ud aspirations of large bodies of men, 6 was no doubt at all that the number of free men now in the world wan vastly greater than it was ten centuries or tiv centuries, or ey century, ay the mere and sino, powers, had plac pre and the Jed them to believe that greater gulf would be bridged over in the future. knew there were nations which had relapsed into barbarism; but if they looked Ab the atate of some of those nation, now—Italy for iustance—they would find that it was better than before the r Looking at the question from theological, the philosophical or the hi torical point of view, they were equally led to the inevitable conclusion that the human race had improved; and if it was progressing it could only be that in course of time it would progress to perfection. (Applause.)

Dr. Jast1Eson then rose te oppose resolution. He said he would not attempt to follow the leader of the debate through the theological portion of his argument, as he did not feel competent to deal with it. In order to make the debate intelligible it waa necessary tu come toa dit standing as to what was meant by theory, Be thought the assertion wh was substantively made by the opener wag thie—that the time would necessarily coma when man's internal relations would be in perfect harmony with hia external relations; and the assertion came to this—that there was a gro' jenicy on the part of the human race individually and collectively to sacrifice ite own interests to the interests of others. 'The question became one of development, and they naturally looked, as the' opener had done, to the theory of natural selection—the theory—for an answer. If por-was to be attained, it must be from the material, intellectual and moral di velopment of the race and individual But of late years they had come to know that all such advances must have as a necessary antecedent some development in the structure of the brain, and unfortunately although they had learnt a great deal of late about the relations of the brain and different parts to the motorial funicti in some respects to the intellectual functions, they had no such certain rules as to enable them to tell in what direction brain development must advance in order to have that moral and intellectual advance which wasan absolute necessity tothe theory advanced by the opener. 'That was the firat difficulty in the way of the ncceptation of thie theory. It might not be absolutely opposed to the theory, but it Ww gent objection, he thought,' to the possibility of their determining whether the theory was true OF not, or at all events to their determin: ing it in an affirmative sense, But passing that over, evolution was necessary to the perfection of the human race, and evolu. tion was effected by moans of selection which must be either natural or artificial selection. That was only to be effected by murringe, and they all knew that artificial selection was quite contrary to the emotions and prejudices of cultivated people, The Platonic notion of an idyllic republic in which only the fairest and strongest and wisest were to he allowed to well was.an impossible dream. Young hearts would not be content to wait upon the decisions of drowsy old philosophers before deciding whether to marry or Natural selection was therefore the alternative, and he supposed no doctrine had even been a0 thoroughly misunder-otood and misrepresented us that doctrine Clergymen were, he was sorry to say, the tuffeuders in this respect. The theory opposed to lay it down that nan wag Jed from an ape; it did Phon they were told that it he true because if it were, auch peculiarities as the amull feot of Chine woman and various other bodily defer tien which were artificially produced would bw inherited. Not only was the absence ch inheritance not opposed ty natural but if such ti that would be the strongest nyainat the doctrine of natural People almost invariably opponent had done ao if_ evolution necessarily implied progress, Now it did nothing of the kind; in many euges it led degradation, To put the matter in a cons crete form he would take this as n propos tion—that neither moral nor intellectual development was a rule without an excep:

n example hie instanced the en in Ceylon, who wore oe-heirs with ourselves in the magnificent Aryan civilisae tion, but who hnd fallen to a state of the most degraded savagery, fe also instanced the Fellahs of Egypt, and other ra He thought we could hardly plume on: the superiors of the Ancient He next gave instances of d generation among the lower animals, as the cases of parasites and certain species of lizards. With regard to intellectual velopment, there was now the same fanas im—though not so wide spread, because the feeling of educated people was against it—the sume ignorance, thesame opposite to the expression of free thought, asin old deys, Choy had miracles cropping up

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account