The Archive · 1890

Naval Court of Enquiry

THE LOSS OF THE ' POOCHING."

On Monday a Naval Court of Enquiry into the circumstances attending the loss of the British steamship Puoching, while on a voyage from Sharghai to Hankow, was opened at H.B.M.'s Consulate-General by Lieut, E. G. Shortland, R.N., (of H.M.S. Hyacinth), President, Mr. G.'M. H. Playfair, (H.M.'s Vice-Consul) and Captain W.' J. Nantes, (master of the British steamer Maha). After the usual formalities the first witness called was—Enxest Onnistianses, who deposed in answer to the President—I was first mate of the Paochiny. We left Shanghai at 1.35 a.m. on May 29th. Capt. E. W. Place was in command. As nearly as can tell, the fire broke out st a quarter to six. Iwas in bed at the time. The fire was first discovered in the tween decks, forward. Iam not aware of the cause of the fire. I do not know what part was first ignited. When I saw the fire the whole starboard side of the tween decks was already ablaze. We led the fire hose down at once, but from some cause—I believe the dense smoke in the engine room—could not get the donkey pump started. Water was not obtained at all from the engine room pump. There was no hand pump on board. We bad had twelve fire buckets, filled with water, standing on the passenger deck, and four water kongs on the upper deck. Some of the buckets were handed down to me and their contents thrown on the fire, but it gained so rapidly that I had to desist. So few buckets were of no avail. The captain was close to me nearly all the time. I last saw him about five minutes before I went overboard. There were a number of Chinese passengers on board, I believe between fifty and sixty. I produce the manifest of cargo. We had the usual Hankow cargo, including inflammable articles; these last were all stowed in the tween decks. I superintended the stowing, with the assistance of a stevedore. The usual precaution was taken of laying down the fire hate ready for use; we had nothing else. I last saw the fire hose used about five or six days before leaving port. It is used every day. It is not customary to work the crew at fire stations.

By the Vice-Coxsur—I last saw the cap-tainan the bridge. It was on the upper deck, We call the bridge the fore part of the wheel-house. I cannot say what the captain was doing on the bridge when I saw him last. I cannot say whether he was taking measures to get the fire under at the time; the deck was then all ablaze, When I jumped overboard, I considered that everything possible had been done to save the Vessel, as far as our means went.

By Capt. Nawres—We had two connections for turning on water from the main engines. They were amidships, close to the engine-room; there were none at the ends of the ship. We carried three boats, and one sampan; the three boats were inboard and the sampan was always swung out when we were under way. The boats were all in chocks. The deck crew consisted of one boatswain, eight sailors, porter, four quarter-masters and a carpenter. We sometimes worked the boats in and out with the deck crew, but not with regularity. I do not know the cubic measurements of the boats. I hat i to do with the tallying of cargo. radore's crew receive the cargo and tally it, and it is brought on board by a gang of shore coolies who do the stowing as wel have nothing to ge by, oe to wlsotl there are dangézous goods on board, except the shipping orders from our agent. I see the shipping orders; when the compradore says they are correct, I sign them. I have no circulars or written orders about the stowage of cargoes; but it is customary for the chief officer to look after that.

By the Presipent—It was three or four minutes at the most after the alarm of fire that I gave op the idea of saving the ship. We put out the port boats, but were unable to yet out the starboard boats on account: of the fire. There wore two boats on the port side. Two quarter-masters got into the forward boat. There was no time to tell off any passengers for the boats. Thirty-four were saved in the boats; others were picked up in the water by other steamers. I sprang overboard wit a chair out of my room, I could not swim, but I got hold of the chain (I do net know how) and was taken off by the Ngenkin, There were three steamers in sight at the time of the fire—the Ngantin, the Sual, and the Taito. They saved all that were left. They gave every assistance in their power. I should. think about thirty lives were lost. I estimate that the four boats would hold about ninety-five persons, This is a rough guess; it has never been tried.

By the Vice-Coxsvr—The port boats were a boat which would hold thirty, and the sampan, which would hold fifteen.

By Captain Nanres—The deck passengers were spread all over the ship. The passengers did not rush for the boats, and did not impede the crew.

Exxest Srronpaut, sworn, deposed—I was second mate of the Paoching. When the fire broke out I was on the bridge, on the The second engineer gare the first alarm, upper deck. The captain was on the bridge, Ido not know where the fire broke out or what was frst ignited. On thewlarm of fire T rang the bell and gave orders to get the fire hose and buckets ready. The engines were not stopped and no ventilation was closed. We were going at full speed. 1 do not know at what interval after the firet alarm the was stopped. The captain and pilot were in charge of the deck. I was spreading the bridge awning,. I heard the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account