To-pay we are enabled to follow Chang Chih-tung's report on railways in China with that of the Governor of Formosa, Liu Ming-chuan.' This semi-independent ruler, the only high official who staunchly and in the main successfully resisted the French in the late war, has a much more practical mind than his colleague at Canton. His report is brief, and very much to the point. Ten years ago he urged the value of railways, and was not listened to; he might have mentioned that he has backed his opinions by introducing the iron road into his own satrapy, We cannot say very much for that part of his argument in favour of the proposed line from Tientsin to Tungchow, which refers to the capitals of Europe, for the Censor might retort that the Germans found the French railways very useful to them in the siege of Paris; and Liu aust have had a descent on Peking from Siberia in his mind when he shewed how useful the railway would be in bringing up the troops from Tientsin and 'I kus and indeed the last para-Ria that he regards as the possible aph in his report shews that it is foe to be provided against; but he disposes sensibly enough of the objection as to the men whom the line would throw out of work; and it would undoubtedly be a good thing to brigade the defenders of Peking more often with Li's foreign-drilled ary. The trunk line that Liu proposes would have Chinkiang or Shanghai as its terminus; and he is, of course, careful to shew that its construction would be a blow to the profits of foreigners. As to this, we must take our chance; but we might remind the Governor that the coasting trade of Great Britain has not fallen off, covered with railways as the country is. There is not very much more inthe Governor of Formosa's report; there will be more interest in ig what those high officials have to say who have come little into contact with foreigners, and who will have evolved their recommendations or objections from their own consciousness and their study of the classics. If they can find that, as Jimmu lenno 2,500 years ago laid the foundation for the new constitution of Japan, so Confucius not long afterwards made a deliverance which can be construed into an approval of the iron road, a great point will have been gained; for here, if anywhere, existence broadens slowly down from precedent to precedent.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.