Tue punishment of the 2ud Battalion of the Grenadier Guards was the principal topic of the week whose papers were brought on Saturday by the Sayhalien. Some of the papers do not usitate to call the insubordination of the battalion a mutiny. Technically, no doubt, it was a mutiny, but a mutiny of the mildest kind. There' was a "mitigating circumstance," which the Times thus describes: "Upon the all but universal absence from parade becoming manifest the company ollicers went to the nien's rooms, whereupon the men followed them in a completely subordinate manner to the parade ground. That is to say, that having planned and carried out a demonstration utterly subversive of military discipline, the men appeared desirous not tu carry the matter any further." In fact, it was a mere demonstration, to which, as one of the pap ests, the men had been mainly driven by Ube intolerably bad weather which eh: ised the ssu Englund this year. offer aggravated, says the Times, by the fact that they were inspected a few days before, "when the men had full opportunity to make known, in the manner provided by the regulations of the Service, whatever vances they may have believed themselves entitled to complain of." 'This sounds very well, but the Times mast know Cut Tony Atkins is the last mau in the world ty come out with his grievances at a formal inspection when heis asked in the usual perfunctory manner, 'Well, my men, have you aitything to' complain of The general opinion of the newspapers ig that the punishments dealt out were just; the retirement of Colonel Maitland, after hie had publicly stated that he had by his sea-kit and meant to go with the re ment; the sentencing of six of the supposed ringleaders-—for the men refused to gay who their loaders were—to teras of imprisonment with hard Inbour ranging from eighteen mouths to two yenrs; and the exile of the battalion to" Bermuda, where they will have nothing to do but drink, The papers, however, are means unanimous in praise of the decision arrived at. We may take as representa ti of the two views the Subrday Rede the Duily Clvonicle. The Sutwrduy saysi—
The course which has been taken with the six companies of Grenadiers who forgot themselves three weeks ago suggests one consoling reflection on a deplorable business. It shown that governing persons in this country can still act with promptitude and sense when they are allowed to act freely. The Horse Guiards—or, as we think more just to say, the Comm has proved capable of dea danger without either underrating it, 0 what was equally easy, making more of it than was necessary. By displacing the officer who could not so nianage his battalion as to keep it in order, by sending the men who refused obedience out of the country, and by inflicting a special punishment on individuals, enough has been done to apportion blame and chaste ys and done wit fuss, Colonel Maitland would have very ground of complaint if we were to dwell at any length ea his responsibility for the disturbance; but he cannot complain when the worldnotesthevery pater facts that hismendid break out of hand, and t that his superiors, who Ind every motive to support him, have cone to the conclusion that the disefpline of the regiment would run a better chance of being thoroughly restored under another officer. That the men should also be punished was a matter of course. Some of those who have thought it necessary to give their opinion have come to the extraordinary conclusion that, because the Colonel was thought not to have unimaged well, the men ought to have been held as excused. It would be a pure waste time to argue with persons who can talk in tgs style." They must be incapable of understanding what military discipline means. Mutiny and lesser degrees of insubordination are always serious offences, no matter how or in what way they have been provoked, for they strike at the very life of all armed and disd ciplined bodies. They are not only a sin against the honour of the corps, but they tend to make th If a terrible danger to the unarmed and undisciplined population around it. Moreover, there is no fact in military history more certain than that acts of insubordination, when they are weakly dealt with, have a dreadful tendency to repeat themselves with ever-increasing "frequency and gravity. It was, therefore, absolutely necessary to punish the insubordination of the battalion, even though we knew—what, a matter of fact, we do not know—that it had been brought on by gross provocation. As Mr. Stanhope reminded the House of Commons, soldiers in the British army are ate and recognised means of making their grievances known. It may very well be that this resource is more effective in appearance than in reality; but it was surely better for the men to risk angering their Colonel by complaining to those to whom they have a right to complain than to disgrace the regiment and bring punishment, on themselves by refusing to obey orders. The exact punishment inflicted has been well chosen, As no individual ringleaders could be picked of the oldest soldier in every pany to serve ws example was sagacious. In future the oldest man will take care not to the mixed up in such proceedings if they should unhappily recur, ant each man, as he in turn becomes oldest by the retreat of his seniors, will hasten to extricate himself from the danger in which he stands. We notice in some quarters " disapproval of the despatch of the six companies to Bermuda, on the ground that it seems to put a stigma on all foreign service by nuking it a punishment, We do not think that any such opinion will be entertained by military men. The position of the Guards as to foreign service is well known, ranted by all soldiers. Do these critics think it would have been better putting i by depriving to fall back on the old money method of indeed have been done, but the course actually of its colours and facings? That sight chosen has been the better, if only because it Will make any further steps unnecessary.
The Daily Chronicle's view is diametrically opposed to that of the Saturday The decision to send the Second Battalion of the Grenadier Guards to Bermuda strikes as being singularly unfortunate, We do not suppose that the Government have been foolish enou: a menace to the United Press and that large igland may think differently. rican people who are wu-
Altogether the choice is a terrible blunder. But what is the battalion to be sent there for? Clearly for punishment. As the rai falls on the just and the unjust, so this punishment here falls on guilty' and not guilty. And the guilty—whatof them The clearly were not ly to blame, else would authorities Jedd Colonel itland by Eaton. If Colonel itland was not to blame he would not have been superseded, and he assures us he did not resign. If he were to blame then the men bad some reason for what some of them did, though two companies, at least, were on detached duty and did nothing. Yet if the speech attributed to the Duke of Cambridge at Wellington Varracks yesterday is, cor: reetly reported. the battalion is represented as "utterly disgraced." We submit the sgrace™ falls on other than the bulk of the officers and men of the bat-Colonel Eaton hopes the men will the character they have if the links in the chain of evidence can be and the non-commis touch with their officers, of whom they saw nothing, save on some parades. And was that not the fault of the system by which the oftlyers of the Foot Guards alone live out of barracks? It is aimitted.to be the fault of the system, because officers' quarters are now to be provided in barracks used by the Guards. But this is not all—the battalion is to be sent away to virtually a penal settlement, where nothing is produced but onions and potatoes, and some men, chosen at hap-hazard, are to convicts, sentenced to terms of fron two remain at home. In what capacity? As years' to eighteen months' imprisonment, be-cotise they are supposed, through their seniority only, to have been ringleaders to protest against a course of conduct which has resulted in the supersession of the colonel commanding the battalion! 'These men were yesterday removed from barracks with every mark of, ignominy, handcuffed, in' prison garb," "haggard and dejected,'
in tears"—for what Why, for doing what in them lay, though in technically wrong fashion, to bring about an alteration in the system' which las, when brought to light, caused the removal of the colonel to the half-pay list. We say that this is a gross and erying outrage on justice. We can hardly believe the sentences will be persisted in, The exercise of the mercy inherent in the Crown is clearly called for, and we hope petition after petition will pour in to Her Majesty asking for the " pardon" of these unfortunate men, But let us note four things besides, 'The colonel's command was not a success, oF he would not have been superseded. 'The whole battalion is punished for what was only the fault of a part of iv at most. 'The officers are punished for what was the fault of the Guards' system, not of the officers as a body. And for the first time in the history of the Army, foreign service, instead of being held up asa privilege, is stigmatised as a punishment. We think the utter disgrace" is not with the Grenadier Guards.
At was rather an absurdity that the men were cheered as they marched off as though they were going on active service, and the ridiculous sentimentality of the Duke of Cambridge and Colonel Eaton at the ing tion is well put in the following song from the Pall Mall SONG OF THE GRENADIEK GU VKDS IN BERMUDA,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.