The Archive · 1888

THE P. & 0. MAIL SERVICE

To the Editor of the Nonr-Cuiva Darty News, Sin,—I beg to inform you I have received telegraphic instructions that, commencing with the Ballarat to leave on the proximo, the Company's steamers conveying the mails from this port are to be despatched at daylight on Saturday; and that the time of departure from Hongkong will be daylight on the following Thursday.

The alteration in the date of departure of the steamers is made under the terms consequently the reservoir embankmer must be at least as high as the river embankments. A square reservoir of 10,000 acres would require about 16 miles of bank or 12 miles if the river embankments be used for one side. The 100 reservoirs would therefore require about 1,200 miles of embankment, or more than the length required to embank buth sides of the river from the mountains to the sea. By making a smaller number of larger reservoirs the length would be diminished, but in_any case it would be very considerable. Moreover, these reservoirs would net do away with the necessity of river embankments, but only with the necessity of continually rising them, Their first cost therefore would be all se much extra, The total area suggested would no doubt be sufficient for the purpose intended, but in order to deposit silt in the most perfect manner, the reservoirs should be that their level would be but slightly affected by floods. Such, for instance, is the case with the Rhone which enters the lake of Geneva as a imnddy stream and emerges as a clear one. Splitting up the area would diminish the good effect of these reservoirs, but would not of course destroy it, But what would be the effect of depositing silt inthem? No measurements have been made which show the proportion of the silt in the Yellow River which is deposited in its bed and the proportion carried out to sea, but judging from the slong for some hundreds of miles, I should appearance of the river which I have sailed

think more than half is carried to sea.

Now if the river is to be rendered even tolerably clear much more silt must be deposited in the reservoirs (which will be comparatively still) than formerly was deposited in the bed (where there was always swift current) and assuming the 1,500 square miles of reservoir to be double the area of the flood channel of the river, they will rise approximately as fast as the old bed used to rise and the result will be, say 1,000 miles of river embank-quiring raising or renewal at the same tate as was required for the old river enibank-Fequiring certain annual repairs, and ments. reservoirs constructed on' the plain are therefore out of the question, and unless Mr. Fergusson can show that there is some valley where an enormous deep lake could be made by the construction of an embankment of a practicable height aid length his scheme is unworkable.

But even if workable is it the best Mr. F m says "Rivers were never tended to carry off to the sea immense bodies of the earth's crust" and he afterwards refers to the power lating such matters as "nature." One finds one class of people referring the power which rules the universe to a Supreme Being, and another class, hesitatingto use such definite language, making use of abstract terms such as nature, and each class occasionally makes state: ments which the other class finds somewhat, startling, but I believe both classes will agree with me in thinking that a statement that the Supreme Power cannot carry out its own intentions is the most sepuiding reposition that has ever been put for wai Thave always hesitated to state definite views regarding the regulation of the Yellow River, because, although [have travelled over and carefully examined the so-called old bed and the late bed, I know my information is very limited, but I believe at present (though quite open to conviction that Iam wrong if definitely observed facts go against me) that the best way to deal with the river over at least 300 miles of its course (and probably' rather more) is to embank it, The plain has a very definite and not inconsiderable slope towards the Yellow Sea and the Gulf of Pechili, as is proved by the courses of the river to both these places having been comparatively straight, and the current having been rapid but Iaterally there is so little ditterence of level that the river, if left to itself, might be 20 or 30 or leven' more miles wide in some places, There is " depression at the Hongtse lake, and Dr. Williamson has pointed out that there is low. lying land along the course of the little Yellow River. It might be advisable to follow this course, but it must be remembered that if sea level be reached too soon the lower portion of the river will become a tortuous stream causing great trouble, and a line of uniform inclination would probably suit much better.

sisting of a thin bank of earth with a If the present weak embankments, con-by Substantial embankments, strengthened reportion of millet. stalks, be re

when ni y matrosses of willows fastened with piles and loaded with stones, and if these embankments be made along a well-considered course, sufficiently wide to give room for the river in floods wi distinct low water channel excavated in the centre, the river will be fairly well under control. It will raise its bed, no doubt, requiring the banks to be raised an equal amount, but it will do so most near the mountains. Tt will then gradually acquire a steeper slope and so carry here silt out to sea, and although the height above the plain may eventually become more than the conservators can Teal with, and a change of course may become hecesing of this sort will occur for very many generations.

The fact is that what is wanted is the conservation of the river. Any one who thinks of the many years spent on the Mississippi or even on the Sulina mouth of the Danube must see, without any special knowledge, that no scheme for putting the Yellow River in order in a definite time for. definite sum of money can_possibl und. It is very dificult to impress of the case on the Chinese authorit They do not understand the conservation of roads or bridges, or buildings or works of any sort. They would willingly even an exorbitant sum to have the river put to rights once fur all, but any one who

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account