2nd Dec, Is the Chinese tariff, looked at as a whole, too high? Are foreign merchants in China suffering grievously from the unfairness of the import and export duties at present levied? If they were, would not the Chambers of Commerce in China have taken. up the question, or would they have left their interests in the hands of Mr. Holt S. Hallett? This gentleman writes to the Zémes from Brighton on the 20th of October last, pointing out that it is of great importance to our manufacturers that the present opportunity for revising the tariff should not be lost sight of, and thus allowed to lapse without advantage being taken of it, Article 26 of the Treaty of Tientsin provided for an, immediate revision of the tariff, on the round that that fixed by the Treaty of Nanking had been found "by reason of the fall in value of various articles of merchandise, therein enumerated, to, impose a duty upon these considerably in excess of the rate originally assumed to be a fair rate," about the rate of five per cent. ad valorem; and in the next article it was provided that further revisions might be demanded, by either side, at the end of every ten years; but if no demand for revision was made within six months after the eud of each period of ten years, then the tariff shouldremainin force for ten years more. After quoting these articles, Mr. Hallett goes on to say "Nobwithstandingthe greatend constant decrease in the cost price of our manufactures since October, 1860, when the treaty was ratified, our Government omitted to have the specific rates in the tariff revised in 1870 and 1880. The opportunity is once more before us, and it will be a serious blow to our trade if our Government allows into pass without having the specific rates in the Chinese tariff again reduced to the standard limit, 5 per cent. ad valorem. I will take two instances to show the need of revising the tariff, one in cotton goods, the other in iron. Our 7b. cotton shirtings on entering a Chinese treaty port are worth about £50 a ton. The spe-' citic duty levied on them, which in 1860 was equivalent to 5 per cent. ad valorem, is now equivalent toS per cent., and the transit dues, which in 1860 were equivalent to 2} per cent., are now equivalent to 4 per cent. ad valorem. The import duty and transit duties together are therefore 4! per cent. ad valorem higher than they were when the tariff was fixed in 1860. In the same way with pig-iron, the duty and transit, dues are now 44 per cent. ad valorem higher than when they were fixed in 1860."
Mr. Hallett, it will be seen, instances only cases in which the specific duty is now considerably more than the 5% ad valorem which was the original basis of the tariff, and he might have given even more striking examples than he does. There are, for example, large quautities of grey shirtings imported, whose selling value is under one tael a pice duty paid, and they pay eight candareen: Haikuan currency a piece, or nearly ten percent. A reduction of five tael cents a piece in the cost of these to the consumer would, no doubt, in time lead toa larger consumption as all cheapening of articles dues; but it would take sometime. The eight-pound-four shirting, however, remains the leading weight in this class of goods, and i darkens a piece is little more than five per cent. ad valorem on these; and on the heavier and better shirtings up' to eleven and twelve pounds, the specific duty is considerably less than five per cent. ad valorem, and the possibility that a revision of the tariff would include a raising of the rate on a very large proportion of the goods imported does not seem to have struck Mr.
Hallett. A revision would not, in fact, be all in favour of the manufacturers, as they no doubt know, It is the same thing with exports. The specific duty on tea amounts now to something like twelve-and-a-half to fifteen per cent. ad valorem on the average value of the tea exported to Great Britain; but that on silk is not much more than three per cent. on the average value; and there are a large number of exports of which the same is true. Our governments, if they ever consider the revision of the tariff at all, comfort themselves with the thought that if foreigners really wanted it, their Chambers of Commerce. would take the matter up, and that merchants and manufacturers leave revision alone, because they realise that it would work both ways.
Specific duties can never for long be an accurate proportion of the value of the goods on which they are levied, 8 the values of raw materials and manufactures change from day to day, but there are many things that make then preferable to ad valorem duties, though the latter seem more just at first sight. There is, of course, infinitely more trouble, and therefore expense, in the collection of ad valorem clu they have the great moral di that they tempt the shipper to mani-plate his invoices, a temptation that weak human nature cannot always ist with sufficient sternness. fortunately, mankind generally holds it a venial sin to cheat, if it can, its ows as well as alien governments; and a mau who would hesitate to pick a pocket, will without a quam make an inadequate declaration to an income tax collector or a custom house officer. Much of this temptation is removed when duties, are specific. As regards the Chines tariff, it is universally recognised that it isa very light one. It is distinctly a tariff for revenue only, with no thought. of protection in it, and it compares most favourably with the tariffs of most European' and American States. Ifa revision were pressed for, it would be! difficult for the united Powers to refuse a general raising of the tariff, were the Chinese negotiators to compare their! tariff with that of many of the countries concerned. There is another thing to be considered; that it is doubtful whether there would be for a long time much increase of consumption of the articles on which the duties would be lowered, if the five per cent. ad valorem rate were again made the basis, or much decrease of those on which the duties would be increased. The steady way in which the prices of cotton goods, for instance, followed the fall in the value of silver, showed that there is a demand for a certain quantity of certain goods, irrespective to a great extent of moderate fluctuations in price, and this is an argument against the opening of the question of revision by the government, as long as the latter is not urged to it by the Chamber of Commerce.
As regards Mr. Haliett's second point, the evasion by the southern Viceroys of the transit pass system, and the imposition, against the treaty, of heavy "inland charges," we are quite at one with him. Here an energetic Minister might do something, but his remonstrances commot lave much weight as long as the 'I'sungli Yamen knows that under no. circumstances will foreign governments enforce the observation of the treaties, They will represent and ask, and possibly go so far as to demand, but as they are precluded from hinting at resort to the ultima ratio, if their demands are not granted, they have little hope of success.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.