The Archive · 1891

Treaty Revision in Japan

Irth March

Treaty Revision is not dead in Japan, but rather suffering from a temporary suspension of vitality; and the fact that the Diet has been prorogued without any definite statement on the subject having been elicited from Ministers, confirms the opinion we previously expressed that the people generally are t very well content to let things go on as they are, he Japan Mail poured on us all the vials of its wrath for expressing the opinion; we added that the proceedings of the Diet, which was soon about to meet when we wrote, would show whether there was that anxiety in the country for revision which the foreign organ of the government asserted to exist; the Diet has adjourned without extorting any promise from the government that the treaties should be immediately revised, without imposing on the government any irreducible minimum. So little interest is really felt in the matter that Viscount Aoki, the Minister for Foreign Affairs, did not reply until the 5th of Murch last, twelve days ago, to the questions addressed to him on the subject by Mr. Misaki Kamenosake and others on the 24th of December last. A country cannot be burning for treaty revision when it allows nearly two-anda-half mouths to elapse between the putting of questions in the Diet on the subject, and the delivery of the answers, That even Viscount Aoki does not consider the matter of much importance is shown by his first excuse for the delay: "I wished to reply to this previously, but I have been occupied with other business." His second excuse was an excellent one, if it had been anything more than an' excuse wished also to reply as fully as possible even upon the matters in course of negotiation." Then, presuming that the reports of his speech in the Japan Mail and Japan Herald axe trustworthy, Viscount Aoki carefully gave the Diet no information at all. We say "presuming that the reports are Srustyoey, not with the slightest intention of suggesting the contrary, but because they lifer go remarkably Hom the Viscount's speech, which the Hiogo News says was delivered in the House of Peers, as reported in the Osaka Asahi Shimbun, and which we are obliged to think was cooked up for the benefit of the country folk, to show them what a very patriotic and determined person Viscount Aoki is. According to that report, foreigners were to be allowed to reside freely in Japan, but not to acquire land, while they were to be entirely subject to Japanese jurisdiction. The Japanese were to have perfect freedom to fix their own tariff, but foreigners were only to trade at certain ports, and were to be debarred from the coasting trade. "In other words," as the News says, " foreigners are to surrender all the rights they at present possess for the very doubtful privilege of being alowed to reside at any place in Japan." This was the tenour of Viscount Avki's speech, as reported for native consumption, but it was very wuch gentler as reported in the Yokohama papers. Mr. Misaki asked last Decem! whether. the government, in negotiating the revision of treaties, looks to recover the empire's judicial autonomy and tariff autonomy ther and in their entirety, or whether it looks to recover them in part only." To this Viscount Aoki replied that the flesirability of recovering their autonomy government were fully conscious of the

in both directions, but they could not say that they were going to do it at once. He spoke with the feeling of responsibility that becomes a Minister when he proceeded to point out.that changes of that kind cannot be enforced in a hurry, and that there is a proper procedure to be gone. through to effect such great works. If in crossing a plain you come to a river where there is no bridge, you must stop and build a bridge, and that is what the goverumentary doing. They are at work building a bridge, and their great endeavour is to make that bridge as short as possible._ The anti-unconditional-revisiouists in Yokohama will see with pleasure that the Japanese government does recognise the necessity for this bridge, for the great meeting of last year was called because its promoters had learnt that the British government was about to agree to revision without any bridge and it was because they ale that a Mail attacked Mr' Lowder sud "his bridge was ut that the Japan

fellow-promoters of the meeting so mercilessly. Viscount Aoki went on to say that a3 the question whether the government looked to the recovery of a portion of their. autonomy now, and the remainder at' a future date, he had to own that practically their idea was to be content with.a portion now, and to recover the remainder in as short @ time as possible. The government, and the speaker himself, felt that the privily in relation to the tariff which foreigners enjoyed under their treaties could not be.withdrawn at a mo+ ment's notice. It will be seen from this resume, thatthe government practically told the Diet nothing at all, except that negotiations were going on, and the government were, as all governments should do in making treaties, trying to get as much concession for their country as they could. When Viscount Aoki was asked how his scheme of treaty revision differed after all from the discarded schemes of Counts Okuma and Inouye, he could only say that it was impossible for him to explain the difference exactly, "for though their projects are now things of the past, mine forms the subject of actual negotiation." We have consistently supported the claim" of the Japanese to have their treaties revised and to be gradually freed from what seems to them the indignity of extraterritoriality, and we are glad to see that the present government treats the question in such @ moderate spirit Lowder and his friends are not likely to find any fault with negotiations carried on on so temperate a basis, and. the treaties should soon be revised if the Japanese government. continues to recognise that foreign. governments are not unreasonable in requiring certain safeguards—the bridge of Viscount Aoki—before consigning their nationals to Japanese jurisdiction, and their trade to an entirely one-sided tariff.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account