The Archive · 1890

The State and Morality

2st Feb.

Tue proposers on Tuesday of the resolutions talling upon the Municipal Council to abolish the opportunities for the practice of certain vices in Shanghai would have done much better if they had not been so sweeping in their demands; they laid themselves open to Hesiod's reproach, that "it is folly not to know that the half is often more than the whole;" they would have carried, no doubt, the majority of the meeting with them, if they had contented themselves with asking the Council to do its best to restrict the opportunities for vice. It is curious how often enthusiasts require reminding that it cannot be the function of the State to enforce morality, where the neglect of it is only personal in its effects. Sir Edwin Arnold told the Japanese the other day that the only thing worth having they could bring from the West was the Sermon on the Mount, and we presume that he imeaut that his hearers should make its injunctious their guide in their private life. But if he meant that the State should make it the basis of its legislation, he brought himself at once into conflict with no less a man than Dr. Magee, Bishop of Peterborough, whose article in the last issue of the Lortuightly, "The State and the Sermon on the Mount," puts very clearly what should be the limits of the State's action in the enforcement of morals. Dr. M ins by saying that he has been bitterly assailed for making two assertions: 1. That is not possible for the State to carry out in all its relations, literally, all the precepts of Christ, and that a State which attempted this could not exist for a week. 2. That if it were possible to do this the result would be a perfectly intolerable tyranny.

There can be only one answer to the first question which Dr. Magee asks his assailants: "Is it then the case that it is possible for the State literally to carry out all the precepts of Christ An affirmative reply would mean that the State should "disband its army, burn its ships of war, abolish its courts of justice, pull down its jails, dismiss its policemen, bestow its revenues upon all and sundry who ask for them, and still continue to exist as a State." Then the Bishop's assailants shift their ground and allow that neither the State nor the individual can obey the precepts of the Sermon on the Mount literally, but they can obey them in the spirit. But this concession does not satisfy Dr. Magee, and he replies that it is his firm belief, " that neither in the spirit nor in the letter can the entire of that Sermon be carried out by the State, and that whenever it attempts to do this it is tending to its own destruction." We should like to see all our spiritual pastors and masters display the healthy firmness and common songo of the Bishop of Peterborough. In explafuing his position he first attacks the common fallacy that the State is the nation, whereas it is that part of the nation—that committee of the majority of the nation—which has been "entrusted with certain rights, interest, privileges, and possessiuus of the citizens of the coun+ try which it rules, to be maintained and administered for their benefit." Directly we remember that the State is the trustee of the nation and not the nation itself, we see that it cannot be asked to obey the precepts of the Sermon on the Mount. It is no more justi-_ fied in non-resistance to assaults on its ursa or its person, than a trustee would justified in not resisting attacks on the person or property of his ward. Putting aside the question of "how the individual is required by the Sermon on the Mount to deal with his own rights and possessions, it is clear that it gives him no directions as to how he is to deal with the rights and possessions of others." And it is throughout the rights and possessions of others with which the State is dealing, not its own.

The morality, then, that the State is bound to exercise is morality in the discharge of its trust. It must simply do its duty to those whom it represents, in accordance with their directions, and with the constitution, written or unwritten, under which it exists. nothing to do with any Higher Law. This is what we intended to convey in saying the other day that these settlements are not governed by "the principles of British and American common law and the law of God." We might have pointed out, indeed, that British common law is a misnomer. All trustees have to carry out their trusts under certain instructions; in our case these instructions are the Laud Regulations and By-Laws, and the morality to be practised by our State is obedience to these Regulations. Our Council representing, as it does, all nations and all creeds included in the community, would be false to its trust if it allowed itself to be swayed by any other law than the Land Regulations, or by any sectarian view of the law of God. The morality and justice which actuated it must be universally accepted; they must be those which, to use Bishop Magee's words, "were not created nor were revealed by Christ; they existed and were known to exist before the givin; of the Sermon on the Mount, and woul have continued tu exist had that discourse never been spoken, or had He who spoke it never appeared amongst men."

We have not space, nor have we the desire, now to go into the question of the desirability of checking the tempta~ tions to vice offered in these settlements —though as to that there can be little We have pointed out before now the uestion—and the practicability of it.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account