The Archive · 1888

China and Corea

We have published during the last few days the principal part of Mr. Denny's iphlet attack on China and appeal for the independence of Corea, The Fortions of it which we have withheld with the legal question of the vassalage or non-vassalage of Corea to China, and seem to us to have no practical weight in the controversy which Mr. Denny has endeavoured to raise. The opinions of Wheaton and other authorities will have no weight in determining the future of Corea, should that matter t itself for urgent solution before the members of the Tsung-li Yamen. Whether Corea is to be allowed to go as the factions which intermittently rule her may desire, or be taken seriously in hand by China, will not be decided by academic rules, but by the necessities of China's case at the time. We are not therefore about to consider elaborately, whether there is historical evidence of Corea having been a vassal of China. Some evidence of vassalage has been presented, derived from the Sheng Wu Chi, the military record of the 'l'a Tsing dynasty. The vassalage is not distinctly claimed on this record, it is merely to be inferred by the reader from certain portions of the conditions which were imposed on Corea, after it had fallen to the Manchus early in the seventeenth century. The chief of these conditions on which a claim of vassalage is attempted to be displayed are: That the defeated King of Corea agreed to surrender the seal and insignia of rank which he had originally received from the Ming Emperors; II—That he agreed to ada it for all time the Manchu calendar. The other clauses, such as the one which prohibited the Corean Kings from erecting fortresses without the permission of China, are such as are often imposed on defeated countries, of which Russia at the close of the Crimean war forms an example: We are told that when matters were arranged tween China and Corea, the King of the latter country performed: the fo tow before the Emperor Tai-tsung. This ceremony does not amount to much, for at that time the whole earth was held by Chinese annalists as barbarian and eager to send tribute-bearing kotowperforming missions to the Emperor. Besides, Corea was at that time, and was for a hundred and sixty years a tributary of Japan, a point on which, we are told, the Chinese historiographer is silent, we dare say he has been upon a good many other points which told against his country. Still, it appears to us that there is evidence to show that the Kings of Corea acknowledged the Emperors of China as their Lord Superiors. This we take to be shown by the petition which was sent by the King of Corea to the Emperor Kanghi in 1694, a translation of which was given in April 1887 in the letter of a correspondent whose knowl of the historical and actual Corea is undoubted. Mr. Denny i his inconsiderate way calls our col rident an advocate of v: re, wwheress he simply related a one fact which bore on the question of Corea's vassalage or dey anita Gai Chin. Mr. Denny tries to shew that our correspondent put the case—which was that at the end of the sixteenth and the beginning of the seventeenth centuries the consent of China had to be obtained before the successor chosen by the King of Corea could receive the title of HeirApparent and then could not assume the title of King until it was conferred on him by Peking—" much this does not appear to be the case, stronger than the facts warrant." But

and it is with history and not with our correspondent that Mr. Denny should be angry. The conclusion we come to is that Corea was, almost down to the time when she made treaties with States in the West, dominated by Peking and owed to the Chinese Emperor something which if it was not vassalage was remarkably like it, at all events at those times when Peking fitfully woke up and asserted its rights.

When we come to the time when Corea entered into relations with other powers; we find her making a treaty with Japan in 1876 in which the first article is "Chosen being an independent state enjoys the same sovereign rights as Japan." The next treaty was with the United States in 1882, and as it stands there is nothing about the dependence or independence of the country. Neither is there any reference to either of these conditions in the treaty with Great Britain. There is not a word of Corean independence or Chinese supremacy in either of these documents. Mr. Denny tells us that Li Hung-chang endeavoured to the last to get the vassalage of Corea acknowledg; in the American treaty, but that the American representative would have none of it. He was satisfied with the King's letter in which he be- acknow his Kingdom to be tributary to China, but said that as regarded the various duties which devolved upon Corea as a tributary state to China, the Laos oe hes ce concern whatever. Sir arkes ai ith mel sel see sentatives of other western powers. But some time afterwards the Rules for the Land and Water Commerce between China and Corea were agreed to, and has long been cop of. out vassal the opening sentence says that "Corea

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account