The Archive · 1890

NOTES BY QUIDNUNC

There are so few things that one can know about this peculiar country that I sometimes wonder if we know anything atoll, The trifles under one's very nose 80 befile investigation or are capable of s0 many diverse explanations that one is left with an uncomfortable feeling that probably the right one has never been touched. The author of Chinese Characteristics has presented us with a new and authentic basis on which to work, but though his knowledge be wide and minute, his observation and his philosophy acute, it passed his wit to reach a definite conclusion, Historic finger-posts there are none, and perhaps that does not matter, now that Professor Bryce has assured us that the one thing certain about history is that it does not repeat itself. We used in happier climes to argue by analogy, but an analogue has been out of court here' ever since Cooke sent his wonerful letters to the Times. You remember the brilliant description of the country where the men wore petticoats and the women donned the—well, the other things! And then only the other day, as if to rive the last nail into the analogical coffin, Major Knollys, having exhausted his vocabulary of pleasantries about his own countrymen and countrywoman in China, brings his verbal pyrotechnics to bear upon the country in which they live. An imitation of Cooke if you like, but an uncommonly good one." What a comical juxtaposition of ideas is that in the last Paragraph with its sly allusion to the country where the magistrates have no honour and the roses no smell! If to reach a paradox were to have seized upon an ultimate truth, we might draw the cvy visitant from the bottom of the well and walk with her hand in hand all our Chinese days. The air is full of paradoxes, but somehow they cease to become a source of conviction by mere stress of numbers, and not infrequently end in mere pyrrhonism. With nothing to guide us, what can we do but doubt? What else remains for us in a land where the past lies blank behind us without even a ruin to mark it, where everything is contradictory and nothing familiar, or ther, where things elsewhere most familiar om here most strange, Like strangers' voices here they sound, In lands where not " memory stra "Nor landmark breathes of other days "But all is new unhallowed ground.

Upon the whole a sturdy scepticism in regard to all Chinese matters may be recommended to the new arrival axa not unhealthy state of mind for beginning the search for truth. It is more becoming at any rate than the valiant cock-sureness of the "griffin", and he need not fear the occasional unpleasant consequences which unbelief carries in ita train elsewhere. The odium sivologicum indeed we have, but as for the credo, no two persons have ever been found to repeat it in the same way, and for the most varied ades of opinion supporters and authorities will be found near at hand. As a general rule it will be found perfectly safe to question every dogmatic statement. there sre six reasons which justify the remark that the Chinese are wholly given oyer to materialism, half a dozen can be found to prove their general piety. In-innate that asa nation they are untruss!

and champions, chiefly the younger ing forward to attest the national evidenced in the persons of their "boys Whose honesty they all durst swear for, Though not a man of them knows wherefore.

Some think the Government autocratic others, and this principally the older hands, are convinced of its democratic basis. In fine there never was such a country for contradictory theories established by seeniingly incontrovertible facts, It is somewhat humiliating to confess that our present state of certitude is only possible through our ignorance. The msn who knows is never cock-sure; and when we have learned more we shall probably assert less, And not till then shall we reach the correct solution of our problems.

I remember years ago, when I first came to China, how one was almost compelled to accept as axioms a string of opinions about China and the Chinese which succeeding years speedily caused one to modify or reject. Thera was Filial Piety, for instance, to doubt which was to be damned utterly. Are the Chinese really more filially pious than we? Everybody said they were except old Dr. Yates, who used stoutly to maintain the contrary. For my own part I always rebelled at the statement. I could seo small signs of it in daily life, while a contrary spirit was often manifest enough. The proofs advanced, such as the ger holiday claimed during the Feast of Tombs, the anxiety to borrow money for the too frequent interment of near relations and such like, seemed to me capable of a more obvious if less charitable interpretation. But then the Classics are full of the subject. The word was never out of the Master's mouth. The children are taught it at school. The Confucian system teems with admonitions on, examples of, and incentives to the practice of filial piety. The mind oscillated between such extremes unable to accept either. 1t was Martineau, I think, who first brought me intellectual relief. He is talking of old age and endeavouring to explain the silence of Christian precept on the subject of the reverence due to it, while the traces of such a doctrine are frequent in Greek and Roman literature, Every system, he goes on to say, strengthens most its weakest points, That Cicero gave such

Age prov t he regarded the departure preparation of his ti eon of morality with anxiety and apprehension, Christianity is silent, for its spirit of faith lifted this class of duties beyond the danger of neglect. A decline of tenderness towards the aged can never arise without. scope ticism of human immortality. That is just the point. Here we have a people who have never really conceived the idea of an immortality such as was common to the Greeks and Romans and in a far high degree to ourselves. I cannot help thinking that Confucius and all the rear of them kept harping on the subject just because they saw the supreme necessity for it. You may remind me that the Chinese are deeply impregnated with Buddhistic ideas, and among them the conception of future if not an immortal life. But then that involves metempsychosis, and when you come to think of it why should on pay reverence, which always has the after-death idea connected with it toa father who may shortly reappear pig? Buddhism, you see, in its essene outside the sphere of parental duti gether. In our sense it does not even recognise them. We cannot be sure, but at least there are sound reasons for doubting, if the Chinese are Gilially pious at all and it is certain that with their present beliefs they have no reason to be 80, But if we assume, and their language and literature give ample warrant forthe assumption, that the Chinese are mainly Buddhistic in their ideas, what are wetomake of the con-traditions to Buddha's theory of life which appear to be as universal as they are patent Mainly this; that the connexion between Conduct and Belief is more remote than we are apt to suppose. The theologians have so long saddled us with a contrary opinion that it has become no easy matter to slacken the mental girths. But as soon

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account