The Archive · 1888

QUEEN'S BENCH DIVISION

(Before Lord Coleridge.) 'THE MOOUL STEAMSHIP COMPANY (LIMITED) — M'GREGOR, GOW, AND COMPANY AND — OTHERS

In this case, which had stood over for some time for judgment, the Lord Chief Justice gave the following judgment this mornning "This was a one which over from causes not under his. control. Plaintifis were a trading between Australi taking China by the way, and transport of what had beet est, in late spring and early. summer months, and the places for loading which, as far as this case was concerned, were Shanghai, at the mouth of the Yangtee-Kiang, and Hankow, 600 miles up. stream. Defendants were certain great shipowners, companies and private partnerships, trading for the most part from this country to China and from China here direct, who desiring to keep this very valuable trade in their own hands, and to prevent, if they could, the ruinous lowering of freights which they contended would follow from unrestricted competition, entered into what they called a conference for the purpose of working the homeward trade by Storing a rebate of 5 per cent. on all freights paid by the shippers to the cun-Fence vessels, such - te not to be at Shanghai or Hankow (the rebate. not id to any shipper shipping any tea being confined to these ports, but that is immaterial) in any non-conference vessels. The agreement entered into by the conference was in April, 1884, and in that year plaintiffs joined it. They were excluded in 1885. "A commercial conflict was the result, with heavy losses on both sides. For their loss plaintiff now sued the conference, who, they said, bribed, coerced, induced shippers to forbear from shipping cargoes in pluintifiy' vessels. 'The question was, Would this action lie? If so, the damages are to be settled els doubt, whatever be the legal was considerable moral and sensible defence for defendants' conduct. They were running steamers regularly all the year round from England to Chins and back, considerably benefiting the commercial community of both countries, and it was clear fron the evidence that they could not do this at a profit, and would therefore probably cease to do it at all, unless they could practically monopolize the carrying trade daring the tea harvest. It was the large profit they made by keeping up the rate of tea freights which enabled them to give a regular communication during the other months of the year, They contended, therefore, that What they did was not purely selfish—though, of course, self-interest guided them, but that there were real and large public benefits accruing to China and England from the course. For this contention here was some ground. The complaint, then, was that defendants unlawfully combined and conspired to prevent plaintifls from carrying on their trade that they did prevent them by the use of unlawful means in furtherance of such unlawful combination and conspiracy; end that from rs naleyial here yoying and conspiracy damage had resulted to the plaintiffs. Defendants sus wer that neither was the combination unlawful in iteolf, nor were unlawful means used in furtherance of it, but the damage, if any, to plaintifis was the necessary result of the defendants carrying on their lawful trade in a lawful mauner. In the statements of law by counsel on either side there was often close apparent agreement, but when it came to the application, the same words were evidently not always used on both sides in the same sense. What seemed to be the law on the matter might, as the facts mostly depended' on written -documents, be stated without much dispute. It could not be, nor was it denied that to ground this action there must be an element of unlawfulness in the combination, and that this element mast. exist alike whether the combination was. the subject of an indictment or of an' action, But in an indictment it sufficed if the combination existed and was unlawful, because it was the combination itself which was mischievous and gave the public an interest Thad' stood to interfere by indictment, Nothing need

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account