The Archive · 1885

Shanghai Literary and Debating

'SOCIETY, A meeting of the members of this Society and their friends was held on Wednes evening in the Library of the Royal A jetty, Mr, Fryer, Pro, in the chair, The subject announced for discussion was embodied in the following resolute the spread of Republicanism is not {uconsistent with the maintenance of monarchical institutions."

The Prestvexr briefly opened the discussion, remarking that a good debate might be expected, as the rival systems, Republicasism and Limited Monarchy, wore both fairly represented in Shanghai and in fact at that meeting.

8. Wickisox, in moving th revolution, said it was necessary, in ord that they might discuss this" question fairly, that they should have a clear understanding of what republicanisia was, Republica at once an li and what monarchical institutions were, and a principle—a form of government and the principle which was supposed to underlie that form of government receive ite greatest development ore By the spread of republicanism, he me: the spread of this principle, which mi be stated to be development of popular influence in the government of country. The question then was whether the spread of popular influence i ernment was consistent with the mainten-noe of a monarchy and with all that the existence of a monarchy implied, It was of course inconsistent with the existence vf 8 despotic monarchy; but he would endeavour to slow that it was not incon-the existence of such a form f monarchy as they had in Great Britain, where the monarch was considered as the hereditary chief magistrate and the fountain of all honour. In a constitutional monarchy the system of government might be absolutely the same as in a republic with the single exception that the chief i /as appointed in a different way. this respect the difference was not necessarily very groat, because there had been monarchies where magistrate was elected for life were none the less cot the chief magistrate was diary cllicer, the republican principle was veepable of as full. development as in republic, Under a quustitutional mouarment of the country;-and the-extent which they participated depended not on the form of the goverument—monarcical or republican ther causes altogether. People might obtain the largest. possible share in the government of the cotintry, and yet the monarchy remain. Then there was the wider question to consider, as to whether the republican principles which it was admitted were spreading, were 20 spreading as to involve the overthrow of monarchies. They were all more or less familiar with the causes which had led to the downfall of kings in ancient modern times. 'The people had from ime to time risen against monarchs who id not full the duties which devolved upon them; in some cases they had made the mistake of looking upon the institution' of monarchy i ing the germs of the evil which lay, not the institution itself, but in the parti Me individual, He would refer to the case of the secession of America, In that stance, whatever faults the king person-been guilty of, there was occasion was really due to the faults of the country which he repre-—and it was perhaps well for the English that the king had for the sins of his peuple; as by that means much of the animosity' which might otherwise have existed betw two countries had been happily buried. the secession of the American colonies there was no person whom they could choose who could exactly have filled the po: was of pre' principles, as opposed to episcopal principles, was sufficient to determin mont as republican cal, In the cases of the South American colonies similar causes operated, so that on their revolt they nearly all adopted re. publican forms of government; but in one cab where these causes monarchy was eatabli be admitted that government were well as, if not be South American country. But in Europe they would find that in neatly every instance where it had been necessary to found a new government, a monarchy had been chosen, He instanced Belgium, Greece, Italy, and the Turkish princi support of this contention, and argued that the eatablishmout of these monarchies showed that themaintenanceof popular right people having ash cir own government was not con copie of these countries as being intent with monarchical institutions. He lad endeavoured therefore to show, first, that there was no inconsistency between the spread of republicanism and the maintenance of monarchical institutions and, secondly, that there was a growing tendency to adopt a monarchy instead of a choice decided. There remained the question as to which of the two forms of government best fulfilled the conditions of good government. It would be sufficient for him to show that @ constitutional monarchy was as well form of government to ious of good government but he would go further and endeavour to show that it was even better fitted to fulfil these conditions than any other form.

May had laid it down that conditions of a good government, were (1) that it should be in accord the sentiments of the people; (2) that the rulers should be unable for any length of time to act against the will of the majority; and (8) that the government of a te should be representative of. all the ments of its society, With regard to the first point, the gorerumeuts of both Eu gland and the United States were in.accord with the sentiments. of their with regard to the second the was fulfilled at least -as well in England as in America; and with regard to the third the condition was better fulfilled under the British constitutional monarchy than under the American republic. Let them take the distinction between the aristocracy and the plebs. In England it must be admitted that both were ted, whereas in America-it wus a matter of regret to many of its citizens that the patricians of the United States did not have a part in its government. Lastly he submitted. that the Constitution of the United Kingdom fulfilled as fully as any more 80. tha 6 condition of giving to security and liberty. The republics of South America had, with one or two exceptions, utterly failed to give security and liberty to their citizens; and although they had succeeded in this respect. in: the United States they had failed there to make: their government as thoroughly representa-ti of all classes as was the gover: the United Kingdom. They had England practically introduced manhood suffrage without blow being aimed at any class of society, and he had no doubt that in the future, as in the past, all classes of the people would be represented, and that the triple watchword of the republicanism in England would be, as elaewhere, Liberty, Equality and Fraternity—Liberty to do everything but injure your neighbour; that Equalily which was the Dest of all equality—a fair start with power to achieve the highest honours Fraternity, that every class should endeavour to do its duty to every other class.

Mr. Sranxey then rose to lead the oj position, He explained that Mr, Judd, who was to' have performed that task,

duty, an tarkey) had strung had bows sudden! M, et Feige 4 on Shoe Me, Suds notey marder fore the m Toast the framework of that Mr; Judd commenced at ment when all were born tay, equal in the natural relation of parents and children, the ruler and the governed, soon extended, beyond the narrow limits of the family, and as clans and tribes began to be formed, and their mutual relations became more complex, both amongst themselves, and to neighbouring and allied-tribes, it was found imperatively necessary to select a head to guide and represeue the The natural growth of the monarchitem was then tr of the dogma of divine right of hinge then the gradual uprising of the people against the tyranny of their rulers, Even as early as the beginning of the 16th century La Boétie, in his treaties Voluntary Servitude, burst forth thus.

"Wretched sud insensate peopl moured of your misery, and blind to your interests, you suffer your property to be pillaged, your devastated, your houses stripped of their goods, and all this by.one whom you have yourself to power, and whose dignity you mai with your lives. He who crushes you hus but two eyes, two hands, but one body. All that he has more than you comes from you; yours are the many eyes that apy your acts, the many hands that strike you, the many fect that trample you in the dust, All the power with which he-injures you is your own. From indignities that the beasts themeolves would not lure you.can free yourselves by simply willing it, Resolve to serve no more, and you are free, Withdraw your support from the Colossus that crushes you, and it will crumble in the dust, Think of the battles of Miltiades, of Leonidas, and of Themistocles, which, after -two thousand years, are as fresh in the minds of mou

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account