The Archive · 1889

ARE WOMEN TO BE ENFRANCHISED

The verdict of the members of the Shanghai Literary and Debating Society and their friends said, no, after hearing the arguments pro and con on Wednesday night. Between forty and fifty people, about a third of whom were ladies, attended the debate upon the subject in the Philharmonic Hall, thus proving that though the worthy Chairman, General Kennedy, in introducing the speakers, mentioned that the admission of women to the franchise was a burning question in Europe and America, Shanghai has not yet been seriously deranged by the shrieking sisterhood who advocate the overthrow of the tyrant man. Nor does it seem that the oppression of the sex is sufficiently galling amongst us out here, to inspire even a single one of the down-trodden sisters with the courage of her convictions, to come upon the platform, and the burning words of eloquence which one might naturally expect to come from the persons aspiring after liberty all fell from the lips of the oppressor, man, himself. The two orators who led the' affirmative and negative sides of the question were happily described by the Chairman as the young blood of the society, for they tackled the subject, which i- one of such far reaching consequences as to make the sagest statesman pause before committing himself for or against, with recklessness and dogma. tism, each laying down the most sweeping propositions, that fairly showed the Chairman's laconic description to be correct. The speeches of Mr. A. Dallas who cham-piened the cause of the oppressed sex, and of Mr. H. Sharp, who appeared in defence of the oppressor, were too long for anything like even a summary in our column: but in point of argument and logical connection we think that Mr. Dallas's was the better of the two, and bore evidence of elaborate preparation, if not of a more thorough understanding of the question. But his feeble delivery greatly detracted from the interest of his well-reasoned address. He packed his oration well with useful figures to show that the tide of public opinion in England, as shown in the fouse of Commons, was turning towards the political enfranchisement of women, which was first brought into serious attention twenty-two years ago by John Stuart Millin his beckon he Subjection of Woman. After the last General Election, in 1886, there were 283 members out of the total of 670 in the House in favour of granting the sex the power of voting a parliamentary elections. He then proceeded to argue that women were as intellectually qualified to all, of their Protons, fathers and hus-exercise the right of voting a8 many, if not fands, and no doubt his audience agreed with him on this point, and in proof of this assertion he instanced the number of girls who of late years have won appointments in the Civil service at competitive examinations, and also the number of ladies who gain their livelihood by intellect tual employment and pursuits. As an example of their fitness for political life, he availed himself of the prominent part which women have played in elections at home of late years, citing the cases of the Primrose jue and the Ladies' Liberal Union. But he did not attempt to show, which we think was well for his side of the question, that this interference by the fair sex in the sphere of politics was a good thing or was conducive in any way tv beneficial results either to themselves or to the opposite sex. He introduced several extracts from the speeches of prominent politicians upon the subject, and was sanguine enough to see the promise of a reform in the political status of woman, in the utterances of Lord Salisbury at a meeting in Edinburgh in December last, in which the Premier paid a high eulogy to the work of the Primrose League and gave vague hints of a further ex-inmate of Coa vetthge, though be earatally impressed upon his hearers that he did not speak on behalf of the party, but for himself alone when he expressed the hope that the day was not far distant when women would take their share in voting and determining the policy of the country, for which preronatives they were by nature, knowledge, training and character as abundantly fit as many who possess the suffrage. Mr. Shai at the outset that he knew little or nothing followed on the opposite side, and confesse

about the question except what he had learned within a few days and also from the leader onthe other side. Mr. Sharp was more effective with the audience than his opponent by being blessed with thet happy gift, which all young debaters yearn for, the utter absence of nervousness, and good confidence in himself. Mr. Sharp's abilities as a reciter are known outside the ranks of the Literary and Debating Society, but he has yet to learn that it is a more difficult matter to attack a subject of uch dimensions without some preparation, Declamation is not debating. He began by generally traversing his opponent's assertions. Woman, to change the ordinary reading of Mark Twain somewhat, though unsurpassed asa sweetheart, and unequalled as a mother, was best as' sich," and not one woman in Mr. Sharp's opinion and experience possessing the most elementary notion of politics, the whole sex were not qualified to vote. Ina light bantering vein, Spiced with a mild though harmless asteast he proceeded to deal with the case as put forward by the other side, and not having a battery of facts and figures at his disposal he cast about the light shafts of ridicule with more or less effect. He found no doubt fair game in the present form of the Woman's Suffrage Bill which has passed its second reading in the House of Commons, as being an anomalous and somewhat absurd. measure, which put a premium upon the condition which women least desire, spinsterhood or widowhood, by giving onl; this class a vote and debarring marie women from the Franchise. Again he made mild jokes at the Primrose dames and Duchesses whose whole notion of political matters was comprehended in the wearing of a trifling decoration, an imitation of the primrose and the' worship of the statue of Lord Beaconsfield on the 23rd of every April. Matrimony, and not political amelioration, was according to Mr. harp, the goal at which every woman aimed' as the writings of all the great lady novelists would show, and as an example of the intellectual feebleness of the sex he pointed to the absence of a female Shakespeare, a female Milton and a female Byron, and he traversed the proposition that a neral demand was being made by the sex for ensancipation from their present state of thraldom, and pointed with pride to the generosity of his own sox in introducing, and carrying such measures as the Marri Women's Property Act, and the custody of Children Bill, which were in favour of women and against men themselves, A very earnest champion in the person of Mr. Donovan next came out from the body of the audience to demand the admission of women to these political privileges which Mr. Donovan pointed to the vast number have hitherto been monbpolieed by man, of meetings in favour of female suffrage which have been held in recent years in almost every country of Europe, and he advocated the reform not only one of expediency but of abstract right and simple justice. He somewhat surprised his audience'by telling them that women are not only the equals of men intellect tually, but very often physically as well which' they could prove upon compulsion, a statement which created roars of Mr. J. C. Hall followed on the negative side and reminded Mr. Dallas that: Mr. John Stuart Mill obtained his idea of women's suffrage from his wife, and that he misled public opinion in England on the point. Mr. Halldid not think that it would

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account