The Archive · 1891

Miscellaneous Articles

CHINA IN THE HOME PAPERS

29th Sept.

Arter years of neglect the home Press is taking up China, and the Ozus brings us a pile of cuttings from newspapers all over England, which it is almost a day's work to look through. The Times, as might be expected, has the advantage of having the best information, and its two leading articles of the 7th and 14th August show an unusual grasp of the subject on the part of their writer. As a rule the Times manages to get the names of places fairly right, and it does not make the mistake that some of the papers do of thinking that Taotai is a man's name, and remarking that "Taotai said to Mr. Gardner," ete., etc. Yet the home papers have had capital sources of information at their disposal. In the Times of the 8th August was an admire able Jetter from a correspondent at Shanghai, giving a very good resume of the situation, and this letter is freely drawn on by the English Press. It mentioned an incident which occurred at Hankow nearly thirty years ago, illustrative of the value of the old "inevitable gunboat" policy, a polic} wiligh, discredited ae if afterwards wes by trimmers at Peking and doctrinaires at home, was the kindest policy that could be adopted in the interest both of Chinese and foreigners; and this we think the people at home are beginning to see. It so happened that Lieut. George Royle, R.N., who was the naval hero of the incident, was able to corroborate the story of the Times? correspondent, only pointing out that, as far as his recollection went, hours not days elapsed between the outrage on Mr. Little and its punishment; but such discrepancies are to be expected in the recollection of events that occurred thirty years ago. The story, meanwhile, is repeated with great approval by many home papers, and this will strengthen the hands of our naval officers, who have been too much tied up with red tape in late years. It is worth while to-day to quote Mr. Royle's statement of the effect of the vigorous measures he took in the face of a foe outnumbering him by hundreds of thousands; for the Chinaman is the same to-day that he was in 1861 "We took three prisoners and let them go next day. hey said that they would be beheaded for losing their ship if the mandarins caught them. One did get caught, and he reported that I had burnt the other two to death on board the war junk. This the people believe to this day.

"They were said to be so incensed about this that the Taotai (the governor of the city) sent officially to warn me not to land. Thereupon I went ashore alone immediately. Certainty I was mobbed, but the sight ofa revolver and a big stick enabled me to go through and through the city. After {that no one attempted to molest me, jand the English were respected to such an extent that I am not aware of their having had any trouble since till now.

"he foreign residents appreciated the peace and quietness which resulted, though the Saturday Review styled it another holocaust of the inevitable British gunboat.'" rational view that, whether the out-'The home papers generally take the

breaks be directed against foreigners or against the central government, foreign Powers must protect their citizens as a first duty: and we are glad to see that a Hlarge number quote from our columns the excellent dispositions made by Mr. ide Berviéres and Mr. Hopkins, with the assistance of the officers of the [itis, Inconstant, and Palos, for the protection of Kiukiang. But there jate a few exceptions to this rule. \For instance, we find the Sheffield Telegraph very indignant with "highly moral Editors" in England for demand-ling "that a t show of naval force shall be made by the combined squadrons of the nations who chiefly trade {with the Chinese." he writer tells his readers that the Chinese are frugal, industrious, and unoffending; they cultivate the arts of peace; they threaten no neighbour; they seek no quarrel they wish only to be let alone." There jis a half-trath in this, and nothing is more dangerous than a half-trath. The description applies fairly enough, though even then it is a little rose-coloured, to the mass of the Chinese people, but it does not apply at_all to the official class and the Uiterati and gentry. What the writer goes on tosay is nonsense:—"The Rulers of China are entitled to treated with great forbearance. Europeans boasting of their civilisation have made bonfires of populous Chinese \cities, have carried fire and sword to Peking, have sacked the Imperial Palace, land have, while sacking it, wantonly destroyed the art treasures they could not carry away, and they have done all that in them lay to introduce to hundreds of millions of people the use of {an enervating narcotic poison, and to {confirm them in the habit of using it, These truths are well known in England, yet the first impulse of some English Editors on hearing of a few assaults upon Europeans is to demand, in effect, that Christian Europe shall rain fire upon Chinese seaports, and shall thereter claim waggon loads of precious metal to repay them for the cost they j have been at in giving to the Heathen one more—' moral lesson The reference to opium in the above extract comes somewhat unexpectedly after the condemnation of the missionaries which we have had to omit, and the writer evidently did not get all his inspiration from Exeter Hall. The Western Daily Press is also apprehensive about England's action in China, though it allows. that "there appears to be ample justification for the concentration of European war vessels in Chinese waters." the writer is one of the Wolseleyites who think we can rely on China to help us some day in the future against Russia; as if China were a staff that any one could lean on. He says "Tt would, however, be a doubtful policy for England to resort to a policy of coercion by bullet and bayonet in China, even though undertaken in concert, as has been suggested, with Germany, France, and America. China may be a valuable ally for England if Russia should ever overstep the bounds of prudence in furtherance of her designs on India, regarding which Sir Lepel Griffin has just confessed to the conception of a renewed anxiety."

Another. paper, which we presume is an organ of nonconformist Protestantism, is convinced that the real objects of Chinese hatred are the "French foreigners rather than British, or any others and that if active measures are taken by the foreign Powers, " the Jesuits will probably he found' to be the chief gainers." But we are most astonished to find the Globe, that eminently respectable and Conservative old journal, jingo to the core, reprobate ing our being mixed up with any fore ciple demands for reparation. It says:—"Tp the case of England there is very strong reason for abstaining from hostile action either joint or separate. By the force of circumstances China has become her natural ally in Asia; the interests {of both empires are threatened by the same foes north and south. Nothing would please Russia and France better than to inveigle Great Britain into the position of catspaw, to draw the chest nuts out of the political fire for their behoof. And that would undoubtedly be the case were England to take a lead ing part in any warlike reprisals. John Chinaman has not yet either forgotten or forgiven the destruction of the Summer Palace; he is always ready with that historical incident when assured of British friendship. The situation is delicate in the extreme, and no more profound mistake could be committed than to give ready ear to the clamour of the Europeans at the Treaty Ports for a few d'enfer of shot and shell." Ifthe writer had thought for a, moment, he would have realised that the last' power that China would ally herself with, if her alliance were wanted, would be one that treated her weakly.

Some of the papers express great satisfaction with the Imperial Decree in favour of missionaries, and Punch makes it the subject of a rather unfortunate cartoon by Linley Sambourne. This proclamation must be read by the light of the facts stated in Dr. Griffith John's letter which we publish this morning. The vile book which we noticed on Saturday is being reprinted in haste and distributed gratis from the principal pawnshops, and these pawnshops it must be remembered, are the favourite form in which officials, active and retired, invest their savings. Dr. John's letter requires no farther come But ment from na

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account