A very limited audience was present when Mr. Graystou's Bee ted on ' Conscience" was rox on Wednesday. library of the Royal A debate was ities and tame to General Kennedy, U.S. Consul occupied the Chair.
Mr. Graysroy presented himself before the audience as an " humble enquirer after truth" and said the subject was one which had caused him many an hour of anxious thought, in the endeavour to adapt to lof the definition which hi small voice" given to guide by the eternal and infallible Creator, as the director troller of thole actions. It wasa charming, a poe thought to feel that in one' guide, or ever present spiritual adviser, priest that never erred. But unfortunately it was not true, The plain, terse, logical, conclusion of enquiring reason was that the dictates of the conscience of the jot taught by bitter lutely nil. He as-ce was the educa tional development of the inherent instinct of man as a gregarious animal. It was ment that the first germ of conscience came. only, by tue higher educational' develop-To prove that the educate ment was essential to the b inet, he would ask would ti nature hesitate to follow ite first mets of struggling after that nee to its preservation, ge healthy child was cruel, deceitful, cunning, passionate, and revengeful; and as an imple he asked did the boy with " pin through the wing of a beetle, and listening with pleasure to the buzzing noise of the impaled insect, feel any reproach from the voice of conscience. The cone Ip enemy, eaid "Well done, good and faithful servant of the great Being, ao shall you gain the happy hunting geonnd of your fathers," Tustances might be multiplied ad li to show that ce the well known theologian of 'Trinity Col-Cambridge, to bear out hie opi that' men have committed crimes unroproved by the voice of conscience, and he contended that conscience was not an implanted guide or a voice coming from some unknown and unseen power, but the natural outcome of the training and educa tion of the gregarious instincts ut the animal man, Br, Munnay, who rose to criticise the remarks of the lecturer was very glad that he had met, to night for the firet time, specimen of the "anxious enqu truth," who, he held was as sorry that great mer wise, that as people advanced in years they did not also advance in wisdom," He went on to observe that he never heard before that conscience was an unerring guide to the human henrt. The great fault of the paper was that it did not tell the audience what those in jets were, upon which the is argument, writer based 0 was, the quali betwoon right and wrong, and by quoted Roussonu, who compared consol absence of divine inspiration to the dial in absence of the ann, and concluded by giving the words which Shakespoxre puts into the mouth of Kivg Henry I feel i above all earthly digui= a quiet conscience."
W. Joun supported the views of speaker and compared the man who did wrong, and whose con: not reprove him, to the cruatac mammoth caves in Kentucky whic lost the optic nerve through not using it, Conscience was always there, but it was sometimes non-operative.
After a brief reply by Mr. Grayston, to the criticisms passed on the paper, the Chairman took a show of hands for and againat the different views, when six wore held up for the paper, and aixteon for the criticisms, Mr. McKze than, admidat laughter, oxllod for a show of hands of those who did not agree wi when an over! played, A vote of thanks was passed to Mr. Grayaton on the motion of Mr. Wade, who made a brief but humouroi a
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.