The Archive · 1893

THE SOURCES OF THE ANTI-FOREIGN DISTURBANCES IN CHINA

By tue Rev. Giteert Rem, M.a — THE SOURCES AS FOUND IN THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH

(8) A more serious charge than either of the two just mentioned, but an evil less pervasive and general is the shelter extended in a few cases to evil characters by the Roman Catholic Church. It might he possible for the Church of Rome to hold to the policy and right of assuming political power, and yet result in no opposition or conflict, because acting in harmony with the political ideas and schemes of the State; it might also ho possible for its Bishops and priests to extend aid to their converts in their lawsuits without inciting ill-feeling or collision, if skill were shown in the method adopted, so that the effort put forth should appear to be that of friendly mediation rather than of improper interference; but it would be well-nigh imsible to prevent dire effects, if the church, professing the highest purity and sanctity, should shelter in its fold men who are still wicked designers and even villains.

In a previous section we referred to the misconception which the Chinese held as to the good character of the Christian converts, be they Protestant or Catholic, While insisting on all that we there wrote, we must also, as faithful to the facts, acknowledge the point that the presence in the Church of a few bad men has given ocean sion to the general misconception that all converts are bad.

The Roman Catholic Church in some places in China has the very unsavoury reputation of " being good at litigation," Itis also stated by outsiders, and we have heard it confessed by some of its own members, that in order to open up workin a nev district, that Church has offered assistance to parties engaged in certain lawsuits. We ourselves have no extensive acquaintance with Roman converts, and cannot speak authoritatively from personal observation. Others who are equally competent in judging correctly have testified that here and there disrepute able men, and especially those who are proficient in managing lawsuits and preparing accusations for the Chinese courts, have entered that Church and exerted ' their Ped" rumours are set agoing, which in due wwers in their special forte. As a result

time enlarge into slanders, and any disturbance aroused against priest or convert is looked upon as even meritorious. It should also be remembered that in every lawsuit there are two parties, and if one side is victorious through the ai of the priest the other side will cherish a deep resentment. Among the Chinese there is a general fear to offend another or make an enemy, and no doubt some of this fear, or at' least caution, would be highly expedient for foreigners in their religious propaganda.

following language: " While this right of The Rev. Dr. Giang of Canton uses the seyluin aay often defend the persecuted Christian from oppression, it also now, as in the middle ages, sometimes gives shelter tothe guilty. Hence the Chinese officials complain that the Christian Churches become refuges for men who refuse to pay their taxes, and are even guilty of crime." He then mentions a case, which illustrated some of the hostile feeling during the riots in that section in 1884: "It is commonly reported that a man in Canton for whose arrest 8 reward of $1,000 was offered, joined the Roman Catholics, ard the priests said, you cannot touch him, he is one of our people."

That such an impression has gone forth is no doubt grieved over and even resented by the authorities of that Church, but there must have been here and there some ground for the impression and not mere talk, as the Chinese say, "from an empty belly." In one section where collisions have occurred for upwards of twenty years between the Christian and non-Christian, the Taotai who exerted himself to bring about: peace, and showed real friendliness to the Catholic Fathers, recommended that the Bishop should not only restrain his own converts, but communicate with the Bishop of an adjoining diocese to check the rough unruly members of the church, who had. a reputation for making trouble and infringing the rights of others, That no ground fof complaint existed not even the Bishop deigned to assert. And this must be true in other cases as well.

the Memorial of the Tsungli Yamen in 1891 there is given full and hearty recognition of the benevolent and charitable labour of the missionaries, and there is added a brief insinuation as to the converts. "Though among the native converts," it says, good and bad are to be found, still they are subjects of China and areamenable to the jurisdiction of local authorities." Such a conclusion is a decided advance on that made by the same body twenty years before, when it said: Since the conclusion of the Treaties took place (1860) the majority of the converts are persons out virtue." At that time not only did it make this general charge, but supported it by particular cases, giving the names of persons and places, Thus it gave the names of certain converts in Szechuan who had instigated conflicts, which resulted in the death of the non-Christians, and then added the following definite instance of wrong doing: The Christians again, under the leadership of a priest, named Tan Fu-chin, killed Chao Yung-lin, and 200 other persons. The surrender of this son was demanded, but the Abbé Mihires said that he had left for Europe, and that there were no means of arranging this case. Hence great anger among the in-inhabitants of Szechuan." Further on, it mentioned the case of a certain missionary who killed a Russian, of certain converts in Kueichow who " committed all sorts of disturbances," and of certain leaders of a band of rebels embracing the Catholic religion and continuing "to stir up indescribable and countless disturbances and troubles."

The Rev. Pbre Louvet, referring to this memorandum, speaks, of it as "filled with calumnies against the missionaries and their works." It is beyond our province to investigate the truthfulness or falsity of these statements, but we are inclined to believe that the Prince and Ministers of the Chinese Government would not dare to make libellous charges in a memorandum sent openly to all the Legations in Peking. At least we have heard of no refutation, unless the reply of the United States Minister to the Fcthermsore, from what we have heard neral complaint be regarded as such.

through foreigners who have visited these two provinces of Szechuan and Kueichow, as well as from Chinese officials who have lived there, we judge that such instances could easily have occurred in these places during the decade between the years 1861 and 1871. It should be noted, moreover, that it is only these two provinces which furnish most of the' proofs to the particular es, and hence the Roman Catholic Church throughout all China should not be condemned merely by what has occurred in a certain section during practically a transition period.

Tu this memorandum, after referring to particular converts of the Catholic Church, there occurs this sentence: "They were perpetually at the yamen, and undertook

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account