27th May. Tue April issue of the Imperial and Asiatic Quarterly Review opens with six articles on the recent Anglo-French Convention with reference to Siam. With the aid of this multiplicity of councillors we ought to be able to make up our minds as to the value of the Convention to England, France, China, and Siam.
HN. D Brendetae ton, v0, The The opening paper is by General Sir
title of his paper is "Prance and Siam," and he begins with a slight sketch of early French relations with Indo-China, a subject which has been more fully treated in Mr. Gundry's China and her Neighbours. General Prendergast goes on to predict that France will soon definitely annex the large slice of Siam which Lord Salisbury has assigned to her as her sphere of influence. It is only 80,000 square miles, "and the intention of France to pursue this course is sufficiently indicated by the continued occupation of Chantaboon by French troops." Lord Salisbury and Mr. Curzon have done their best to depreciate the commercial importance of this eastern portion of Siam; but it includes Khorat, to which the Siamese are building a railway from Bangkok, as it is the centre for the trade of all north-eastern Siam, M..de Lanessan has always urged that the project of constructing the Bangkok-Khorat railway should be thwarted by every possible means; the French object being to divert the trade of Khorat to some French port to the east of Bangkok, and this will, of course, now be done. General Prendergast quotes M. de Lanessan to prove the value of the Great Lake and the provinces of Angkor and Battambang, which the convention throws into Prance's lap. "Francehaving a definite forward policy appears as the prominent party to the declaration of 1896, she has virtually secured a vast territory and has adopted Siam as a buffer between French Indo-China and Burma; she has gained possession of Mongsin and of two districts of China and has done much to strengthen her own mercatitile position and to exclude England from access through Burma to Yunnan. The policy of France was indicated by the writings of explorers and others at earlier dates and was clearly set forth by M. de Lanessan in 1886, and Great Britain has looked on at the rapid expansion of France without making any serious effort to inter-fore; she has deliberately allowed port his princely enterprise will meet its due after port, of which the commerce be-reward; he will certainly be raised to Ionzed to the merchants of Great the stars' by collation into the pages of some. subsequent edition of his own; Prance with the result that crushing Britain, to pass into the hands of. felon serious, omplte ud of excead- 'UBRT* uns bare Hee rear work for having done at least "one ingly great magnitude. withstanding this, General Prendergast comes to the rather inconsequent conclusion that; if the Siamese vastly augment the production of the Menam Valley: and if we build a railway from complete the line from Mandalay to Kuniong Ferry; and if we get the West River opened to British trade, as well as the Yangtze right up to Yunnan; if we do all this, " British mercantile interests will be well served, and it may be predicted that England, France, Siam, and China will all benefit by the declaration of 1896." The General concludes with a truism, which we wish our Foreign Office would take to heart. "Russia has shown the advantage of a fixed policy in Asia by extending her borders from the North and West. France has' realised the profit of a fixed forward policy la Indo-China, The inaction of China has resulted in defeat and loss of territory. It seems absolutely necessary that England too shall have a fixed policy in the Far East."
"The second paper is headed "The Mekorg-Menam arrangement," and is by Major-General A. R. McMahon. He begins by remarking that he recommended on the Ist of January, a fortnight before the Convention" was signed, that with the view of saving Slam, she should be converted into a buffer between England and France, and made the Belgium of the East. He also gives a slight sketch of early French relations with Siam, He appears to approve of the Convention because while it relieves Siam sooner or later of two-thirds of her territory, it guarantees to her the remaining third, the argument apparently being that one-third guaranteed is better than three-thirds held precariously. He gives a long quotation from Lord Salisbury's explanatory letter accompanying the convention, with which we have already dealt, and winds up by saying "T fully endorse the hope entertained by Her Majesty's Government which is referred to in his Lordship's concluding paragraph, and also believe that a preponderance of favourable opinion should be allotted to a settlement so admirable, which among other desirable things, gives promise of the opening out of Yunnan, said by experts to be the "richest untapped market in the world." Gen, MacMahon's paper is on the whole what we might expect fom man who can gravely repeat such nonsense about such a poor province as Yuanan, The third paper, and this is the last we have space to deal with this: morning, is by a man who at any rate knows his subject, Mr. W. A. Pickering, cata. It is headed "The Mekong 'I'reaty and the Malay Peninsula," and Mr. Pickering begins by showing how slow we have been to extend our protectorate over the Malay States, while other nations are in the habit of accusing us of maintaining a constant policy of "grab." He points out that while the Siamese portion of the Malay Peninsula is now acknowledged by France to be within our sphere of influence, he "cannot see that France has guaranteed to act with us in case any other European Power should choose to take advantage
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.