The Archive · 1896

CHINESE PHILOSOPHY

2nd June.

In the Dfonist, a quarterly magazine published at Chicago, are found high-class articles by Professors on various philosophical subjects. In the number for January, 1896, there is a translation of a lecture by Professor August Weismann on germinal selection which defends Darwin's hypothesis of natural selection against the doubts thrown on it by Haus Driesch and by Huxley, who said that even if the Darwinian hypothesis were swept away evolution would stand where it is. The great difficulty Weismann acknowledges in natural selection as a philosophy is that we can never tell whether an observed variation in species is useful or not. Variations seem to be accidental. It remains to be discovered by some happy thinker why the useful variations are always successful securing permanence. Wilhelm Roux has added to Darwin's view the struggle for existence of parts in every organisation. Weismaun says, if the parts participate with the whole organism in the battle of life, then every atom must have a share too in the same battle. Weismann proceeds to develop from this basis his theory of germinal selection, Symmetrical parts show usually the same variations and to this is due very much of the utility of the newly developed variations, as in the human hand and foot, But if the animal needs that they should differ, then they differ, For instance, in the eyes of the sole the two visual halves vary differently, Such is an example of modern philosophy in Western countries, of its aims and its results, With this the Chinese philosophy is in strong contrast. Yet Dr. Paul Carus praises it very highly in an elaborate article in the same number of the Jonist. He says there is in the Chinese conception of the universe very much that appears to us as self-evident and unquestionably correct on a prion consideration. There doubt, he says, that Yao, Shua, and Ya were historical personages and they re~ present an epoch of civilisation which has never been reached again by the Chinese. Public works were undertaken, such as regulating the course of great rivers, and the sciences of mathematics and astronomy flourished. Eclipses. of the sun and moon were calculated and we know that the brothers Hi and Ho observed and calculated the planetary revolutions, and further we possess in the Shuking documents that give evidence of manliness and moral stamina commanding our respect, The speech delivered by the son and successor of the worthy Yii in B.C. 2197 reminds Dr. Carus of the famous address of Frederick the Great to his generals before the battle of Leuthen. He says the Viking is one of the most enigmatic books on earth and its mystery is The North - China Herald and Supreme Court & Consular Gazette (1870-1941); Jun 5, 1896: considered by many as beyond all hope of solution; and yet it exercises. a greater influence over the minds of the Chinese than does the Bible in Christian countries. He adds in speaking of the Great Extreme, or the Monism of Chinese philosophy, that Chou Tun-yi who worked it out is the first systematic thinker of China and certainly deserves the title of Prince in the Empire of Reason, conferred on him after his death. Laotze may be deeper, Confucius more influential, Mencius more versatile, but none of them is more methodical, none of them is more precise and clear in comprehension than Chou Tun-yi, and there is only one who is his equal; his great disciple, Chu Hsi.

Ds. Carus has spoken too highly of Chou Tun-yi, The work he did was eclipsed by that of the later philosophers of the Sung dynasty, and besides, although he was orthodox in a certain way, he exerted no great moral influence. The fame of Confucius and Mencius is that of men who saw the importance of morality and based on it their system of instruction. It was the result of Chou fan-yi's work that the attention of students was drawn off from moral philosophy to metaphysical cosmogony. His aim is in the Map of the Great Extreme to show how the actual universe was formed from an original unity. One becomes two as we see in light and darkness, the "grateful vicissitude of day and night" out of this duality came the fivefold division of fire, water, metal, wood, and earth, Who grand cause moving produces light, reaching the limit it rests, and rest causes the appearance of Yin. Yang and Yin interchange and during a year their changes produce variety of temperature, variety in the length of the day, and variety in the forms of terrestrial life. He represents the original unity as a hollow circular blank. 'I'he five elements at their origin receive each one its own nature, when combined they produce man and woman. Each sex embraces in itself the five elements in suitable proportions and is therefore represented also by a blank circle. Such is the philosophy of Chou Tun-yi. If a Chinese of the modern school is asked what he thinks of it, he will say it is a one-sided system of thought, not comparable to the teachings of the Four Books; such a condemnation of Chou Tun-yi is right. His system explains nothing. It fails to recognise God and substitutes spontaneous evolution for a reasonable origin of the world. Confucianism is good because it is moral. "The system of ChouT'un-yi is worth little because he adds to the Confucian motrality an essentially speculative and superficial nomenclature, without any honest research. What are the five elements but a feature borrowed from the Persian philosophy Persia borders on Babylonia and has been for five thousand years the home of an educated lass. Before Zoroaster and in Zoroaster's time the five elements were a part of the teaching of the reflecting minds of that country. lhe Yin and Yang of China were in the classics of China and formed the dualism of Persia before they were adopted by the later philosophers of the Central Flowery land. The Sung dynasty philosophy is indeed a remarkable philosophy but its results are of no great' value, Thomas 'I'aylor Meadows in his. work on the Chinese and their Rebellions has said that Chou 'I'an-yi is constituted by his writings the definitive fashioner of the Chinese mind. here is a great error in this statement. It was the moral system of the classics and the political philosophy of the classics that gave to China its admiration for the principles of filial piety and dynastic loyalty. The doctrine of the five elements stands in the way of true science and checks honest enquiry. The Chinese would be better for a new philosophy based not on a formula of empty wames like that of Chou fun-yi but on reverence and industry, love and truth, justice and thrift, prudence and altruistic sacrifice, he good features in the teaching of Chinese antiquity have in fact made the nation. If then we find in a scheme of philosophy the omission both of the divine and of the moral element it is and must be very unsatisfactory, 'This is the reason that no enlightened Chinese thinks anything now of the philosophy of the Great Extreme, It had its day, and its day is gone for ever, Chu Hsi was weak' enough to uphold it by his vote and influence. Buddhism was for him a system too unsubstantial and too inconsistent with the instincts of our common human nature to satisfy a thinker born in the land of Confucius, It is a pity that he andah the more famous writers of his time, Chou, Shaou Chang, and the brothers Ch'eng, should have thought they could find a valuable philosophy in the Book of Changes over and above what Confucius formed there. They committed this great mistake. The Book of Changes is a treatise on divination of which the substratum is in moral teaching, and much of its special value consists in its archaeology. We can find in it what ancient men believed and thought because it is a very ancient book; but we claim that the Sung philosophy in studying the Great Extreme aimed with misdirected energy to construct an unscientific evolution destitute of any principle of solid utility. To this it was led by the atheistic philosophy of the Buddhists having preceded it. Dr, Caras does not estimate the effect of Buddhism son Chinese thought, nor that of Zoroiastrianism, nor that of the astronomy sind mathematics of Babylonia. It was ithe arithmetic of Babylonia that gave ito the Book of Changes the remarkable ioumerical system which excited the admiration of Leibnitz, Two centuries sign Leibuitz wrote te Pare Bouvet in Peking that he had found reason to think that binary arithmetic was known

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account