Rerererme to the quarrel between Sir) Morell Mackenzie and the Geran doctors, from the'point of view of the general critic, ays it will be hard for the istify themselves from a boorish and brutal pedantry; and it will be equally hard for the English doctor to justify self from the charge of indiscreet condescension to the curiosity of the vulgar. The Spectator remarks that it is quite natural that disinterested outsiders reading the savage controversy between the English and German throat doctors in the case of Emperor Frederick, should feel a little irritated as well as disgusted. And this seems the general view in England. But Truth says it is absurd to blame Sir Morell Mac-Kenzie for taking up the cudgels in his own defence, as he only acted in obedience to the commands of exalted persons whose wishes ¢j, a vast field and so many problems to con-try than because he offers such lecture and erudition, If all the classics Inirdy but, "generally epesking, one who stood between the Lord and the Laird, in
yunt ing ground of scholiasts, "In France, even ed, Shakspeare would remain a hay respect of blood, acres and.culture, Or, to put the distinction in another way, every view Williams was an idol of Roman-Scotch gentleman was of necessity a laird, tic in, it may be guessed that his faults were but every Scots laird was not of necessity a not fous the least amiable portion of his work. Here were good Toledo blades, here gentleman." And this is the writer's idea was Ercles vein, here mere bloodshed, dag-of an old Scots gentleman and gentle-gers, passion in tatters, and many a massacre woman coram popula. Of course men like Gautier The old Scotch gentleman was often weak felt the romance of A" You Like It and The in grammar; he was frequently improvident Aideummer, Nights Dream, and it la inv he was in the habit of drinking deep, and anid, But ie may be guessed tat Shak ible that poets should miss the poetry of bandying rude jests with edinburgh advocates, clergymen, and Lords of Session, He was a speare was welcomed less for his immortal little of a tyrant, and a great deal of a Tory. qualities than for his differences from Racine But he was not much of a sycophant, aid and Corneille, and all that loves a perruque. oftener espoused the side of the Scotch' com. In M, Jules Lemaitre's criticism of M. Mounet monalty against the Scotch aristocracy, than Sully''s Hamlet, it is plain that the reviewer the representatives of that, commonalty in the thinks Racine' could have written a better day are inclined to credit him with Hamlet, if (like William Wordsworth) "he ing done, When opportunity came his had had the mind." French opinion remains or when an inspired ploughmian appeared as it was in that earliest French reference to Scotland, he was not above playing the part Shakspeare which M. Jusserand lately dis-ofa rough but not unkindly Macenas, covered. Shakspeare is to, them a rude even of sagacious adviser. But he is gone.
a man of considerable parts almost Gone, too, iden by monstrous blemishes of taste. "the good old Scottish gentlewoman, Jules Claretie is reported to have said that Who, faithful to the good old way, still span, worshipped than in France." Nowhere, and "'nowhere had Shakspeare been more ardently And spoke the good old Scotch, the classic tongue never more ardently, we may add, than by Not of a province, but an ancient realm." M. Philoxtne Boyer, but not by the other lity, when The old Scotch genilewomen retained their he was bound to respect. It also points out that although the German doctors protest, with a unanimity that would delight the heart of a stage manager, that Sir Morell Mackenzie's counter attack on then is unworthy of notice, they are taking a good deal of pains to reply to it, all the sane. Underthetitle of Heterobiography" the Saturday replies to a series ace rumours which have appeared in sun 13, notably Truth and the Pall "Mall-an to the sale, the Editorship, and circulation of the per. It gives ten of these assertions strictly authentic," none of which are true. That active imaginative creature the London correspondent of provincial newspapers is often the author of such statements. The threatened great coal Dans les salons de Philoxéne Nous tions quatre-vingts rimeurs.
There are two pleasant articles—on visiting Paris in the early days of the eighteenth century and on the cooking, preserving and wine making of our grandmothers and great grandmothers.
The Spectator, writing of Mr. Balfour's speech at Haddington, says of the hope of the Tory party We are not able always cordially to like Bir. Balfour's speeches. They often leave 2 impression on the reader, and still mor, 22 the hearer, that while the speaker has,°.9? up his mind, is intellectually conver og J"and intends to act on his conviction. b-, ips little moved by his own conviction "44 py is ponent's argument, Mr, Bal 900, thing the suliarities longer than their less home-keeping husbands and brothers; they even spoke Scotch, when their grocers' daughters, had begun to speak English, Where now is to be found such a gentlev; oman as the almost centenarian Mrs. Vio'et MacShake of Mias Ferrier, tall, hard of fe-seure, and sharp of to rallies her 9" and nephew before his 4 nth Car', ylian ferocity of improvements, hints "aot her grandniece is a puir, feckless Wir slestrae"—but presents her with a pair of "aamond earrings—and looks back with Pride over her ninety years to the time when Sver'erosmmed'to may their heeds war, their ain i? thee days—wife an' servants, releeners an' childer, a' trammels i' the presence o' their heed." Mrs. MacShake has been evicted from her agyial lodging in the Old Town of Edinburgh. But has not some national chat~ acter, if not virtue, gone with her
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.