Ca., furniture dealers of Nanking Road, deposed—I have supplied furniture worth Tls. 728 to the accused on the hire system, and have received $102 for the hire. I have been to the premises since the fire and all the furniture is there with the exception of that in the office, which has been. burnt, except a copying-press.
By the Magistrate—When I went to the house after the fire I noticed the walls were damaged. and the floor was all dirty.
Sung Ping-song, a coolie in the employ of Mr. Bullard, was re-called and questioned concerning the evidence he gave at the former hearing. He said when he discovered the fire Mr. Hart's office door was open; witness opened the outside door.
By the Magistrate—When I noticed the glare I went and shouted but could get no answer, so I presumed Mr. Hart was out Mr. Hart went by my room at half-past nine going into his own. T did not see him go out. When he came in it was about 9.30. I saw the signs of the fire at 10.15. The first thing I saw was a glare through room, I heard a noise ax vf a gas glops the office window which is opposite to my fell and I got up and saw the fire. T do not know whether Mr. Hart's servants sleep on the premises or not. They belong to Ningpo, and I belong to Pootung, His Worship—He need not be frightened; have Mr. Hart's servants a. bed-room: or room of any kind? They do not sit. on the staircase the whole day—I have never been inside the place so I cannot say.
Capt. Mackenzie explained that Mr. Hart's premises were shut off by a door like a separate flat.
His Worship remarked that it was strange the witness should not have had the curiosity to find out.
Capt. Mackenzie—Quite so, but he may not of necessity know the internal arrangements of the house, His Worship—Are there any people besides Mr. Bullard and Mr. Hart who live 1 that compound?—No. On the second storey a Chinese shroff has an office. I do not know if anybody else sleeps in the house.
His Worship—It is very strange. Does he know whether Mr. Hart's doors are locked when Mr. Hart goes out or are they left open?—I do not know.
His Worship—Has he been told by anybody to be careful of what he says in Court? He has not been told to tell something and keep something back?—No.
Accused—He says he does not know whether my doors are locked when I go out, and still he stated that he went into the place and called, so that he admits it must have been open.
His Worship—When he first saw the fire had broken out, and when he opened the door, he saw the door leading into the office wide open Witness—Yes, the office door was open.
His Worship—How does he know the time?
Witness—By the Customs clock, which had just chimed the quarter.
Capt. Donald Mackenzie was then sworn. He said—Since the remand was granted last Monday I have made a more thorough examination of the premises, and you will see on the plan (produced) that there is a. place marked ''kitchen." On examination of the house we found in there, close alongside the stove, a large heap of torn Tie floor is of wood, except where around per, apparently newspaper, on the floor, the stove a piece of tin has been put, which has a piece about a foot and a half either worn or torn out of it. Alongside this is about 50 or 60 Ibs. of coal.
His Worship—60 or 60 tons?
Witness—Pounds. On the top of the burnt paper had apparently been placed a wooden stool which is burnt on all four sides. I also found the outer door, leading into the office where the fire took place, must have been locked as well as the inner one, which we broke open. I deduce this from the fact that the bolt of the door is still shot, and in the lintel of the door is a small bit of brass, which is broken, and the wood work is burnt away. There is no key to the door, and I presume the door was locked by someone outside and the key taken away. Lalso produce a letter which was found on Mr. Hart's mantelpiece, sent to him by gentleman in Corea. The letter is dated the 2Ist of September, and by the envelope it arrived here from Japan on the 29th.
Accused—The letter is entirely a private one.
Capt. Mackenzie—I admit that Accused—I have no objection to your Worship reading the whole of it, but I do object to Capt. Mackenzie reading it in public.
Capt. Mackenzie—I admit it is a private letter, and if it had been possible in the course of my duty I should not have brought it forward.
His Lordship—Are there any passages. Which you we ike to point out
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.