We are anxious to see the Japanese succeed in Formosa. It was with the approval of Great Britain that Japan took the island, our Government being anxious that it should not fall into more dangerous hands; and we do want to have to confess that after all the Chinese know how to govern Chinamen. It should not be done by extermination; by making " solitude and calling it peace. When the stories first reached us of the way in which small Japanese commands were harrying the interior of the island, we abstained from publishing what we hoped were exaggerated rumours; and when our telegram came from Amoy denouncing the atrocities of the Japanese in Formosa, we trasted that it was only the dacoits whom they were bent on exterminating. The correspondence, however, that.is printed in our columns this week leaves little room for doubt that they have nation which governs itself so well at home, should achieve such a ghastly failure when it attempts the administration of a dependency. It is true that the statements on which this conclusion is based are to a great extent one-sided; for though the. letters sent us come from three independent and thoroughly impartial writers, much of their information was necessarily derived from Chinese, It is noticeable that as the foreigners in Seoul heartily welcomed the Japanese at first, and were only disenchanted by seeing how the latter behaved themselves, so the foreigners in South Formosa, after thei experience of Liu Yung-fa and his followers, welcomed the Japanese at first and have been subjected to the same disenchantment. It is true also that the Japanese have had much provocation in the interior of Formosa; where opportunity offered the Chinese dacoits—which is the most convenient and intelligible term for them—have ruthlessly massacred and mutilated small parties of Japanese; but this does not warrant the wholesale destruction of villages of agriculturists, men, women, and children. These are the methods of the Arabs in Africa, not of really civilised Power, While, in a word, there are excuses for Japan's failure, there is no doubt that the conquering country has so far failed. Partly, no doubt the failure is due to the Japanese Government having been unwilling to send a sufficiently large force, with leaders of sufficient standing, into such an unhealthy country, where the soldiers have not the excitement of actual warfare to keep them out of mischief and in health. To scatter little bodies of men under young sud irresponsible officers who have not, as the officers of our army in India have, the instinct of conciliating subject races, is to invite disaster. It must be remembered, too, in comparing our subjugation of Burma, for instance, with the attempt of the Japanese to subjugate Formosa, that our officers have the prestige of being regarded by the Burmese as belonging to a superior race, and the Japanese have no such prestige to assist them in their dealings:
with the Chinese.
Yhe Japanese as a. people are not unlike their country; outwardly gentle,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.