The Archive · 1889

The Telegraph Convention

Ist Oct

Ir is gratifying to know that, as the following telegram from Colonel Denby shews, the protest of the Hongkong and Shanghai Chambers of Commerce was not altogether too late Peking, 17th Oct., 1889, 11.30 a.m. Chamber of Commerce, Shanghai. I have circulated your telegram for the information of my colleagues. Understand telegraph convention not yet ratified. As Minister of the United States have asked Yamen to await protest. Dexsy."

The article we print in another column from a well-informed source gives full particulars of the strenuous attempt that is being made to bind the foreign communities in the $2 fetters, and take away China's independence; and the unexpected return from Hongkong of the Manager nected with the fortunate delay in the telegraph Company is no doubt con-ike ce the Eastern Extension

ratification of the Convention. This delay, we are informed, arose through a change at the last moment in the terms as to the time of building the Chinese line to Kiachta, and this gave the Tsungli Yamen a door to through. The change was that the Kiachta line should be built within five years instead of after five years. The whole use of the Kiachta line, however, to all except Russian subjects, depends on the Convention. If that is ratified, and the rate of $2 a word maintained, but few messages will be sent by Kiachta; but if China preserves her independence, builds the line, and joins the International Convention, we shall have telegraphic rates down to $1 a word, and the Chinese will get a fair share of the traffic.

There is one stipulation in the new Convention which is perhaps hardly understood generally, and which ought to have decided all the foreign ministers, except M. Coumany, to oppose it as a district breach of the most-favoured-nation clause in their treaties, Messages to all other countries but Russia passing over the Chinese line to Kiachta are to pay China five francs a word, while messages to Russia are only to pay to francs. We should hardly have expected to find an English Company and an English Minister supporting such a stipulation as this. This is a direct premium of three francs word to Russian trade, and would quite explain, if there were no other considerations, M. Coumany's anxiety to get the Convention ratified. By' the most-favoured-nation clause in the various treaties with China, privileges granted to one nation may be claimed by every other, so that if the Foreign Ministers generally do their duty, they will claim a reduction of three francs a word when, if ever, the Convention is ratified. It is obviously unfair to make an American or British' or German merchant pay five francs a word on his message, when his Russian competitor only pays two; and the Chambers of Commercecan appeal to the International Convention against this preference. It is easy to understand why the Telegraph Companies have endeavoured to throw so much mystery over their negotiations, and have only promised to publish the Convention after it has been ratified. People whose objects are unimpeachable are not so anxious to prevent the world knowing what they are doing. Memiwhile the Convention is not ratified yet, and it would be well for the Chauber of Commerce here to telegraph tothe Chamber in London, as the Hongkong Chamber did to this, and enlist its coucurrence in the opposition. One thing they may rely on, that the information we have been able to collect on the subject is thoroughly trustworthy.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account