10th Nov.
Stnce the late war with Japan, the Customs service has become, in a greater degree than before, an institution whose welfare and good management are matters. of international importance. Being, as it is, the only sound security for recent and past loans, the only negotiable asset that China has been able to place against her heavy liabilities, its position has become thereby more secured and, at the same time, more open to criticism by all interested parties, Expecially, therefore, does it behave England. to see that the counsels and control of the service be wisely ordered and effectively carried out; for not only does England represent a large percentage of China's creditors, but, on account of her preponderating influence in trade, it is evidently her duty to obtain for those interests the leading voice and guiding hand in the service's administration, hat this was the view of English statesmen was evident in the late loan negotiations; as evident, in fact, as the eagerness displayed by the Franco-Russian alliance to oust British interests from their present position, It will not be well, however, if England rests content with having averted the dangers which threatened at that juncture; it remains for her to ensure such an administration at the Foreign Inspectorate, both now and hereafter, as shall disarm the hostile criticism of other bondholders. 'M'hat there has been room for such criticism at various times, and especially during the late war, few will deny.
The service is a purely international institution, and in its administration lies the difficult. task of serving many masters. But recent events have greatly affected its position in one respect, viz., that whereas heretofore its revenue was mortgaged to a comparatively small extent, there is now, practically speaking, a lien on the whole security; and this lien is not likely to be removed so long as the Chinese system of government remains what it is. This state of affairs naturally affects the respective positions ofthe mortgagees, the Chinese Government, and the Inspectorate-General, and would now justify an interference in control which formerly would have been impossible. For this reason it behoves England, as the most interested party, to aim at placing the Administration upon the soundest, most prosperous, and most permanent footing possible. In saying this we do not mean to detract one iota from the high praise due to the present Inspector-General, nor to criticise for one moment his wonderful capacity for organisation and effective control. 'The service, as it is, is of his making; and it stands forth perhaps the most wonderful monument to the genius and labour of one man which the century has' produced. It will require the larger perspective of posteri to do full justice to the life-work of Sir Robert Hart, let the present day honour him as it may. But he—none better—is aware that in the administration of his service lie grave difficulties and serious defects. Its internal finances have been for many years in an unsatisfactory state owing partly to increased expenditure, and partly to the depreciation of silver, a factor which has told seriously against its position. Then tuo in the uncertainty which has beset, and which still besets, the question of its continuity on existing lines, there lies a grave source of danger. 'I'hat the present I.-G. has virtually controlled the entire Inspectorate single-handed for over thirty years may have been of the greatest good to China during that period, but there is no doubt that much insecnrity arises from the fact that at this moment he cannot point to any one man, or body of men, trained and ready to carry on his work. Autocracy, like' many other good things, has its disadvantages. But, let us not forget that Sir Robert Hart has always laboured under the difficulty of serving many masters, and whatever defects we may observe in the present system are probably defects which he has been unable, however willing, to remove, It isone thing to advise the T'sungli Yamen and another to ensure the adoption of advice; in this particular, the mortgagees of China's revenue have a distinct advantage over Sir Robert Hart, for they can speak, not as servants, but as wasters of the position. They can insist on the removal of anything which endangers their vested interests.
The political and financial status of the Customs are matters on which it appears to us unadvisable to touch at the moment; we are concerned to-day rather with its personnel. This latter, in an international service, must ever be a subject requiring the most careful management and consideration. 'l'o say that the welfare of the administration depends upon the personnel is unnecessary; to maintain it ina high state of discipline and efficiency, and to ensure the prevalence of esprit de corps and a healthy tone amongst its members, should be the aim of all who have its best interests at heart. That these latter attributes have greatly diminished in recent years is a fact patent to every resident in the East where formerly they existed, we now meet with feelings of discontent and uneasiness for the future. That this is partly due to political and financial aspects, we may admit; but there is another factor, viz., the absence of superannuation, which has for some time been making itself keenly felt. It speaks volumes for the kindness of heart which has always characterised the Inspector-General that no rales have ever been formulated by him on this subject. In the younger days of the service they were naturally unnecessary; but the time has come when it would appear imperative that some steps should be taken to remove the congestion which prevails in the subordinate ranks. As things are to-day, promotion, except in cases of arbitrary selection, has become so slow as to compare unfavourably with that of other and better paid government services so slow, in fact, as to cause among the younger employes a permanent feeling of discontent. In all government administrations the necessity for compulsory resignation of senior men, after certain specified terms of service, is recognised; where general efficiency and satisfaction are aimed at sach a measure is unavoidable. It may be said that the Customs have no pensions; but, on the other hand, the septennial sterling bonuses may well be considered to represent in the case of long-service men an ample equivalent.
From the last Customs Service List we gather that in the case of the 13 Senior Commissioners the average period of service is over 31 years, and their average term as Commissioners is about 23 years, nine having served in that capacity for over 24 years. ''urning next to the Deputy Commissioners we note that they number 16, with an average service of 20} years; next come 2 Senior Assistants of 37 years' standing and-16 First Assistants whose average is 22 years, We need not follow our enquiry through all the lower grades, but when we observe that it requires, generally speaking, over 21 years for an employe to reach a salary of T's. 225 a month, we cease to wonder at whatever discontent such employes may occasionally express with their condition. 'I'he man who has served 30 years, with the liberal pay and allowances of a Commissioner for 20 years of that period, should be in a position after that time to make room for his juniors—in any other service he would be compelled to do so—even though his mental and physical capacities for work be in no wise impaired and it is evident that unless he does so, there is slight hope for younger meu to attain to the posts in which lies a possibility of providing for old age. It is impossible for an Inspector-General or the Chinese Government to expect hearty service or to obtain enthusiasm, from an employe who, after ten or twelve years' work, finds himself on the salary of a second-rate clerk; and it will be equally impossible for the Customs Administration to preserve its former high standard of men and recognised efficiency of work if such conditions continue to prevail.
We make these comments in no spirit of gratuitous criticism. As Englishmen, we are proud of the service that Englishmen have founded and maintained. The machine isa good one, but its flaws, evident and palpable, call for and deserve recognition by all who would work for its maintenance. If these flaws be due to the Chinese Governmemt, there are now interested parties enough to have them remedied; but in any case, the personnel of the Customs should henceforth, by virtue of recent events, be
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.