The Archive · 1891

What Is to Be Done

7th Oct.

Me "communicated" article which we pobticias on Monday shows more regard for the Chinese government than most of us are willing to see displayed at the present juncture. The writer of that article holds that "it would be a mistake for foreign Powers to interfere at the present juncture, beyond such measures as are absolutely necessary for the preservation of the lives and property of their nationals, and using such pressure as is needed to secure action on the part of the government commensurate with the issues at stake, and affording all moral support in this her time of trial.... Rebellion is in the air, and it is by no means certain that it can be averted. The conditions, however viewed, are critical. All necessary pressure should be used by foreign Powers to secure proper action ers on the part of the Chinese government, while at the same time great care should be exercised not to give the least countenance or aid to those who are seeking the overthrow of the government." That is to say, that in the triangular duel in which we are now engaged, we are not to fire at the Chinese government because by so doing we assist the Kolao Hui; and obviously as our grievance is against the Chinese government, we must not fire at the Kolao Hui, which, after all, is at present only a shadowy antagonist.

consider that this is very bad advice, in the state of things at which we have now arrived. Foreign Powers have, as we have said before, gradually accumulated a long list of grievances against the Chinese government, culminating in the series of out that have occurred this year in the Yangtze valley. They have asked for redress in vernment says it has granted, some it is willing to grant, and some it is trying to still debate over; until at last the foreign Ministers have said that they will not waste any more time in debate. One theory of the outrages, at which some of the Chinese Ministers abroad have eagerly grasped, is, that they are the work of a secret society which is aiming to overthrow the government. This may be true entirely, partially, or. not at all: we believe it is partially true; not-entirely, because the widespread pamphlet to which we have recently referred incites to just such outrages as have been committed, and contains no hint of rebellion, not a word to rouse the people against their government. In fact, the people are advised to destroy foreigners and their doctrines as a patriotic duty, with no reference whatever to the government or the dynasty, or to anything to be done byarebellion. The officials connive at, if they do not actively promote, the distribution of this pamphlet, as officials of the government, not as rebels against it, Who goveroment does not allow that any rebellion exists, and until it does the government cannot use. a rebellion to stave off inconvenient demands, nor can foreign Powers admit it as an excuse for inaction. If the probability of a rebellion is admitted as an excuse to-day, we may well expect that it will be urged whenever a claim is made on the government; for secret societies and disaffected, disbanded soldiers, ready for any extent of dacoity, China has always with her. There isa pertinent little incident mentioned in our Hankow correspondent's letter this morning. he only course before foreign Powers now that will not make the future worse than the past, that will hot in fact make the existence of foreigners in China impossible wherever they are not in sufficient numbers to defend themselves, is to hold the government responsible for what has bap-pened and may happen, leaving it to deal with its own rebellions its own way. the government were fighting for its life with internal foes. Its st man, with the country's main army and fleet, is doing nothing. The French government was promised more than ten days ago that Li Hung-chang's celebrated ivan, squadron should be sent here to keep order. As usual with Chinese, the execution of this promise is limited to the despatch of two vessels to Shanghai, where they lie awaiting orders.

Meanwhile we have to possess our souls in patience, knowing that our governments have gone too far to recede now, and that they do not mean to be satisfied with words. But it takes time and much telegraphing between capitals to make the final arrangements when the period for action is arriving. The time is favourable; there is indeed the usual autumn crop of rumours at home of possible complications in Europe; but to them.we are accustomed at this time

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account