The Archive · 1896

Why Are Foreigners

"If all the Cobden Club preaches is true, how does it happen that all the nations of the earth are devoted to Protection?" 'That is a question which the plain man finds a very great stumbling-block when he begins to consider the problem of free exchange. 'I grant,' he says to the zealous Cobdenite, that all yoy sounds perfectly reasonable and true, and intellect tually I am convinced. Still, it seems"to me rather strong order to say that we are the only nation on the face of the earth that has got any sense. If the Free-trade arguments are really as good as they sound, would they not have been perceived by other people besides ourselves? We obviously have not got a monopoly of logic and common sense in other matters, trid it is rather puzzling to see why we should have one in regard to economic subjects. Isn't it, therefore, possible that there is some flaw in the Free-trade argument which we are not clever enough to see? After all, that seems as likely a hypothesis as the other,—namely, that all foreigners, and even our own flesh and blood in America and the Colonies, are fools, and we who inhabit this little island the only wise men on the face of the earth. If there is any-and there must. be "good deal in ity thing in secures indicat orbit terrarum, Free-trade stands to lose." In other words, the ordinary man is good deal frightened and puzzled, and his faith perceptibly weakened, by the thought that perhaps after all he is pursuing " hidden fallacy. This being so it is worth while to consider why it is that alitest all foreign nations are given over to Protection. If it is because they have really convinced thernselves that Protection is the best means of increasing the national well-being, then no doubt the doubts and difficulties of the plain man which we have described hold the field. Tf, however, it can be shown, as we believe it can, that foreign Powers are, when we reach the ultimate cause, Protectionists for very different reasons, the plain man's "blank misgivings" ought to cease, determine, and become of no effect.

We believe that the true raison why foreign Governments are Protectionist is a very simple one. The explanation is to be found in two facts,—(1) that they are obliged by reason of their expenditure on armament and other phenomena of government to raise vast sums of money and (2) that tle populations of, all countries outside England have a profound detestation of direct taxation. But if money has to be raised, and you cannot raise by direct taxation, you must get it by tariffs. Foreign Governments, then, are obliged to have high tariffs. But given high tariffs as a fiscal necessity you cannot well help adopting the principle of Protection. Taxes ate, generally speaking, odious to the whole community. It is, however, a peculiarity of protective taxation that there are alwa: a large number of people ready not merely to endure it, but to support it with enthusiasm. No one was ever known to be enthusiastic over the Income-tax, but men, especially those who own land, will wax Iyrical over a duty on corn, arid burst into odes on the waving cornfields, and the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account