The Archive · 1891

A REBELLION OR WHAT?

When, five months ago, the present anti-foreign disturbances broke out, the public, both in China and at home, seized upon Mr. Drummond's explanation of them asa most probable one. It did not appear at all unlikely that one of the secret societies, with which China is known to be honeycombed, and which, as we learn from history, have stirred up rebellions in the past, should be endeavouring, by embroiling the government with foreign powers, to make for itself an opportanity to stir up another just now. In spite, however, of the wide acceptance which this theory has met with, and its practical adoption by the Chinese government and its apologists, it worth while to enquire if some other explo. nation would not better fit the facts.

It may be said that previous to the Wuhu riot there was no word of any dis-atisfaction with the government, in any quarter. The central power appeared to be better able then to carry out its will everywhere, than at any other time during the present century; and was engaged in nothing which was likely to make it unpopular. provincial authorities were trusty, the literati loyal, and the stupid people" submissive usual. There was not even a cloud the size of a man's hand to betoken the approach of " great rebellion. Yet the rebellion theory was accepted although unforeshadowed, and is still retained although unsupported by proof. With the exception of "the man behind the temple," no rebel has been seen by a foreigner as yet, nor have any who have confessed to treasonable designs been seized by the native authorities, as could hardly have failed to have been the case were a genuine rising on foot. Such rioters as foreigners have used have not been rebels, but were, and still are, the Emperor's most loyal subjects and servants,—soldiers and yamen men. No genuine act of hostility against the government, as such, can be alleged against them; foreigners alone have suffered at their hands. Some proof that the rebellion theory is the true one there may be, but it

are actually on the scene of the disturbances do not endorse it, as an examination of the correspondence columns of the newspapers will show.

But further, the acceptance of this theory necessitates our believing a number of other things which seem absolutely incredible. We must hold that the would-be rebels are so lacking in common sense as to suppose that, in addition to defying the dragon throne, they can afford to make enemies v and array against themselves, the whole niilitary world besides, Were there really two parties in China about to engage in mortal strife, one or other of them would certainly court an alliance with foreigners. At present both are equally hostile to us—a most remarkable, and, on this theory, unaccountable fact. also believe that the Chinese gov is dealing with its deadly enemies in a way in which no government ever before dealt with such, It cannot see them till they are actually pointed out. Their very names and addresses must be put into its hands, or it will fail to find them. When caught it will not punish them, unless compelled; and is always ready to encourage those who help, and to obstruct those who hinder them. In short, we must hold that the government has gone mad; and besides that it has been struck with a strange paralysis. Oficers can no longer control their soldiers, nor Viceroys and Governors their oticers, nor the Emperor any one in connection with this rebellion business. As regards all other matters the engine of State works as usual; on this one point only is it helpless. All which are things incredible.

Although s0 little can be urged in support of this theory, it must be said in its favour that it is a most convenient one for the Chinese offici ud their friends, Tt puts the odium of the riots upon patties with whom they, of course, have no sympa: thy. It relieves them from the responsibility of any longer protecting foreigner: how can individual.mandarins be expected to cope with rebellion? It upsolves them from all fear of punishment when riots occur; who would be so unreasonable us to insist on punishing men for what they could not help? Best of all, it furnishes a splendid argument why foreign powers should stand quietly aside, and allow events to take their course, since by interfering they would necessarily precipitate ea great a calamity. Amongst the m: xims reverenced by the people of this country are some which tell us that "if we would know the affairs of the Empire, we must read the works of the ancients" and "if we would understand the present we must study the past." These precepts hold good anywhere, but particularly in China; whose motto might well be samper idem. " Referring then to the pages of the ancients, we find that there was a time when the Chinese welcomed intercourse with foreigners, but it was before the present dynasty obtained possession of the throne. The Manchu rulers, themselves foreigners, have constantly and consistently endeavoured to exclude all other outer kingdom men, and, before they were compelled by the strong arm to act otherwise, spared no pains to make life a burden to all such as came within their reach. In thus acting the literati, the only body in the empire whose opinion is of any weight, were entirely at one with them. We tind that troubles, like to those we have recently had, were by no means rare in the experience of the foreigners of a hundred years ago. It would be easy to parallel all that has happened with similar events in the history of the old Canton factor It is now one hundred and forty years since we find bitter complaint being made that "injurious ai were a unally put up by the government, accusing foreigners of horrible crimes, and

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account