The Archive · 1896

Objections of the United States

On the 11th of April Mr. Olney acknowledged the receipt of this draft treaty in a despatch in which he stated that. Article 4 was unacceptable to the United States. Mr. Olney wrote with Article 3, no criticism could have If Lord Salisbury's draft had stopped been made either of the arbitral machinery provided, or of the arbitral subjects enumerated, except that the latter seem to be so cautiously restricted as hardly to cover other than controversies which, as between civilised States, could almost never endaner their peaceful relations. But Arvicle as well as Article 4, is apparently qua-lifed by the provisions of Article 5, since the national honour may sometimes be involved even in_a claim for indemnity to an individual. Further, the arbitral machinery provided by Article 4 is open to serious objection as not securing an end of the controversy unless an award is concurred in by at least five out of the six appellate arbiters.

Mir. Olney proceeds to say that, in_call-scheme as langoly restricting its value, he ing attention to these features of the

was directed by the President to propose a substitute for Articles 4 and. 5. is suggested clause differs in many ways from that proposed by Lord Salisbury, the most important being that an award appealed against should be reviewed by Gourt compooed of three of the judges of the Supreme Court of Great Britain, and three of the judges of the Supreme Court of the United States, who, before entering upon their duties, should agree that three leamed and impartial jurists be added to said Court in case they should be equally divided upon the award to be made, and the decision of this Court, whether unanimous or by a majority vote, should be final. In conclusion, Mr. Olney suggested that if his emendation of Article 4 should prove acceptable to Lord Salisbury he was willing that the Venezuela dispute should be adjudicated upon by the tribunal formed under the Treaty.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account