20th Nov.
In its article on "Intervention in China" the New York Tribune is more temperate than the New York Times, to which we referred yesterday, but this does not make it any the less to be deprecated. There is the additional danger in the case of the Tribune that itis the organ of the U.S. Administration; but though it may have received general instructions to write in favour of the Chinese side, it does not scow to have been well advised as to details. The Tribune begins by saying that the United Star overnwent has been invited to join Great Britain and France "in a warlike demonstration against China for the alleged purpose of compelling the Yamen to protect foreigners from mob violence." This, we are told, is not the first time that such a request has been made. "England and France, with designs on Chinese territory that do them discredit, havexlways been anxious to secure American aid and countenance. heir propositions have been based on the alleged necessity of enforcing treaty rights, and they have always concealed an act of downright vandalism. In the case now pending England's motive is less open to suspicion than is thut of France, but both of them have interests in China which we do not share or sympathise with. We are not coucerned to hold possessions acquired by piratical wars, uor to force our people either for trade or religious. propaganda where they are distinctly forbidden togo." Nor do the United States think that there is any cause for a warlike demonstration. "he American people are of one mind in thinking that European aggression toward China has gone far enough, whether it be that of England in Canton, France in Tongking, or Russia in Corea." And the Tribune gravely suggests that if any answer is
England and France, it should take the made to the piratical propositions of form of remonstrance, The writer goes on to mention that US. Minister to Peking, reported that there were altogether 1,022 American residents in China, of whom 506 were missionaries, about one-fourth of all the missionaries in China being American citizens: "For the security of these people we have six men-of-war, including the flagship Charleston, now in Chinese waters, and another, the Petrel, will j the fleet ina few days. A military force of about 3,000 men, twice as many as are usually allotted to the entire Asiatic station, has thus been made available for such service as may be required of it. This force is ample. Even if the disturbances are as great as has been reported in European capitals they are not likely to call for acts of armed resistance." Ihe writer recognises that "native officials of high degree may have instigated the riots, and are covertly protecting those who engage in them, but in any case our marines are competent to shield the small body of American traders and missionaries who have recklessly penetrated into the interior." But how are the U.S. marines going to protect the American traders and missionaries and customs officials who have recklessly penetrated into Chungking, an open port? Surely it is more statesmanlike to bring pressure—by a demonstration, if uecessary—ou the central government, to'compel it to protect the foreigners in China, than to dissipate the American marines all over the empire, protecting American missionaries here and there? Then comes a highly misleading statement, which we must quote in the writer's own words":—" It must be remembered that foreigners have no conventional rights beyond the twenty-three ports which the Chinese Government has thrown open to trade. If for any purpose, religious or commercial, foreigners go into the interior and undertake to trade and propagate beliefs where the people are unwilling to receive them they go in contravention of positive Jaw and at their own risk. The State Departwent has notified this fact to our missionaries again and agaivu. China has never accepted the liberal principles of international law with regard to the rights of aliens, and for excellent reasons. Such rights as aliens possess are purely conventional, and, under the operation of the most-favoured nation clause, common to all. As officially expressed by Secretary Bayard, the treaties as they stand permit foreigners to resort to China for trade, for curiosity or as teachers in established schools, but even then only to certain carefully defined and limited localities where they must pursue their business with due regard to the feelings of the people.'"
Missionaries in their zeal, we are told, disregard this positive law, and they put their government to a great deal of trouble when they are violently ejected from districts they have unlawfully invaded. But the Tsungli Yamen has been most conciliatory and reasonable, and has "tolerated their residency in the neighbourhoods not opened by treaty law, and has pursued the policy of indemnification to sufferers from mob violence when their religious operations have been thus tolerated." We should hardly have thought it possible that the U.S. State Department does not know, or that if it does know a leading New York paper could not have found out from it, that besides the general protection to the Christian religion and its teachers and converts provided for in all the treaties, it is specially stipulated in Art. VI of the Convention of 1860 between France and China, that "it is permitted to chase land in all the provinces, and to French missionaries to rent and pur-
erect buildings thereon at pleasure a permission which is extended by the most favoured nation clause in all the treaties to all subjects and citizens of treaty Powers. How can we expect the people at home to understand and take a clear view of the situation in China, when their teachers in the Press are so ignorant? 'I'he zeal of the missionaries is not, as a fact, without discretion for they have a perfect right to establish themselves, purchase land, and erect buildings, in Hunan; but knowing that they would seriously embarrass their governments if they attempted it, they have so far refrained. It is, however, a great weakness on the part of our governments that they do not insist on measures being taken to make Hunan accessible to missionaries.
We do not quarrel with the Zribune's recommendation that follows that the government should "learn the ciroumstances attending the Yangtze Kiang outrages before assuming that all the wrong is on the side of the Chinese." But surely Colonel Denby tras attended to that. Nor is it our place to contradict the paragraph with which the writer concludes his article "In any event, it is well to bear in und that the United States are in no position to denounce China for not protecting foreign residents. 'I'he horrible atrocities at Rock Springs and Seattle are somewhat too recent to perniit' us to indulge in dissertations upon the incompetency of the Chinese. Government in dealing with rioters. It a' revent dispatch to our State Department the Chinese Minister observed that in China, so far as is known, not a single"Ametican has lost his life by mob violence, while in every case where: injury "has been done to the property "and, right" "of American citizens by conspiracy and mobs, punishment lias: been promptly inflicted on the guilty and' full pecuniary indemnity Tas "been nade by the authorities. We believe this to-be an accurate statement of fact, and until we can present its like we should be exceedingly chary of rebuke and denunciation in our comments npon'disorlers in china." But it does not'seem tots very good reasoning to say that steps Should not be taken to: prevent, out-Tages on missionaries in China, because
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.