6th Feb.
Turre has been some agitation during the last fortnight or so among a portion of the community, inspired by the recent decision of the Committee of the Shanghai Public School to restrict the school to children born of Western parents, In another column we publish a valuable communication on the subject, which will, no doubt, be fully gone into at the forthcoming Ratepayers' Meeting; but meanwhile we may present a few considerations that may well be weighed by the ratepayers before that meeting takes place.
The Shanghai Public School was! originally founded by the Masonic Body here, who saw that times were changing, that people had to look forward to spending the greater part of their lives here when they once became residents of Shanghai, and that they could no longer afford to send their children home to Europe or America to be educated. Shortly after it was established by the Masonic Body, the school declined to admit Eurasian children; butit did not pay, or rather it became a heavier burden on the resources of its founders than they cated to' shoulder, and it was taken over by Mr. Lanning, the Head Master, 'a8 a private speculation. It suited him as 8 private individual naturally anxious to make the school remunerative, to admit Eurasian children, After a little while, the ratepayers began to realise the desirability of having a first-class public school' at Shanghai, to which their children could be sent, so that they might avoid the pain of parting with their children during the most interesting period of their lives, and the expense, often almost prohibitory, of keeping them at school at home. When Mr. Jamieson in 1894 brought forward the scheme for turning the Masonic into Public School he distinctly stated, and the statement was received with applause by the ratepayers, that the school was to be for "European children," and the constitution of the Committee, which consisted, when the decision now complained of was taken, of Messrs. Geo. Jamieson, R. M. Campbell, J. L, Scott, O. Stuebel, and F, M. Gratton, should be a sufficient guarantee that the intentions of the ratepayers are not disregarded. It has been the constant work of the Committee to make the School the high-class institution that it was intended to be, and to this end they are empowered by the constitution "to refuse admission (to) or to expel any children whose presence might be or is considered by them detrimental to the School." They have currie to the conclusion, not lightly or suddenly, but after long deliberation avd discussion that the admission and the continued presence of Eurasian children is detrimental to the best interests of the School, and on that ground have felt obliged to send out the recent circular to which exception has been taken. The ratepayers may, primd facie, feel ats thet the Comes ofthe Seba, constituted as it is, must have good grounds for the course they have taken, somewhat invidious as it appears to be at first sight The Committee, we understand, came reluctantly to the conclusion that the School was not doing what was expected of it, or what it was intended by the ratepayers to do and they saw that it was becoming a question whether the School should become a Eurasian School or a high-class public school for European children; and their duty is to make it the latter.
It is reported that the Masonic body take some exception to the circular previously referred to, but it is difficult to see what their objection is. By the terms of their contract with the Municipal Council, they have the right to the permanent free education of four children in the School. This right has always been recognised and availed of, and the four children being educated in the School under this agreement are all European children, The decision now come to by the Committee of the School seems a little hard at first sight on the Eurasian children and their parents, some of whom even make the grave mistake of G, representing that their children are being "expelled" from the School, which is not at all the case, But it must be remembered that there are three other schools.in Shanghai for Eurasians, all receiving support from the ratepayers, the subsidies they receive equalling exactly the amount paid to the Shanghai Pablic School. The Thomas Hanbury School and Children's Home was largely built and is largely supported, especially for Eurasians, by the Shavghai community, and it is now being extended, a fresh sum of} with Ils. 5,000 having been lately subscribed in Shanghai for the purpose, in addition to 'TMs. 4,000 given by its great benefactor, Mr. Thomas Hanbury. It is not likely that in the face of these three existing schools, the ratepayers intended that the 'I's. 45,000 they raised by debentures on which they are paying interest, should be used in starting another Eurasian school. It was intended to start a High School for European children of all classes, and the endeavour. of the Committee has been to realise this in the Shanghai Public School, 'The Eurasian Question is a much too large and important one to be entered upon now, and we should hope that it will be put altogether on one side when this question comes up for discussion at the Ratepayers' Meeting. 'I'he facts simply are that the ratepayers Lave incurred a heavy liability and a large annual: expense to establish and main tain a first-class Public School; that they have put the management of this school in the hands of an exceptionally strong and representative Committee, in whom they can safely have every confidence; and that this Committee have, after long deliberation, found themselves obliged to take step which offends a section of the public, It isa misfortune that it, has this effect, but the Committee have no recourse if they find that the action they have taken is otherwise necessary and we cannot doubt for a moment that they will be supported in what they have done by the general voice of the ratepayers. he view the Committee take of the intention of the ratepayers in establishing the school is, we are convinced, the one that commends itself to all but a small section of the community,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.