The Archive · 1897

Committee on the Merchant Marine

Sir,—We have to deal with real facts and actual conditions. The interests of shipowning and shipbuilding are identical, because no nation can successfully own ships that cannot successfully build them.

notion can alber, built ex. wu ships when, unprotected and unencouraged, it is brought in competition with other nations that are protected and encouraged.

This is the existing condition of the shipowning and shipbuilding interests of the United States.

The resulting fact is that the enormous revenue represented by the freight and passenger tolls on our commerce and travel is constantly drained out of this country in the order named, but mainly British into British, German, and French pockets,

while the vast industrial increment re-resented by the necessary shipbuilding inures almost wholly to Great Britain. Ib is sheer loss. It is the ineiral cause For this drain there is no recompense.

of our existing financial condition.

So long as this drain continues, no tariff and no monetary policy can restore the national prosperity.

Until we make some provision to keep at home some part at least of the three hundred and odd millions annually sucked out of this country by foreign shipowners and shipbuilders, no other legislation can bring good times back again.

It is a constant stream of gold always flowing out.

The foreign shipowner who carries oversea commerce makes us pay the freight both ways.

For our exports we get the foreign market price, less the freight.

For our imports we pay the foreign market price, plus the freight.

No.fine-spun theory of any cloistered or collegiate doctrinaire can wipe out these facts.

The fact that so long as the freight is paid to a foreign shipowner, so long will it be a foreign profit on a foreign -product is fundamental-and unanswerable.

The English steamship is a foreign product, and its earnings, which we pay, are a foreign profit.

No sane man will argue that a foreign profit on a foreign product can be a do- sea mastic benefit.

"Add to this the fact, equally important, that the carrier of commerce controls its exchanges, -and the condition of commercial, financial, and: industrial subjugation is complete. Such is our condition to-day, Great Britain has many outlying colonies and dependencies.

The greatest two are India and the United States.

She holds India by force of arms, whereby her control of that country costs her something. She has to pay something for and commercial drainage of She holds the United States by the folly of its own people, whereby her control of this comm try costs her nothing. She has to pay nothing for her financial and commercial drainage of the United States.

But the amount of her annual drainage of gold from the United States far exceeds that from India.

Therefore, the United States is by far the most valuable of all the dependencies of Great Britain.

In the relation of England to India, there is something pitiable because India is helpless.

In the relation of the United States to England there is nothing that is not contemptible, because it is the willing servitude of a nation that could help herself if she would.

England is wide awake to these conditions, and keenly appreciates the priceless value to her.

The United States blinks at them, half dazed, half asleep, insensible of their tremmendous damage to her.

England, clearly seeing that, in this age more than ever. before, ocean empire is world empire, strains every nerve to perpetuate her sea power and exhausts her resources to double rivet the fetters which it fastens upon mankind.

Since 1885 England has expended $517,000,000 for new ships of war and their armament. During eleven years she has built 38 first-class battle ships, 3 second-class battle ships, 9 armoured cruisers, 20 first-class cruisers, 51 second-class cruisers, 33 third-class cruisers, 30 gunboats, 12 composite sloops, and 74 torpedo destroyers, including the vessels authorised in the current year's programme, The aggregate is 270 vessels of 1,136,575 tons total displacement, 1,674,700 horsepower.

Of the navy England already had in 1885 there remain available 42 armoured ship 34 cruisers, 11 sloops, 19 gunboats, and 95 torpedo boats, which she is re-engining, rearming, and otherwise modernizing as rapidly as she can.

personnel afloat she has augmented her force from 52,600 in 1885 to 100,500 in the estimates for 1897.

In other words, England has doubled her navy in personnel and material and more than quadrupled it in warlike efficiency during eleven years of the profoundest peace the world ever saw.

Even greater exertions has England put forth in the augmentation of her merchant marine. During the calendar year 1896 she added 1,380,000 tons of new steel shipping to her merchant fleet, -breaking up meantime 530,000 tons of old and obsolete shipping which could no longer be operated profitably; a net addition of 850,000 tons to the total of her merchant marine by the register, but a practical addition of the whole 1,380,000 tons, because the 530,000 tons broken up had done its work for her aggrandisement and simply passed through the scrap heap and the mills into the new tonnage.

No great fact can exist without a great reason.

Tu recent years Germany on a large scale and in a systematic way, and this country on a small scale and in a spasmodic way, have put forth efforts in the direction of England instantly takes alarm. To her the growth of any other sea power, even if its scope be comparatively. small and its extent comparatively feeble, is a peril second only to the landing of an invading army in Kent.

England is determined that she shall be not only the supreme sea power, but also that except within limits set by herself there shall be no other sea power at all.

She will tolerate the growth of any other sea power only so far as the point at which it begins to affect her naval supre: macy or dispute the ocean monopoly of her merchant marine.

The moment any other national aspire: tion toward sea power reaches that point England must be prepared to crush it.

She will crush it by intrigue, by cajolery, by treaties, if she can. She will crush it by preponderating force if she must.

er since two first-class American ships were put in the transatlantic trade under American management every device of foul play that selfish ingenuity can invent and every resort that unscrupulous rivalry can suggest have been exhausted by the English Press and the English administration to defame and discredit them.

English officials abroad, from Ministers and-Consuls down, industriously reproduce in the newspapers of Japan, China, Chihli, Argentine, and Brazil the misstatements of the English Press about American vessels.

The British Post Office delays the American mails for days in the slower ships of the Cunard line rather than send so much as one letter by the American line.

Our Post Office responds by liberal allotments of its European mails to all the British lines.

The result of all this is that while this country has never known such financial distress, England has never known such industrial activity and financial prosperity as now.

Does it not occur to men who: look the least bit below the surface that the warfare for ocean empire, and the strife for commanding sea power which England forces upon the rest of mankind have reached a stage so acute that her Prosperity uualtarably means the misery of everybody else, and that everybody's loss is inevitably her gain?

What is the response of the United States to this tremendous exertion of English energy and resource to the aygrandisement of her sea power To the English estimates for the current year for further increase of her navy amounting to eleven millions, nine hundred and five thousand pounds steriing (£11,905,000, say $57,334,300), and a programme involving 108 new ships in all stages between laying down and completion, the United States responds by " sudden halt in even the comparatively feeble programme fitfully pursued since 1885, and a flat collapse of the policy of the new navy as a whole.

To the 1,380,000 tons of new merchant shipping built by England during the past year, what will be the response of the United States Now the future lies wholly in the hands of Congress.

From that quarter comes no sign.

A tariff bill framed to produce revenue, and at the same time promote and encourage American industries, is to be passed. lo a greater or less extent this tariff is calculate-~ to promote and encourage every American industry but two—shipowning and shipbuilding.

As I have already said, this ceaseless ebb of gold without compensation is the tribute this country pays to England, and it is paid through English shipowners The United States has never been able to get any of it back except by borrowing it on bonds.

England is keenly alive to these great economic facts and their results.

Is the United States to be forever blind to them and their significance?

These are the questions which confront Cuas. H. Cran.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account