Unthinkables—discussed by Frederic H. Balfour, Author of Cherryield Hall, Dr. Mirabel's Theory, The Song of Songs, ete. London: Richard Bentley and Son, 1897.
The versatile author of Dr. Mirabel's Theory, which metaphysical novel was reviewed in our columns some three years back, has now ventured upon more direct challenge to the "thoughtful" reader and to modern philosophy generally in this his latest work, well entitled Unthinkables. We will not go so far as to say that the title is the most expressive part of the book but, holding as we do with the late George Cornwall Lewis that Metaphysics is little else but a clash of words, there would seem at first sight to be small senso in asking the reading public to expend thought upon matter which the author describes at the outset as "unthinkable." Still though, whereas in the realm of metaphysics, it may be well said, that "Thinking is but an idle waste of thought, And Naugiit is everything and everything is Naught," yet the human mind is so: constituted that it will not rest content in the knowable and follow the reputed advice of China's Great Sage to his disciples, given 2,500 years ago, but will persist in trying to think out the unthinkable, maw ardent souls deeming precisely those things most worthy of proof of which nothing can be proved. Hence the long array of priests and metaphysicians, from the days of Isis to those of Herbert Spencer, supported by a confiding race of mortals anxious to lift the veil which an inscrutable fate maintains everlastingly drawn. And, in his contribution to this endeavour, the author of the book before us is not more unsuccessful than his predecessors although he eminently succeeds in presenting to us his teleological views in clear and intelligible language.
The avowed object of the book is the reconciling of science with religion, but, Under the definition of religion, all dogmatic theology is practically abandoned by our author} yet, without dogma, so theolo-Frence Mr. Balfour's clever sununary of the us all toll us, religion is only a negation.
results of modern free speculation in the domain of metaphysics simply lands us in an enlightened Pantheism. Thus in his attempt to reconcile the conclusions of modern science with old-world religious traditions ho presents us with the dogma that the Supreme Being is Life" or "Force" that force which is apparently distinct from and yet inseparable from matter; that force which in the shape of Will" wells up in the consciousness of every human being. Thus God is the eternal sentient ' Cause,"—is "Life" itself; that life which we cannot contemplate apart from matter; which controls the universe in its minutest and in its randest manifestations, and which Mr.
odd defines as " the arrest of the universal movement towards equilibrium." Thus the Deity is not the Deity of the Bible, (ye "quate from our author)—no, "quae riental monarch, a Sultan' of the sky, a personality distinct and apart from other y personalities, to whom every thought and event and word throughout boundless space is conveyed by some occult system of telephonics, and whose dealings with creation are, magna componere partis, analogous to' the dealings of a human sovereign with' his subjects." No! God is inseparable from His universe of which He is Himself a fundamental part, if not the Universe itself. And the terms in which this conception is embodied are:—The Absolute; The Unconditioned Being, pure and simple; the Universal Nowmenon; The Self-existent Power that never began to be; The Ultimate Reality of Fact.
ra Th if we give up the God of the Bible, King of Kings, the Emperor of the Universe, holding a levee, at which He receives the reports of his Ministers," (frst chapter of Job and fourth and fifth of the Apocalypse), we seem to be necessarily landed in Pantheism, and neither of the two conceptions is final. We are reminded of the celebrated interview between Confucius and Laotze; Confucius, who is supposed to have taught the uselessness of speculating about intangible and provable problems, and Laotze, the Mystic, who tells us in the Taoteh classic, that the Unreal is the only Real. What would we not give to have a shorthand report of this celebrated interview! All_we know of it is that Confucius, "fter quitting Lao-zo, became absorbed in thought and said to his disciples: 'I have seax the Dragon;" which, allowing for the terseness and obscurity of the then written language, we may take to mean an acknowledgement that "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio,*
Than are dreamt of in your philosophy"
Thus the Seg would hardly appear to have been the pure materialist that Dr. Legge would make him out to have been, but it is rather that, while exhorting his disciples to confine their attention to right conduct in this world, he admitted that there were problems beyond which he was unable to solve: and this we take to be the precise attitude of the modern pious Agnostic.
Mr. Balfour's book is a small handy volume of 160 pages and to those who shrink from the probity of philosophers like Kant, Hegel, and Schopenhauer, or the profundity of Herbert Spencer, yet would gladly be acquainted with the best thought on the subject, our author's clearly written summary should come as a great boon, and we strongly commend its perusal to all, theologians and agnostics alike. They will find in it a short digest of metaphysics and learn what is the road which those who are slowly bringing about the someday inevitable reconciliation of science, religion, and ethics, are now followin; Whatever their preconceived views on the subject, they will find thought stimula! ed and something explained; while to us at a distance from the great intellectual centres of Europe it brings home the ferment in men's minds now working towards as great a revolution in thought in the twentieth as was that brought about by the Reformation in the sixteenth century.
The work is divided into four chapters of which the following are the titles How to believe in nothing.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.