The Archive · 1898

The Cost of Lighterage from Woosung

19th Mar, Tue judgment delivered on the 15th instant by Mr. John Goodnow, U.S. Consul-General, in the case of Clark and Service, owners of the steamship Ardandearg, against the Standard Oil Company, is a very important one. It settles so far a very important principle, and it isa very able deliverance and very sound. The question before the Court was whether, considering the terms of the bill of lading, a steamer which has to deliver a part of her cargo into lighters at Woosung to enable her to cross the Bar and come up to Shanghai, is bound to pay the cost of the necessary lighterage. Ihe Standard Oil Compavy in New York shipped in the Ardandearg 100,893 cases of kerosene oil at New York for Shanghai. When she arrived at Woosung, the Ardandearg drew too auch water to cross the Bar without accordingly discharged- into lighters, the cost. of this being 'I'ls. 878.88, which the Standard Oil Ao. her refused to pay, and.this was the sum claimed: by Messrs. Clark and Service. 'The defence against the claim was that the shipment was made in pursuance of a contract or freight-note which provided that the oil was to be delivered' at Shanghai at some wharf below Pootung Point; vtiat if there was not enough water for the Ardandearg to cross the Woosung Bar when she arrived, she should have waited until there was enough water; that it is the custom of the port for the steamer to pay lighterage in a case of this kind;.and that in any case there was other cargo besides that shipped by the Standard Oil Ca. on the steamer, and therefore the defendants could not he called on to pay the whole of the lighterage. This last defence was allowed by the Court, which gave the plaintiffs accordingly only 3$the of the whole cost of lighterage, so that we may dismiss this point; but it is evident that the remaining ths will fall upon the steamer, for the consignees of the cargo that she carried for Japan had no interest in the matter either way.

The freight-note is dated New York, September 16th, 1895, and says: Consignees having privilege of ordering steamer to the Eastern Wharf or to any other of the wharves below Pootung Point provided there is sufficient water"

The freight-note also says: "This contract is made subject to the terms and conditions of the form of bill of lading in use by this line"... The bill of lading, which is dated the 15th -of October, 1895, says that the oil is-to be delivered by the steamer "at the port of Shanghai, or as near, thereto as she may safely get;"'and it contains in the margin the words from the freight-note: "Consignees having privilege," ete, Several expert witnesses ware oallert to prove that the custom of the port.is for the steamer to. pay the lighterage, Mr. Alex. McLeod, who has had 26 years' shipping experience, said: " When goods are shipped to Shanghai under bill of lading to be delivered of, Shanghai or as near thereto as the ship cin safely get, and she cannot get up without lightering, the cost of lighterage Is by custom. borne by the steamer or ship: that is now the custom and has always been the custom in Shanghai," Mr. Robert Carr, Mr. Brodie' Clarke, Mr. 'T. R. Wheelock, and others gave similar evidence; but against this it may be noted that the bills of lading of the China Mutual Steam Navigation Company contain a stipulation that lighterage where. necessary will be at the steamer's expense but the consignee's risk. Mr. E, A. Hewett, the agent of the P. & O. Company, testified that the custom in the case of his company was for the ship to pay the cost of lighterage, but he should not consider: himeelf bound: to pay it,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account