The Archive · 1898

The French Mail Papers

(FoR THE WEEK ENDING THE 11TH OF PED

Tas following extract froma leading article in the Times of the th ult, hints very shrewdly at the reason why Poking does not really care for a loan from a foreign Government "Those who have followed with attention the course of events in the Far East will learn without imnjoderate surprise that there is Feason to apprehend the breakdown of the negotiations for a Chinese loan. Our Peking it, who has shown himself won-Gerfally well informed throughout, tells us that it-is believed that the Chinese will decline the British proposals on account of the opposition of Russia, and the Russian England. Like the famous ass of Buridanus aponaa an accent of the opposition of they ao, 20 equally "tempted "by, coveted momelé on one side and' the other, or go equally repelled by the difficulties of either course, that they end by taking "Te has' been suspected by. read cilatly "Bungey' "whoa markable display. of philosophic indifference. which he repudiated, used the word." war, In the same way it seems probable that the therefore an obligation comes upon us to Chinese have other reasons than equal defer-tell him everything that has gone on io ence to English and to Russian wishes for China. I think he has extended the result declining financial assistance. The money Of that expression of the Chancellor of the was wanted chiefly to pay off debt, aad to Exchequer perhaps too far. There is no release Weihaiwei from pawn. As no vei doubt that there were suggestions—I do not margin was allowed by. our say on what authority they rest, but. there for purposes more directly connected with the were suggestions—that our treaty rights in comforts of the official class, they have prob-China might be set aside, and that the com-ably. reflected that the advantages accruing parative freedom of traffic which we have from a mere change of creditors are not great achieved by the Treaty of Tientsin might be from their personal point of view. The destroyed by the action of other European indefinite retoation of \Weihaiwei by Japan Powers. I think it was quite right that a would be a serious loss to China were she an protest should be made against the mere enter organised empire, and would be found into-tainment of such an idea, though I do not for lerable by the class of statesmen-that such an an instant suggest that any European Power empire imply, But as things actually are really entertained it, But I will relieve the it does not matter very much to the men who noble enrl as to one part of his speech. Ho direct Chinese policy that Japan holds Wei-seems to have imagined there was a danger haiwei and Germany has established herself that we should be dispossessed of or should Kiaochou. On the other hand, the in-abandon the privileges secured by the Treaty creased control of revenue which this country of Tientsin. would have demanded as security for repay-'The Earl of Kimberley: I did not say that.

f the loan does directly affect the Which itis their' privilege to. manipulate, ing class by curtailing the supplies I do not think riy Government would do Henco'it is not dificult to understand that The Marqui the noble the present form of indebtedness may seem to, earl says that he does not them preferable to that more regular but less ment would do that. That always moans convenient obligation which we offered as a that you believe that the Government of the substitute.

This country will find no reason for distress day would doit, (Laughter.), Then I would put it in this way. Not only have we not in the prolonged retention of Weihaiwei by surrendered one iota of our treaty rights, but is just conceivable that the we have no intention of surrendering thom—not sorry to be provided wit (cheers)—and, though I will not_ make uso of argument for continued occupa-those high-sounding words which grate on tion. It is true that the Chinese Government the noble earl's nerves, I will say there is no is said to be about to invite subscriptions to effort which this country will not make an internal loan of s hundred million taels, b rather than allow those rights to be destroyed. the response is not expected to be very ge (Cheere.) But I am bound at the sime time rous, Such an expedient has been resorted to to say, lest it should be supposed we have before and has been speedily followed by been maintaining a desperate diplomatic repudiation, a process as disagreeable to the battle in, favour of the Treaty of Tientsia, confiding Oriental as to the creditor of the that nobody yet has suggested the slichtest West. We shall see when the ti intention of infringing any of the rights we ying an instalment of Jenjoy under that treaty; and I venture to demnity how much the Chin hope, knowing the soundness of the judg-can obtain in this manner. The proposal to ment of the statesmen by whom Europe is find money for China cannot be regretted governed, that no auch intention will over although it has come to nothing. It has had be ontert But the noble ed. rl says thoro the great incidental advantage of leading to rained oxciti a very distinct formulation of our policy in excitement has arisen, as China, and of calling forth in favour of that erally do, from an extra policy' o singular! limous expression of ordinary confusion of thought. There ara* public opinion. jure of the loan nogo-'Biations leaves us in full possession of the, ome persons in the country who imagine that by the Treaty of Tientsin we have nctreaty rights we previously enjoyed but rq quired the right to force China to take a loan, rnovar enforced with proper vigour and:|and also the right to force them total ence. This new proof of the futility with it conditions we may think fit to i ness of the Central Government at Peking Tord say that. there had been no guarantee, I was. sorry to. hear the noble cantlet fail to convince the Foreign Office that British rights must be defended and enforced That is hardly the position which lender in detail. At thesame time, the acquisitions and borrower usually occupy, and I think of other Powers occupying far less favour-he inverted the usual position on this able. position in every way may serve to show occasion. We did not make the proposal to the absurdity of hesitating to protect our Ghina, it. was China that proposed to us that interests locally from fear' of embroilment we should guarantee the loan. The proposal with China asa whole, There is no Chines was received, I observe, with the groatest en-Empire in the European senso of the word. thusiasm in this country, an enthusiasm to There & only a congeries of provinces which there was no echo in my own mi occupied by Chinese over whom Pekiog (laughter}—for I felt the greatest hesitation has no control worth mentioning, but. who About the proposal, not because Twas in can be readily coerced by any Power that doubt whether it was worth our while -to insiste upon its rights or chooses to create make a small contribution to the necessities righto to be insisted upon. Pablic opinion in of China, but because I rather dreaded this country having been fairly roused to the entering upon the path of finding money importance of enforcing rights which we have for a Government that might want money. possessed under treaty, for more than China is not the only Government in the generation, it may be hoped that the matter world that might want money—(laughtor)—will not again be allowed to drop into obli and I should be sorry if we encouraged d Ifour Chinese trade is to be extended or even mands which, of course, we might not be able maintained our Chinese policy must be to deal with, and by which we might be mated by " very different spirit from that embarrassed.' However, we came to the con-which has been the despair of our merchants clusion—I think it was a right one—t for several decades. But the change will not intimate to the Chinese that we should make be effected and maintained except by continu-the advance on very favourable terms, only ous pressure of public opinion in favour of that in consideration of the sundry embarrass energetic insistence upon treaty rights. ments and objections there might be we should require certain concessions from Chins It would not be a bad thing if our native in return, But I am not going through the contemporaries would transiste the above Proposals, the negotiations are not concluded, extract for the benefit of their fellow-and it would not be right for me to do so. countrymen who read, and who are in-But I may say this, those concessions were terested in the way they are governed. without exception directed to the object of The following is the Far East section of Increasing and freeing the trade with China, Lord Salisbury's reply to Lord Kimberley and none of them contained "nything injurious in the House of Lords in the discussion on to China herself. Then the noble lord glanced at the legend of Talienwan; it is a very the Address curious legend. What happened in respect Lord Salisbury said: The noble earl said to Talienwan was this, it was mentioned that, beesuse the Chancellor of the Exchequer, in dealing with certain speculations show with: other-treaty.ports by Sir Claude donald, with our approval, to the Chine:

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account