The Archive · 1898

Gay Dan Bank

"The hearing of this case was resumed, Mr. J. ©. Hanson (Messrs. Dowdall and Hanson) appearing for the plaintifis, and Mrs if, P. Wilkinson, Crown Advocate, for the defendants. 2 Upon resuming, Mr. Wilkinson proceed-ea to sum up for the defendants. In traversing the evidence the learned counsel referred to the evidence given by the compradore of the National Bank as to the separate accounts kept" by him. These books had been produced in Court, and the defendants had also produced their books, of which there was only one set, and a very full investigation of these accounts had been made by permission of the Court, which investigation had been checked by clerks in the employ of the defendants. Counsel contended that the compradore's books agreed with those of the National Bank, and that of itself ought to be sufficient to dispose of the case. would be remembered that in the evidence given by the witnesses for the plaintiffs un-dor cross-examination they failed to explain why the English accounts, which agreed with the Chinese books kept by the compradore, did not bear out the details of the orders sued on by the Bank of China, The defendants had produced only one set of books, which they had had expert evidence to- say were properly kept. They had Mr. Hanson's opening speech and the evidence of the witnesses for the plaintiffs as to what the ordinary course of king business was. Mr. Hanson said that when native banks do business with foreign banks they give the security of their chops, payable to bearer, but there had not been the slightest attempt to prove that these chops had not been brought to the National Bank. They had the evidence of Mr. Stewart to show what was the usual course of business when loan transactions took place between native and foreign banks, viz., that the application was made to the compradore, translated by him and taken to the manager for his approval.

The National Bank had been unable through its foreign staff, and had refused to prove through its native staff, on what particular day any bank order was brought to them and counsel challenged them to say when these bank orders came into their possession. Counsel referred to the evidence of the shroff as to the numbers of the notes being kept and said that in this case the numbers did not appear in the National Bank's accounts nor in the Chinese books, but they did appear in the comprador uvate books, which were his real accounts.

un sel referred to the fact that he had called another banker who said he had never known of a fresh: loan ie made on the security of a bank order which had previously been held. That was the usual course of banking business here. The orders sued upon had been kept in the National's Bank's safe, contrary to the usual course of business, for six months. With regard to interest and payment of interest he (counsel) bad asked for the production of anything written by the Gay Dah Bank relating to it and the National Bank had been unable to do so. The compiadure had produced certain interest memos which did not agree with the Books of the National Bank or with the loan; these memos were written by his own staff, and he had nothing at all written by the Gay Dah Bank. The petition stated that the bank orders were presented for payment, but were dishonoured. It appeared that the National Bank made no attempt at collection, except through the compradore and they took his word for what happened, but as to that they had no evidence. They had then apparently sat down and done nothing in the matter for three months. No English Court would listen to the plaintiffs when they relied on accounts like these, that were utterly Th hopeless as referring to these bank orders. Ho (counsel) contended that the National Bank had not carried on this business bank as it should be carried on. They lent this money. in the first place fo the compradore and did not care to whom he passed it on. They had contended that they had a compradore agreement making the compradore liable for all Chinese paper, but the fact that the compradore received a commission of one par cent rather spoilt the plea that in'this case they were dealing direct with natives. So great was the faith reposed in the compradore by Mr. Thorburo that the latter did not know he was a native banker, but they had had direct evidence, that he was manager of the Ching Woo Bank. The point that he (counsel) would probably have to meet. was that the National Bank, having failed to prove that the orders came into their hands in the ordinary course of business, would say that the orders were payable in any event. On that point he should not argue, as he (counsel) took it that the Chinese law was reasonable and right on the subject. If the foreign banks here chosa to deal with native documents they had two courses open to them. One was to ascertain for themselves the customs of. native banking business and the other was to transact this business through their compradore, who was under a guarantee. The National Bank had chosen the latter meind if this had been the usual course mess here his learned friend (Mr. Hanson) would have been able to produce other bank managers to testify to it. The native bankers knew the position of the compradores and they dealt with them as one Chivese banker with another, and in a case of this hind they, expected the protection of the Court, as far as it could be given. It would live been impossible as between one banker and another to keep these notes for months, and it would have been impossible for them to have been presented for payment—they would not have been honoured if they had been presented and the compradore, knowing this, did not present them, In conclusion, the learned counsel said he hoped the National Bank would withdraw their moral support from the compradore and allow him to be dealt with according to Chinese law.

Mr. Hanson, in summing up for the plaintiffs, said' that Mr. Wilkinson had made some criticisms on' the compradore's hooks, but these books had nothing to do with the case as far the plaintiffs were concerned. When the Gay Dah bank went on with its case against the National Bank's compradore, then they would but not until then, Mr. Wi said they had done nothing for six months, but he (counsel) would refer to Mr. Thorburn's evidence to show that that assertion was wrong. Although this case was a very important one, it was a very simple one—a simple case of contract. The National Bank's case was that by these notes the Gay Dah bank had contracted to pay bearer on demand and had refused to pay the National Bank, who were the holders of these notes. The question for the Court, was is the Gay Dah bank to be ordered to carry out its contract, and if not, why not. The first point was were these notes genuine ones. That, however, was admitted. The next point was, what was the contract shown by the notes. The notes spoke for themselves. Mr. Wilkins son in his opening speech said that thr notes were the nearest approach to ae que known in Chinese law; but t-45 ture different in that ina cheque "46 hame of the person to whom thy "yore given was entered on the cher ne" Tm these do-cements no name Ww", optered—they were simply orders p2y@" 10 to hearer on demand. By putting the', chop on these notes the bank of issu", suarantoed to pay bearer the value. Tye next point was did the National Bank vive value for the notes in good faith? Ths evidence and the bank's books showed hat they did give value for the notes. Even if the notes had been taken to the rik by someone who found them in the street they would have been entitled to recover the value of these notes from the Gay Dah bank. They. did not, however, come into the Bank's possession in that way, but in the ordinary way of business, viz. through the compradore, When business of this sort was dono it was transacted through the compradores, and in most eases compradores had to give their foreign employers certain guarantees and there was in this a guarantee of this sort. But if foreigners entered into contracts with Chinese it made no difference to their contracts whether they had an

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account