Shanghai, 6th August. Before Taotai Tsar Cniix, President of the Bureau of Foreign Affairs at Nanking, and Sir Nicnotas J. Hassex, H.B.IL's Consul-General.
Bexserz v. Tue Kraxcxas Devesce axp Pay DEPARTMEst.
This was a resumed sitting of a Court constituted under the provisions of Article 17 of the Tientsin 'Treaty of 1858 and Section 2, Sub-section 3, of the. Chefoo Convention 1876, to enquire into the claim by Messrs. Bennertz and Ca. against the Kiangnan Defence and Pay Department. "The "proceedings now take' place at: the 'route Canton Guild, Ningpo Rosd.
Mr. H.'P." Wilkinson, with- whom was Mr. E. Nelson (Messrs Johnson,: Stokes and Master), appeared for the plaintiffs, and Me WY Disuamond for the defendants.
'Wong' Yung-ching, accountant in the employ of the plaintifis, was' called "aid efondatta'on acecune of cbattat which. bore 'Mr. Chis' chop' on' pages.: The conipradore orders upon the payments were made had been already luced in Court, and they were correct.
en the ships were stopped there was. a good deal: of trouble with' passengers, and some ten or twenty hongs.
'Kiang Pah-un said that' after' entering the service of the plaintiffs as compradore he went td' see 'Chu for the purpose of becoming acquainted with him.' Witsess had advanced Tls. 21,000 odd on account of ren them credit 9,000 received ay freight, but,'as'a matter of fact, he only received Tls. 4,000 cash, as the shippers, in conseqtience of the -delay'of the steamers, declined balance. When the steamers were detain-there was further trouble." Up to" the time the TWooning broke down the, business leamern was vety'good.
son said ho was prepared to call a witness from Messrs. Jardine, Mat perhaps Mr, Drummond would Mr. Drummond said he was not prepaied to admit that the business was good business. Pint) Me. Willeinson aid it Would, porhips; be sufficient to rely upon the accounts.
Charles William Groske was ro-called and cross-examined by Mr. Drummond, He said that immediately prior to being engaged asisocond engineer on the Kiangning he was inthe Shanghai Police. "Hevhad never had a certificate, but had served in several German and South: American ships' og an engineer; he had served four years in' the 'Vulcan' Works, at Stettin,' and had worked in English engineering shops. Ho could do anything an angieer might require of hin.
examined by Mr. Wilkinéon, the witness said that with the exception of the time he was in the Shanghai Police he had been. all his lifo.in engineering: He had put the engines of-the Kiangning in such a state that she, could now leave any day.
'Wong Yung-ching -was., re-called, and question.by Mr. Drummond' upon the manner in which, the Chinese account book was prepared, and. the chopping of certain pages by Mr. Chu. He did not. know the reason Mr. Chu chopped the pages...
Kiang Pub-un, re: and. cross-examined by Mr. Drummond, said that as: far as his recollection went the first advance he made on account of the firm was in: May, 1896, and the Jastin August.... During that period he found all.the capital for. running firm ho was guaranteed by Mr. Chu, so, that the firm. On. entering: the service of the if he had made any default Mr. Chu, would have been responsible. The reason. Mr. Chu gave the. guarantee for. Tls. 10,000 to witness was that witness found the undertaking he had entered into was a bigger thing than he could do single-handed. witness: had committed default: up, to'tho sum.of Tls.. 10,000, Mr. Chu would have had to, make it good to. Bennertz & Ca. Further questioned, upon' the, matter. of the guarantee it appeared that Mr. Chu guaranteed the witness against loss to the extent of 'Tls. 10,000,' so that if he'should not be'able'to recover from Bennertz & Ca. he would: hold Mr. Chu responsible: Mr, Chu,'*in fact, guaranteed' Bennertz'& Ca. to witness' and'witness to Bennertz'& Ca.
At this stage the Court rose for the day. I ath August, *Upoii the' Court' asteimbling,'
Chiang Poh-yung: thi i ie compra plaints, was further cleatly arrdblged that Chiang it has' hi Peh-yung; in
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.