The Eastern World publishes the following article on the question of the arrest at Hakodate of a number of Chinese, who were cooks on board a British man-of-war.
We know by a telegram from Hakodate that these men have been sentenced by the Japanese authorities to 15 days imprisonment and a fine of yen 2.50, but it ives not follow that that proceeding closes the whole question The principal but remediable cause of international questions is undoubtedly ix. nor ance of international law, and international law is a very difficult science, especially as both sides in international questions frequently have national prejudices or an unproportionately large sense of their national importance. which obscures sober and dispassionate judgment. To therefore, from the Japanese police authori. ties, or front those who may come into conflict with them, an infallible judgment in international difficulties would be'to expect the impossible, and it will-be especially difficult to impress upon the former the fact that in some cases aliens may commit offences in Japan against Japanese laws which are not offences in the countries to which those aliens may belong. We do not dispute for a moment that this isa fave to be borne ior a while yet, and any-grievance, but it is a grievance that will how, offences of that kind can never be of a character to threaten the safety of life and property.
A case in point that will serve to illustrate a very simple and universally recognised principle of international law happened on the 19th inst. in Hakodate.
On that day a number of Chinese who were gambling in a Chinese house in Hakodate wore arrested and sent to the local Court, but five of them happened to be cooks serving on board of a British man-of-war. 'The matter was reported to the British Legation and a demand for the immediate release of these Chinese was made, as they were not under Japanese jurisdiction as Jong as they were in British' service. The Dynes, for Foreign Affairs is reported to have replied that although the alle; offenders belonged to the British navy they wore Chinese by nationality, and therefore under Japanese jurisdiction. allegiance of the Chinese cooks in question As regards the political nationality and the Department ig right, but in this case that has nothing to do with the forwn before which their case, if a case lies against them, is justiciable. A ship at seals ied in of the nation whose flag she carries, and as international law as is portion: of the territory subject to that nation's jurisdiction (Crape Kelly, 16 Wallace 610), and under the present trestles that refers to all foreign ships in Japanese waters and harbours also. A vessel at sea, as a part of the territory to which it belongs at home, also carries with it the local legal rights and legal jurisdiction of such locality, and which is the point to be considered, "all on board are endowed and subject accordingly. Swaine, J.; Wilson v. Macnamee 102 U'S., 574; S. P., Maclachlan, Merch. Ship., 3rd ed. 64,65,140) To public vessels these maxims poly with still greater force, as such vessels stand on higher ground, for "They are not only public property, built or bought by the Government, but they are, as it were, floating barracks, a part of the public ergonism, and represent the national ignify, and on these accounts even in foreign ports, are exempt from. the jurisdiction. In both cases, (private vessels were referred to first) however, it is on account of the crew, rather than of the ship itself, that they have any territorial quality. Take' the crew away, let the abandoned and spotting more, (Woolsey, Int. Late, hulk be met at sea; it now becomes proper This, we think, very clearly. covers the case under consideration and shows that the nationality of the ship determines that of j the crew as long as the crew is under the ship's flag. But there is still more material to prove the correctness of this position. It a despatch of June 3rd, 1881, to Thornton; Mr. Blaine, Sec, of State 1 "When a foreigner enters the mercantile marine of any nation and becomes one of the crew of a vessel having undoubtedly ational character, he assumes a temporary allegiance to the flag under which he serves, and in return for the protection
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.