The Archive · 1898

The French Mail Papers

(ror THE WeeK ENDING THE Grit OF May.)

"Dirtomaricus," who is by no means a permanently unkind critic of Lord Salis-jury, suns up the situation very neatly in the May issue of the Fortnightly Reviere:—Our old China policy has broken down, and a new and disastrous one has been sub: stituted for it, and the Government has no one to blame but itself. Thatit has obtained some valuable concessions from China, calculated to promote an expansion of our trade—notably the opening of the inland waters—I do not deny; but none of then are incompatible with the partition policy upon which it has entered, and from which it will not easily extricate itself, ind none of them offer advantages which seem likely to outweigh the perils of the new policy. It is possible that these perils are exaggerated, that China may yet shake herself together, may organise her vast resources and become once more powerful Empire, in which case Port Arthur may remain a Far Eastern Gibraltar, and Kinochou become a sort of Chinese Pondicherry. Possible, indeed! But it is not on such sporting chances that practical policies can be framed."

The Times of the 30th of April publishes theKiaochou Convention between Germany and China as summarised by its Berlin correspondent. He adds in his dispatch, which is dated the 29th of Apri The above agreement was described to-d: in the Budget Committee by Herr von Bale as the first part of the whole German treaty. with China, The second and third parts he also communicated to the Committee, but described them as strictly confidential d cements, for to the commercial an us made by China to Germany in the province of Shan-tung. In requesting that they should be treated as confidential, the Foreign Secretary pointed out that England, Russia, and France had lik wise refrained from publishing their new commercial agreements with China,. Refe ring to the statements of the English Bluchook concerning Weihaiwei, Herr von Bulow said that the German Government. only became officially acquainted with the Anglo-Chinese agreement on this subject by means of Mr. Balfour's statement in the House of Commons. But the English Government had spontaneously communicated its intention of respecting German interests. It was evident that the centre of English interests was rather in the Yangtze valley thay in the North. Just as Hongkong lay near the French sphere "of action, so England, in requiring Weihaiwei, had' moved into proximity to the Russian sphere, Weihaiwei was a window which England had established looking out on the Gulf of Pechili, just like that which Russia possessed at' Port Arthur. "Germany had no objection if both Powers contemplated the play of the waves in the gulf from these windows of theirs. As to the question whether this might one day lead to friction between England and Russia, no ove could venture effectual steps for carrying it out, they will on predictions. The German Government have no cause to complain that the public sincerely hoped that it would not lead to do not trast them. But they must show friction. The German Empire did not in any that they realise the extent and the great-way feel itself incommoded by the Russian ness of the burden they bear. There is an sphere of power in Northern China, having ahvays recognised those regions as being the partial failure of the late negotiation, and uneasy feeling in the public mind that the

Rassian sphere." He hoped that the period of surprises and of excitement for China was the weakness displayed more especially during the earlier stages, are attributable at closed. It might be expected that all the least in some degree to the attempt of Lord Powers would now peacefully devote them.

Salisbury to discharge the double duties of selves to the cultivation and development of Premier and of Foreign Secretary. The the concessions which they had obtained. condition of his health has so greatly im-It was hoped that the requisite naval works and yards at Kiaochou would be established proved that, he will Ue able to reten to don and to resume work to-day or by private enterprise. The Admiralty would to-morrow. The satisfaction caused by this then give the private firms their orders for announcement is general and sincere. But repairs. It was not intended to construct unquestionably it would be increased if he fortifications, but_ merely to develop and proposed, as unfortunately he does not pro-maintain the existing Chinese coast defences. pose, to confine himself in future to his With regard to the commercial development sufficiently onerous duties as head of the of Shantung, Herr von Biilow intimated that Government. offers for the construction of railways had been received from syndicates as well as from The Pall Mall of the same date says individual contractors. Similar offers had The exceeding cleverness of Mr. Balfour's been sent in with respect to the working of speech last night receives its due recognition mines and other industrial enterprises. No in this morning's papers. It seems almost decision had yet been taken with regard to unkind, therefore, to express a doubt if he these offers. Where they were serious the parties would be made acquainted with the had the Opposition organised their attack would "have fared quite so. prosperous

provisions of the Shantung commercial treaty differently. He had only to deal with Sir with China, which had arrived yesterday.

William "Harcourt, ponderous, Blue-booky, The question how far the firms and companies and placed in the painful situation of which intended to initiate industrial and Little Englander attempting to play the commercial enterprises in Shantung should Jingo. By far the most effective speech i Lear the cost of the harbour and other works the night's debate, that of Sir Edward Gi at Kiaochou was receiving careful considera-was kept back far too late for party effec: tion. tiveness. Mr. Balfour, accordingly, manufac-'The London papers criticise very fully tured at least a personal success out of what the too great defences made by the Gov-looked like becoming a general Ministerial ernment in the week whose papers are collapse, But to accept every item of his i before us; Mr, Balfour's, on the 29th of genious defence of the Foreign Office at April in the Commons, and Lord Salis-own valuation requires more mental i genuity than lies at the disposal of that, per-bury's on the Sth of May at the Albert son whom the Zines calls the plain man, To Hall. In reference to the former the most of us the diplomatic tussle between Times says Great Britain and Russia seems to have re-{t seems to be a point of honour in our sembled a trial of wits between the respect-Parliamentary system that Ministers ought able family solicitor and a police-court never to betray the smallest consciousness attorney. "The former has his professional that their policy has failed to achieve trium-traditions; his stock of honesty. The latter phant success." Perhaps the theory is an <well, he is a police-court attorney. inevitable result of party goveroment. The The best policy at the command of: the action of an Administration necessarily com-respectable solicitor would naturally be mits their followers, and the natural feeling to give his opponent free scope for his of: loyalty to those followers forces the rascality until the moment came for his Cabinet to make the best of the consequences exposure. That is the conduct which we whether in fact they have proved to be for-ventured to attribute to the Foreign Office tunate or the reverse. The defence which the other day—tho procedure of paying out Mr. Balfour made last night of the conduct rope. To a certain extent Mr. Balfour of our affairs in the Far East was unquestionadopted that explanation last night, for in ably able, but probably there are few who that sense we read his mild allusion to the have followed the recent course of eve distrust and bitterness which Russia has to whom it will carry complete conviction brought upon herself. A mere admission, There is little or nothing in it to show he however, that the British Government had realises that we have suitored any injury in been outdone because it had not condescond-China at all—still less that such injury has ed to the devices of Count Muravieff and on the part of out responsible rulers. been due to any want of foresight or of energy M. de Staal, was rejected by Mr. Balfour fe 'as prosaically tame.

He sot himself to admits, indeed, that we have learnt a lesson prove that the Foreign Office had through-—a lesion aS to the worth of Russian out been alert, sceptical of Russian promises, assurances when Russian assurances conflict able to appreciate Russian performance. with Russian interests—Lut that is a lesson Ho oven attempted to explain away the which men_ of ordinary prudence, not to deplorable withdrawal of our ships from speak of trained statesmen and diplomatists, Port Arthur when the future of that arsenal ought not to have required. But the general was still undecided. It. was only the Ad-tenour of his speech is that we have reason mical or only the Admiralty—we are not to congratulate ourselves on the happy out-Gout, Muravieff took care to instruct, the nite sure which. The fact remains that come of the er Mr. Balfour's animadversions on the cri Tsungli Yamen that it was a good deal more oisins made upon the Government do not than the Admiral or Admiralty, and Sir strike us as being either quite worthy of Claude Macdonald, in consequence, lost a himself or deserved by those to whom he very critical trick: No3 this effort to con-addressed them. No doubt a democracy vert a eeries of diplomatic retirements into like this country stands at a disadvanta deliberately planned advance is too alurmage in some respects in diplomacy as in ingly adroit for the ordinary-sized cranium other matters as compared with a military to take monarchy like Germany or an autocracy We could fill our columns with these like Russia. But the British system has criticisms on Mr. Balfour's speech, but ite merits as well as its defects, and at all we have only room for two more, one from ents it cannot be changed, as Mr. Balfour himself hastened to own. Ministers of all a Conservative paper, the Morning Post, parties must take it as they find it, and do the other from a Radical paper, the Daily Chronicle. 'The former says the best with it they can. 'They may' usually rely, as the history of this oe crisis has Mr. Balfour's speech gives a blow to his shown, upon the generous forbearance both of own reputation, He declared that he thought the Press and of the Opposition where the inthe position of Great Britain in the Far East terests of the natieaare known to be at stake. improved by the events of the last six months. If this Government, or any Government, Tt would be hard to find a man outside the give the country reason to believe that they Cabinet who shares that opinion. But Mr. Know their own minds, that they have a clear Balfour made a much more remarkable state-and well-considered plan of action for the ment. After a discussion of the departure of future, and that they mean to take prompt and j the British ships of war from Port Arthur

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account