Ws have already published a letter protesting against the closing to wheeled traffic of the road' from' the carriage shed by the Swimming Bath to' the Recreation Club's Ground; and in the Municipal Council's minutes published this morning will be found the corres-Ehanghai Recreation. Clab and. the pondence on the subject between the
Council, The Recreation Club, it will be seen, wrote on the 29th ult., protesting strongly against the closing of the Road, and it does seem at first sight injustice, that while the members of the Swimming Bath Club, the Golf Club, and the Cricket Club can drive almost up to their respective doors or gate when the sun is oppressively hot, or the ground has not yet dried after rain, the privilege that the members of the Recreation Club had of driving up to their gate should be taken away. The honorary secretary of the Recreation Club points out that his members paid for the making of the rond now closed to wheeled traffic, and that it was especially made to enable them to ride in carriages or jinricsha to their gate. He points out that there are two hundred members in the Recreation Club, and that they are therefore entitled to the fullest consideration, and he asks the Council to reconsider its decision. He might have pointed out that the general public is interested as well as the members of the Club, as the Club's ground is always thrown open to the public whenever any interesting watch is being played, or Sports, ete., are tuking place.
The reply of the Council is dated the 4th of August. Mr. Bland shows that the Public Recreation Ground is a very different place from the wild common given over to ponies and rooks, and snipe in their season, which the Council took over four years ago. A great deal of time and money has been cheerfully spent in making it "a place for general recreation fur the entire foreign community of Shanghai, in accordance with the terms of the original rust, and it is impossible that any privileges conflicting with the interests of the general public should be conceded therein to any Club or private institution." The transformation that has been mucus four years is really marvellous. Cricket, polo, and tennis are played on this former common and swamp, dotted with grave mounds, every fine afternoon, and on a fine Saturday afternoon, the visitor may find ju full swing on it a baseball game, two cricket matches, tennis on the girls' ground, tenuis on the Germans ground, and. polo, while the baud is playing, cricket matches are proceeding on the Cricket Club's ground and the Recreation Club's ground, and the! sound of much splashing comes from the Swiinming Bath. Bicyelists are wheeling merrily round the bicycle path, small boys are playing immature cricket, small girls are playing rounders, and amahs are letting smaller children tumble about while they themselves sentations that have been made over and over again, parents, allow their children to be taken by their amahs. to [the dangerous corner' by the band; stand, where some child is sure to be killed or injured_sooner or later by a eritket ball, when a match is being played on the pitch opposite the Grad Stand. There is more real danger from discuss the failings of their masters' this than from carriages driving round and mistresses. It is, according to the Council, the large number of pedestrians, cyclists, and children who make use of the metalled road between the Swimming Bath and the Recrea-! tion Club's gate, that has rendered the continued use of that road; to the Recreation Club's gate.
'There is another solution possible to j this question, and that is, to make a separate path for bicyclists and pedestrians and children, from the Swimming Bath to the Recreation Club's gate, and allow cartiuges and' jinrieshas to for wheeled traffic undesirable; and they go on to say that "it must also be evident that if permitted as far as the Recreation Club, similar privileges might reasonably be claimed beyond that point (is the Recreation Club a point?), and the public would eventually be put to serious inconvenience." 'The Council accordingly ask the Recreation' Club to reconsider its protest, and offer " to refund to the Recreation Olub whatever amount may have been expended upon making the pathway before control of the same was handed over to the Municipality." This is the least the Council could do, but this offer cannot obviously be regarded as a complete satisfaction for the privilege now withdrawn, The Conncil wind up by saying " that the new Regulations will come into force on and after Saturday next," and: they are now in force, We have heard it remarked, in discussions on this new Regulation, that if it had-been the Cricket Club or the Swimming Bath that had been affected by it, instead of the Recreation Club, it would never have been made, but we do not think there is any weight in this argument. It so happens that the road which lends from the Bubbling Well Road into the Public Recreation Ground does exactly serve the Cricket Club (which it was originally made to serve) and the Swimming Bath, but it also serves as far as it goes the Recreation Club, and as half a loaf is better than no bread, a road as far as the Swimming Bath is better than no road at all, The Public Recreation Ground is administered by a representative committee of which the President of the Recreation Club is a member, and when the community can get a representative honorary committee to undertake a task like this as a labour of love, it should cheerfully support their decisions. Their object is to do whyt, ig best for the public as.a whole claims of partigif¥rtg2_much to the they having made up their minds ova! this Regulation is necessary in the general interest, we trust that the Recreation Club, although the privilege that they have lost was a valuable one, will on reconsideration accept it in the spirit in which ie was made, Itisa great pity that, notwithstanding the repre-inno to use the present road, There is plenty of room for it, and the only question is the' expense, but then the money tint the Council propose to refund to the Recreation Club might be used for this purpose, and the policemen now used to keep wheeled traffic off the existing road might be used to make amahs keep the children in their charge off it, This suggestion, which has been already made, is worth consideration,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.