The Archive · 1893

CONTEMPORARY ENGLISH

paper the other day, upon 1 proposed emi-In the leading article of a Yokohama

gration to some possible sugar plantations, occurred the following sentence: The profits to be derived from the work and analy interesting particulars about it, were set forth in an admirably clear, well con posed letter which appeared in the columns of The Times last January.", Forty-eight consecutive lines of this admirably clear, ly well composed letter" are afterward quoted in the article san ally to its own argument. The letter is certainly striking enough to warrant comment, not on its own merits but as the object of editorial admiration. As a simple epistle it might be allowed to sink undelayed into oblivion; as one belauded of journalism t demands amore public funeral.

With the merits or demerits of the scheme we are not concerned, though on general philanthropic principles we would it were defended from its friends, for the letter where carefully read seems a highly dissunsive encomium on what it fain would puff.

feeling in the matter. We would simply Nor ave we situated by any individual draw attention to what enormities, in spite of common school education, can still be connnitted in our midst. We are quite willing that principal and accessories in this murder of our mother tongue should escape. We will even point out how they may. The Times, since it published the letter as a letter, can plead the usual disclaimer of responsibility wisely printed as caption in such cases; the writer of the leading article may allege that what won admiration was the portion of the letter omitted to quote; while the letter-write himself, if discovered, shall claim that it was only a letter after all.

Having thus connived' ut the escape of the criminals we proceed with stern con science to fall upon the crime, We reproduce the text entire in italics; our comments: we insert in Roman type.

Tt seems inevitable that the wealth which sugar settlement can develop will come soon ty be @ matter of general recognition.—Tt also seems probable that the sense this sentence can develop will come soon to be wnatter of general recognition, but not instantly. A moment is needed to take in all the words. A moment for each reader, if the sentence be widely read, meaus'a very appreciable loss of time for the human "race. But the bungle here is nothing to the blunder. Why does the writer speak of the recognition, which it is his object to bring about, as seeming meritable, that is, a thing which cannot be ied!' Why in the name of consistency, to sty naught of common sense, should he wish to avoid what he is trying to effect Does he think to take in a simple public himself? If so, why forewarn The astute reader instantly views the scheme with a shade of distrust. When it does, pluntutions must begin to multiply themsebees.—We like lifelike metaphor, but why select one that hints disastrously of rabbits and that too, with singular want of tact, about the very Jand. Australia, where the' phintations are tobe made! And the movement of expunsie) sturted—but the plantations were this instant spoken of as procreating their kind and now in the same breath they are referred to us gas! We sincerely trust that this is only the inflation of fancy, there ix no reason to assign any limit to it.—The plantations are becoming alarmingly more and more gaseous!—other than. that set by the requirements of the world's market.

other words, the demand will determine the supply, which is true but trite enough to be omitted in the account of an important novelty.—Nor can there be much question that' the. suecessful cultivation. of sugar carried on wnuler 'a system hich gives employment to so many hands and settles such a proportiowately large population, on the soil,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account