2nd June, Wien we wrote yesterday that the system of the Hongkong Government seemed to be to have high officials highly paid and allowed to be almost criminally inefficient, etc., we had before us the report of the recent Treasury Comuissou in Hongkong, signed by Mr. E. J. Ackroyd, the puisne judge, Mr. J. Thurdurn, the manager in Hongkong of the Chartered Bank, and Mr. S. G. Bird, merchant there. They were appointed to investigate the Alves defalcations, their instructions from the Colonial Secretary being to ascertain and report (a)—The amount of the defalcations. ()—By what person or persons they. have been committed, (c)—What other person or persons, if any, may by neglect of duty, or otherwise, have directly or indirectly contributed thereto, and The causes that rendered the defalcations possible, and those that prevented their earlier detection; also to advise what. steps should, in the opinion of the Commission, be taken in order, as far as possible, to prevent the recurrence of defalcations, and to ensure their prompt detection if committed.
The Commission had a troublesome and unpleasant task laid upon them, but a far from difficult one, for while it was a little difficult to fix the exact amount of the defalcations, owing to the disappearance of some of the account books, there was no difficulty in fixing on Alves as the criminal, and it was equally easy to show that the way had been made open to Alves by the gross neglect of his successive official superiors, neglect which, it will be seen, is not at all too strongly characterised as almost criminal inefficiency. Nor was there much difficulty in advising how the recurrence of such defalcations should be prevented; except in as far as it seems to be difficult for the Hongkong Government to obtain Treasurers and Auditors who know or will carry out their duties.
Making up the amounts as well as they can, the Commissioners find that Alves' total defalcations amounted to $62,818; of which he took apparently $29,480 in 1888 and 1889, $12,901 in 1890, $11,054 in 1891, and $9,383 in 1892. He was allowed to receive the Crown Rents from people coming to pay them, although properly the money had to be received by a shroff How simply he carried out his leftoa:
laily appointed for the purpose.
tions is thus explained by the Commission When money him he either— was sent or taken to (a) Paid it over to the shroff (b) Paid part of it to the shraf, taking with him the printed form of receipt in which appeared in figures the amount he paid over but in words at length the real amount which had been paid to him. The shroff could not read English but knew English figures, he compared the figures on the receipt with the money handed over to him, made an entry in his cash book, chopped the receipt and handed it back to Alves, who then made the figures agree with the other part of the receipt and gave or sent-it to the payer (c) Orelse he appropriated the whole amount sent to him and made out a receipt on a printed form of his own, which he must have had printed for the purpose, signed the name, and chopped it with a forged chop.
In the case (b) he made the counterfoil correspond with the amount handed by him to the shroff, and not with the amount paid to himself, In the Rent Roll he entered the full amount which he had received, while in his cash book (or Daily Collection book) he entered only the amount paid by him to the shroff.
In case (c) he made out no counterfoil nor entry in his cash book, but so far as we have been able to ascertain, he entered the amount in the Rent Roll as paid, thus affording ample proof of his fraud if this book had been added up and balanced as it should have been.
It is further noted that as Alves had to prepare the estimates, it was easy for him, by under-estimating the revenue, to abstract a considerable sum every year, and yet bring the receipts up to the estimates. 'I'his note might, we think, have been omitted, for Alves had nothing to do with making up the Rent Roll every half year, and he is hardly likely to have intentionally under-estimated the revenue, when the Rent Roll was there to confute him at any moment. For Alves' defalcations would have been instantly discovered if the 'I'reasurer or Auditor had insisted on the Rent Roll being balanced; for Alves did not tamper with this Roll, but conscientiously entered the proper amounts aa received, and it was simply the gross neglect of his superiors—first, in allowing him to receive money, and secondly, in not having the Rent Roll balanced, that enabled him to conceal and continue his misappropriations. Mr. F, Freire, "a clerk in the 'I'reasury Department, did complain to the late Mr. Lister, the then Treasurer, that the Rent Roll was not balanced, and was told by Mr. Lister to mind his own business; and Mr. Nicolle, the local Auditor, says that hie represented several times, in conversation only, not in writing, that the Rent Rolls ought to be balanced, but nothing came of his representations,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.