The Archive · 1893

An International Marine Court

Joh June, A proposition is now before the DiplomatiobodyinPeking forthe establishment of a Marine Court for the of cases connected with shipping in which vessels under the Chinese flag appear as defendants. It is pointed out that the mercantile navy under the Chinese flag is now of considerable extent, 8,246 vessels of foreign type, chiefly steamers, and 6,286 junks having entered and cleared at the Shanghai Custom House in 1892. These steamers under Chinese flag are not more subject to collisions and other accidents than those of any other nation, but such accidents must occur sometimes; and while if it is a foreign vessel that is in fault there are proper Courts to which the Chinese can resort for justice, there is no properly organised Court in which a vessel flying the Chinese flag can be sued. 'I'here have been several cases lately in which Chinese vessels have been the defendants, and it has been fortunate for the plaintifis that the Chinese owners have generally consented to arbitration. But arbitration has its disadvantages, and it is not always satisfactory to the exigencies of extraterritorial ¢jurisdiction, and it seems only fair that as the Chinese vessels when they are plain= tiffs enjoy the right of sueing in a competent Court, a similar right should be attainable by a foreign vessel, when it is a Chinese vessel that has to be.sued, The proposition was laid before the Consular body here last November, and we understand that a subcommittee was appointed to consider the question, but we do not learn that any decision was arrived at, except that the opinion of the committee of the Chamberof Commerce hereon the subject should be ascertained. The suggestion was accordingly laid before the Chamber of Commerce in March last, the which Chinese vessels which lite been proposer pointing out that the privi

run into by foreign vessels enjoy of being able to submit their case to a Court established for the purpose should be equally available to foreign vessels which have been run into by Chinese. The chairman of the Chamber of Commerce replied in April last that the principle as advocated met with the unanimous approval of the committee of the Chamber: " but before committing themselves to any decided. opinion on the question, the committee would like to know "Ist. How is it proposed that the Marine Courts should be constituted "2nd. What power the Courts would possess to enforce their decrees "3rd. Under what National Maritime Law they would be governed It is not easy to see to what the Chamber could have "committed" itself by giving, as it does, its approval to the principle suggested, it being obvious that it is not in the power of any individual in Shanghai, or even of the whole Consular body, to formulate and settle the regulations for the working of the proposed Courts. It could not be settled here how the Courts should be constituted, with what powers they should be invested, or under what maritime law they should be conducted, All these details must follow when the Chinese Government has been persuaded to consent to the principle. the next step, however, has since been taken in the reference of the matter by the Consular body here to the Diplomatic body at Peking; and in a despatch dated the 15th of May last, Colonel Denby, the doyen of the Diplomatic body, acknowledges the receipt of the relative despatch, but mentions that the question could not be immediately taken up owing to the absence from Peking of Mr. O'Conor, and to the desire of some of the Foreign Ministers to have time to investigate the question, and communicate' on the subject with their home governments. The question is therefore hung up in Peking for the present; and even if the Diplomatic body should succeed in getting the Tsungli Yamen to approve the principle of the scheme, it will no doubt be a long time before it will be put in operation.

As most of the Chinese merchant steamers afloat belong to the China Merchants' S. N. Ca., and that company has always shown itself ready to accept and abide by foreign arbitration when its vessels have been accused of being in fault, there does not seem to be at present any urgent necessity for the establishment of the. proposed Courts. But this company might at any moment for some reason or other decline to follow its own precedents, or injury might be done by some other vessel under the Chinese flag whose owner refused to accept. foreign. arbitration, and left the foreign owner of the injured vessel to what remedy he could get from the ordinary Chinese courts. It does not need much argument then to show that the present condition of affairs is unsatisfactory; and it would not be very difficult to constitute such a Court as is required, The Court of Consuls, with a Chinese colleague, if the Chinese Government cared to instruct the Taotai to sit with them, and a foreigner in the Chinese service, the Commissioner of Customs or the 1 Harbour-master as a nautical man, j would constitute a Court that would probably enjoy the confidence of all parties, the only fault in it being that with the addition of two nautical assessors, it would be rather a large bench. We could hardly, however, expect the Chinese to be satisfied with a single foreign judge as a rule: and it is probable that if a Chinese Marine Court is constituted, it will have to be an international one, Ihe great thing, however, is for the diplomatic body to get the Tsungli Yamen to give their approval to the principle. Fortunately, there is little narrow-minded conceit about the Chinese, such as would make them unwilling to leave to foreign judges such admiralty questions as have only come up in China in recent years, and of which their own officials have no practical experience. The China Merchants' 8. N. Ca. is itself under official control, but it readily agreed to leave the decision in the case of the Hushun's collision with the German steamer Peking to the arbitration of the Chief Justice of the British Supreme Court.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account